But for adults, not schoolkids.
Posted on 10/29/2005 11:30:59 AM PDT by cloud8
At least eight high-tech school districts throughout Oregon have begun using Palm, Inc. technology in their classroom curriculum as part of a broad handheld integration program, the mobile computing company announced Thursday.
The integration concept jumped off in 2001 when Palm unveiled its Palm Education Pioneer (PEP) program grant.
With funding from the grant, more than 100 schools nationwide implemented Palm handhelds, while a number of research hubs studied the effectiveness of the device in a classroom setting, according to a recent press release.
(Excerpt) Read more at foxnews.com ...
What exactly can they do on a Palm, except play Mine Sweeper, that they can't do with pencil and paper?
I agree. This smells like another educrat boondoggle.
I agree. I have a friend that keeps telling me that I need to buy a palm pilot. He can't tell me why though. I love "gadgets" if they are useful.
They can pass test messages to eachother with the infrared link. Or maybe even test answers!
The cheating potential is unlimited, the learning potential is dubious.
But for adults, not schoolkids.
I'll let you know just as soon as I figure out what I can do with the one I bought 6 months ago besides take it out and recharge the battery once a month. Obviously, according to the article, they're of more use to 7 year-olds than they are to 43 year-old professionals.
It appears from the article that they're not doing any academic work that they couldn't do with paper, pencils, and books. What else they're doing is the real interesting question :-).
The tablet is connected to a projector so that when the student uses the touch screen to highlight the map all the students will react. Students will be anxious to answer questions and be called to the front of the class to interact. Sounds like a powerful tool!
The ONLY "powerful tools" required in a classroom -- is a competent TEACHER..and disciplined students.
Sadly - those are the missing tools in most classrooms.
Semper Fi
Not to mention the fact that a Palm Pilot can hold dozens of ebooks at a time. So, instead of carrying around a ton of books in a backpack, they can carry even more info around in a handheld that weighs only a few ounces. I wish I had had my Tungsten T5 when I was in grade school, high school or college. I can't do with out it now.
Plus, there's the "cool" factor with kids. If you were raised on video games, which would you prefer to work with, books or handheld computers? I would expect that more kids would find it more fun to do their homework if it involves using a computer of any kind. My kids did, anyway.
That said, this is a public school system we're talking about and Teacher's Unions have demonstrated a singular talent for taking a good idea and turning it into a boodoggle. Here's hoping that doesn't happen here.
I use mine, with a folding keyboard, instead of a laptop at meetings.
My meeting notes are all organized, comprehensible, and electronically searchable.
I think, if used properly, PDAs can be a big addition to a classroom. The problem is that, if use of other computer technology in the classroom is any guide, it will be misused or unused if not implemented well.
Good start. I'm waiting for the additional bundling of MP3, Video, AM/FM, TV and naviation.
> While I love gadgets, I'm also a Luddite in some ways.
LOL Me too. I'm a minimalist Luddite--cheap *and* stubborn.
> For example, he might ask a student to point out the 13 colonies of Pre Revolutionary times [on the tablet PC]
As opposed to asking, Johnnie please come up to the map and point out the 13 colonies.
I've taught with a computer, and find it best when *I'm* the only one using it, and the students are paying attention rather than surfing the web and sending email.
> Sounds like a powerful tool!
It may be. For example, the whole class could interact instead of just one at a time. Or it may be an expensive gimmick. I look forward to hearing how the program worked out for your son-in-law.
How about
edubrat boondoggle
Oregon Ping
Please notify me via FReepmail if you would like to be added to or taken off the Oregon Ping List.
Must be hard to type an opus on that though, LOL! (My DH is a total Gadget Guy, too.)
As for the kids having these, it doesn't bother me that they're being given to the kids through a grant and not taxpayer dollars, but you can count on THAT being the next step. The grant will run out, the school district will think that each kid MUST have a Palm to "keep up" with those that went before and then the taxpayer will end up footing the bill for more of these things...ensuring a tidy profit from the original "grantor."
Nobody does nothin' for free.
Palm pilots are just about at the end of their rather brief product cycle, being replaced by cell phones and blackberries. The Palm OS is a good one apparently, but others know a lot more about that here than I. All I know is that I haven't seen a Palm in ages, and never got what good they were to begin with.
I guess that was what I was trying to say in my original post. Also, being a geezer, when I leave the office or home, I don't WANT to stay in touch with anyone. I finally got rid of my cellphone. (Great move for me.) It was becoming a pain in the ass. I don't consider my self so important that I need to be available and bothered by people 24/7. It's nice.
I've got a couple in a drawer... I run four businesses, but have never used them. I tried, but a legal pad, and a cedll phone are all I need.
The students will be focused on him, the lesson and the projected visuals. They'll still have paper textbooks, paper test papers and paper cuts!!!!
It seems a good Pythagorian foundation for the Socratic Method!
Our tax $$dollars$$ at work.
> I've got a couple in a drawer...
I'll give you 40 bucks for em :)
The single best use of the Palm is the scheduler feature. It beeps at you when you set it to remind you of something.
I have a memory that is way too good for some things, but poor for remembering routine stuff that has to be done every week. This is where the Palm helps me, with convenient nagging.
The second best feature is the Contacts feature. You can have a phone book in your pocket. Not just numbers but emails and addresses.
Also, I use an encryption password keeper that keeps track of the 200+ passwords that I and my boss have.
Finally, it can do anything a bigger computer can do. Just not as fast. You can get programs for anything from engineering to cooking.
Very handy. Very useful.
Actually, the wife lugs around an address book the size of Webster's Third, and I've about convinced her that she needs a Palm. When all this stuff is integrated...cell, PDA, music, camera, Internet...I might even get one myself.
As long as discipline doesn't start to suppress healthy curiousity.
It is not a PDA, of course, and a Blackberry, or similar phone, are easier to lug. But, I can't read the little screen well enough, as my 17" one...
Besides, I can watch (OR MAKE) DVD's as well...
You and me both. We're vacationing this weekend, it's our anniversary. We don't even own a cell phone (I have one for work that I only use when I'm on call. This morning I'm sitting in our room at the Shilo Inn at Bend, and all weekend the phone lines at this end of town have been out, so only way to get us would have been to send a messenger. But on the other hand, the motel's high speed internet connection has been out until this morning (and for some reason, I do like to have that available).
According to the article, that is exactly how it's going down in Eugene. The startup seems to have come from Palm, but subsequent years are presently being covered by "Uncle Sam".
Yep. Unless it's your Mother (and even then Dear Old Mom is STILL suspect) always look for the strings attached when something is given to you "for free." ;)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.