Posted on 11/14/2005 2:09:08 PM PST by Fiji Hill
http://www.townhall.com/phillysoc/bartlettpaper.htm
Philadelphia singer Dick Flood also charted with this song, taking it to number 23 in September 1959.Conservative Pop Music-- The Top 40 of the Top 40
Bruce BartlettFull Text of Speech to be given at The Philadelphia Society
Regional Meeting in Cleveland, Ohio, September 21, 2002.
Pop music is probably one of the last places a conservative would normally look for reinforcement of his worldview. Rock and roll, which has dominated pop music since the 1950s, is inexorably associated with liberalism in the minds of many conservatives. But in fact, there have been a significant number of songs on the pop charts during the rock era that are explicitly conservative. I have compiled a list of these conservative classics.Before listing my top selections, I should explain the criteria on which I based my choices. First, I based them solely on the conservatism of the lyrics. A song had to have an explicitly conservative theme, although just a single line may represent it. I looked particularly for those embodying religious or patriotic themes, as these are unambiguously conservative values.
Second, I paid no attention to the politics of the performer. There are a number of good conservatives, such as Ted Nugent and even Walter Brennan, who have had hit songs over the years. But unless their songs had an explicitly conservative theme, I did not include them. Conversely, if some outspoken liberal recorded a song with explicitly conservative lyrics, I still included it.
Third, I limited myself to songs that made Billboards Top 40 chart after 1955. I relied heavily on the latest edition of Joel Whitburns book, Top 40 Hits. I did this in order to limit the universe of potential songs to a manageable number. Also, I think it is more telling if a conservative song had broad popularity, as indicated by sales, than if it is buried on some obscure album. Unfortunately, this rule forced me to leave out my personal favorite conservative rock song, Taxman by The Beatles (well covered by Stevie Ray Vaughn). I also had to exclude Ray Charles wonderful version of America the Beautiful.
It should be noted up front that the Top 40 list, while dominated by rock, is not exclusively made up of rock songs. It has always included so-called crossover hits from the country, blues and other best-seller lists. A number of songs on my list are of this nature. My position is that if they made the Top 40 list, they can be considered, regardless of where they came from. But if a song made, say, only the country chart and not the pop chart, it was not considered. This forced exclusion of some favorites, especially Merle Haggards Okie from Muskogee, quite possibly the most right-wing song ever recorded by a major artist.
Having explained my selection criteria, following is my list of conservative classics from the rock era, in alphabetical order by artist.
1. Paul Anka, (Youre) Having My Baby
This is a remarkable song by an extremely prolific singer and songwriter. It reached number 1 in July 1974, and stayed there for 3 weeks. What is remarkable about this song is its explicit pro-life message. In praising his wife for having his baby, Anka sings:Didnt have to keep it,br> Wouldnt put ya through itConsidering that Roe v. Wade had already been decided by the Supreme Court, and that being pro-choice had already established itself as liberal dogma, it was very courageous for Anka to put such a line in one of his own songs. The fact that the song was a massive hit also tells us something important about what most Americans really think about abortion. I can think of no similarly pro-choice song ever to make the charts.
You could have swept it from your life
But you wouldnt do it
No, you wouldnt do itAnother pro-life song by a popular rock group is Unborn Child by Seals & Crofts. Prolific hit makers in the 1970s, this 1974 song, which did not make the pop chart, is very hard-core in denouncing abortion. The following lyrics are indicative:
Oh unborn child, if you only knew what your momma was plannin' to doEven more hard-core is Bodies by the 1970s Punk group Sex Pistols, from their 1977 album Never Mind the Bollocks. In extremely graphic terms, they denounce a girl named Pauline, who killed her baby. The refrain throughout is the voice of the fetus:: Im not an animal, Mummy, Im not an abortion. (See also Madonna, below.)
Youre still a-clingin to the tree of life, but soon youll be cut off before you get ripe
Oh unborn child, beginning to grow inside your momma, but Youll never know
Oh tiny bud, that grows in the womb, only to be crushed
before you can bloom
2. The Beatles, Revolution
I remember when I was in college, Young Americans for Freedom had a poster printed with the lyrics of this song on it. The reason is that it is fundamentally anti-revolution. At a time when rebellious youth around the world were shutting down college campuses with often-violent demonstrations, it is surprising that John Lennon and Paul McCartney would write lines like these:We all want to change the worldRevolution reached number 12 in September 1968, and stayed on the chart for 11 weeks.
But when you talk about destruction
Dont you know you can count me out3. Chuck Berry and Linda Ronstadt, Back In the U.S.A.
This song was not a duet, but the same song that charted for Berry in 1959 and Ronstadt in 1978. She had the bigger hit with it, reaching number 16 and staying on the chart for 8 weeks. Berrys original just barely cracked the chart at number 37 and was there for just one week. I included this song because Berry is a rock icon and because I like it a lot. It is patriotic in a very old-fashioned sense, celebrating his return to the U.S. from an overseas trip. It is hard to imagine a black musician writing words like these today: Well, I'm so glad I'm livin' in the U.S.A.
Yes, I'm so glad I'm livin' in the U.S.A.
Anything you want, we got right here in the U.S.A.4. James Brown, Its a Mans Mans Mans World
I included this song on grounds of general political incorrectness and because I love the Godfather of Soul. However, I think one can also listen to the lyrics not just as a celebration of the accomplishments of men versus women, but of entrepreneurs and industry. Consider these lines:You see, man made the carsRather than a glorification of male chauvinism, I prefer to think of this song as a paean to the inventors and builders who made the many products we all take for granted. In that sense, it is conservative economically, as well as socially. This song reached number 8 on the pop chart in 1966 and was on the chart for 8 weeks.
To take us over the world
Man made the train
To carry the heavy load
Man made the electric lights
To take us out of the dark
Man made the bullet for the war
Like Noah made the ark
This is a mans, mans world
But it would be nothing
Nothing without a woman to care5. The Browns, The Three Bells
Based on a French song written in 1945, Dick Manning added new English lyrics in 1959. This version went to number 1 in August of that year, remaining in that position for 4 weeks. It tells the life of Little Jimmy Brownin deeply religious terms. Typical are the last lines:And the little congregation
Prayed for guidance from above
Lead us not into temptation
May his soul find the salvation
Of thy great eternal love
Burnette is best known for his huge hit, Youre Sixteen, but he also had several other songs that made the chart, of which this was the last. It is the story of a soldier going off to war and his final night at home. Although he wants desperately to stay with his wife, he tells her he has to go. Ill go for God, country, and my baby, Burnette sings. This patriotic hit peaked at number 18 in November 1961.
Well the eagles been flyin slow
And the flags been flyin low
And a lotta people sayin that Americas fixin to fall
Well speaking just for me
And some people from Tennessee
Weve got a thing or two to tell you all
This lady may have stumbled
But she aint never failed
And if the Russians dont believe that
They can all go straight to hell
Were gonna put her feet
Back on the path of righteousness
And then God bless America again
Elliman was a member of the cast of the rock opera, Jesus Christ Superstar, written by Tim Rice and Andrew Lloyd Webber. This is a song from that show, sung in the voice of Mary Magdalene. Ellimans performance is incredible, coming close to being erotic while still being deeply religious. It reached number 8 in May 1971, and was on the chart for 6 weeks as a single. Helen Reddy had a simultaneous hit with the same song. Her version rose to number 13 the same month.
Two other songs with a similar message that did not make my list, are Indiana Wants Me by R. Dean Taylor, which hit number 5 in September 1970, and The Kingston Trios Tom Dooley, a number 1 hit in 1958.
Hortons two other hits, Sink the Bismarck and North to Alaska, both in 1960, were also historical in nature. Both written for movies, the former tells the true story of the hunt for a German battleship in World War II, and the latter of the Alaskan gold rush.
21. Whitney Houston, The Star Spangled Banner In the midst of the Gulf war in 1991, Miss Houston was asked to sing the National Anthem at the opening of Super Bowl XXV on January 27. Although a difficult song for even the best singers, she electrified the crowd with this rendition. Released as a single, this live performance reached number 20 on the chart.
Some conservatives may object to inclusion of this song on a list of conservative classics on the grounds that John is an open homosexual. But as noted at the beginning, I ignored the artist and looked only to the song lyrics in making my choices. I also think Philadelphia Freedom is a great song. It was a number 1 hit for 2 weeks in December 1974.
Two other excellent anti-tax songs by contemporary singers, which unfortunately were not released as singles, are Taxman, Mr. Thief by Cheap Trick, and 1040 Blues by Robert Cray. The former appeared on their first album in 1977, with a live version also appearing on their 1999 album, Music for Hangovers. The title pretty much says it all. The latter appears on Crays album, Shame + a Sin. Following are some representative lines:
I hate taxes
I work hard for my money
Every April you take it all away
Taxes gonna break my back I swear
Dont you know I pay a lot more than my share?
You keep all your smart modern writers
Give me William Shakespeare You keep all your smart modern painters
I'll take Rembrandt, Titian, Da Vinci and Gainsborough
I was born in a welfare state
Ruled by bureaucracy ,br> Controlled by civil servants
And people dressed in gray
Got no privacy, got no liberty
Cos the twentieth century people
Took it all away from me28. Laurie London, Hes Got the Whole World (In His Hands)
A simple, yet deeply felt, song about God, the title pretty much says it all. It reached number 1 in March 1958, and stayed in that position for 4 weeks.
29. Lynyrd Skynyrd, Sweet Home Alabama
In the early 1970s, singer Neil Young recorded a couple of songs, Alabama and Southern Man, that painted all Southerners as racist rednecks. Lynyrd Skynyrd responded in 1974 with Sweet Home Alabama, a vigorous defense of the South and a direct counterattack on Mr. Young. It made my list mainly for the following lines: In Birmingham they love the governor Now we all did what we could do Now Watergate does not bother me Does your conscience bother you?
Tell the truth It is worth remembering that the governor of Alabama at this time was George Wallace. And with the song coming out in August 1974, just as Richard Nixon was forced to resign the presidency because of Watergate, the line about that alone makes it a conservative classic. Sweet Home Alabama reached number 8 and was on the charts for 11 weeks. Sadly, most of the members of Lynyrd Skynyrd died in a plane crash in 1977. 30. Madonna, Papa Dont Preach
Amazingly, this is a strongly pro-life song, for which the singer was criticized by pro-choicers at the time. In it, she asks her fathers advice about what to do with an out-of-wedlock child. My friends keep telling me to give it up, she sings, but in the end decides, Im gonna keep my baby. The song hit number 1 in July 1986.31. Mormon Tabernacle Choir and Andy Williams, Battle Hymn of the Republic
Inclusion of this classic needs no explanation, other than that it was a genuine hit during the rock era. This version reached number 13 in September 1959, and was on the chart for 11 weeks. Backed by Eugene Ormandy and the Philadelphia Orchestra, it has been this famous groups only chart appearance. Well-known pop singer Andy Williams also charted with this song, sung during a eulogy for slain Senator Robert F. Kennedy at St. Patricks Cathedral in New York on June 8, 1968. It was on the chart for 4 weeks that year, reaching number 33.32. Ocean, Put Your Hand in the Hand
A Canadian group, Ocean put this highly religious song on the chart in March 1971, where it rose to number 2. The opening refrain puts Jesus at the center of this unlikely hit. Put your hand in the hand of the Man who stilled the water
Put your hand in the hand of the Man who calmed the sea
Take a look at yourself and you can look at others differently
By putting your hand in the hand of the Man from Galilee
33. Elvis Presley, Crying in the Chapel
Although best known for his many rock standards, Elvis recorded a number of gospel songs and considered them some of his best work. This is the only one of those recordings to become a pop hit. Recorded in 1960, Crying in the Chapel didnt reach the chart until May 1965, when it climbed to number 3.34. Kenny Rogers & the First Edition, Ruby, Dont Take Your Love to Town
Although better known in later years as a country and western singer, Rogers started out singing psychedelic rock, such as his first hit, I Just Dropped In (To See What Condition My Condition Was In) in 1968. The following year, he took this Mel Tillis song to number six. Coming at the peak of the Vietnam War protests, Rogers deserves credit for taking a patriotic stance in the following lyrics:It wasnt me who started that old crazy Asian war
But I was proud to go and do my patriotic chore
35. SSgt. Barry Sadler, The Ballad of the Green Berets
Inclusion of this song is so obvious it hardly needs comment. I am still amazed that such an explicitly pro-Vietnam War song could make the pop chart in 1966. And not just make the chart, but be a huge hit. Sadlers song was number 1 for 5 weeks, making it one of the biggest hits of the 1960s.36. Dusty Springfield, Wishin and Hopin
Some of my female friends will object to this song, but I included it because it takes such a traditional approach to how women should deal with men. Springfield made the chart with this song in July 1964, and it reached number 6. What female artist would sing these lyrics today?Show him that you care just for him
Do the things he likes to do
Wear your hair just for him,
cause you wont get him
Thinkin and a-prayin
Wishin and a-hopin
37. Diana Ross and the Supremes, Love Child
Possibly the best-selling female rock group of all time, Diana Ross and the Supremes scored a number 1 hit in October 1968 with this culturally conservative hit. The song is all about avoiding premarital sex and the terrible consequences of out-of-wedlock births. The danger, all too real in the Black community, then and now, is that the child is the one who ultimately suffers. As they sing:This love were contemplatin
Is worth the pain of waitin
Well only end up hatin
The child we may be creatin
38. The Temptations, Ball of Confusion
This song made my list because of one line, Politicians say mo taxes will solve everything. It rose to number 3 in 1970 and stayed on the chart for 13 weeks, longer than all but one of The Temptations many hits.39. Aaron Tippin, Where the Stars and Stripes and the Eagle Fly
Just days after the World Trade Center attack, country singer Aaron Tippin released this unabashedly patriotic song. Under normal circumstances, it might not have been released as a single at all and probably would have stayed only on the country chart. But just as earlier conflicts pushed patriotic country hits over onto the pop chart, the Sept. 11 attack did so again. Tippins effort went as high as number 24 on the pop chart in late 2001.40. Tammy Wynette, Stand By Your Man
This falls into the same category with Wishin and Hopin as an anti-feminist anthem. It is also a great song, brilliantly sung. It is almost impossible not to be moved by Wynette as she belts out the songs title over and over. It is truly a classic in every sense of the term. Stand by Your Man was number 1 on the country chart for 3 weeks and hit 19 on the pop chart in December 1968. R&B singer Candi Staton also charted with this song in 1976. Her version was on the charts for 9 weeks, rising to number 24.***** I realize that some will disagree with these choices, either because they are not sufficiently conservative or because they have better ones. I welcome a debate on the subject and hope others will join in, especially younger conservatives more familiar with the music of the last 20 years than I am. No doubt, I have left off some songs that deserve recognition. Nevertheless, I think I have proven that during the rock era, a substantial amount of music has not only embodied classical conservative themes, but proven very popular as well. I frankly think it would be much harder to put together a companion list of the most left-wing songs. (Off hand, the only one I can think of is Fortunate Son by The Creedence Clearwater Revival.) Perhaps some entrepreneur will put these songs together on a compact disk and we can see if they still have market appeal.
Bruce Bartlett is a senior fellow at the National Center for Policy Analysis and a nationally syndicated columnist. He thanks Stan Evans, Nancy Christy, Chris Bachelder, Howard Segermark, Chris Manion, Terry Teachout and Grover Norquist for helpful suggestions in compiling this list. Of course, they are not responsible for any errors of judgment.
Note: In most cases, lyrics were obtained at www.lyricsworld.com, edited in some cases by my own ear. Contact me with suggestions or complaints at brucebartlett@compuserve.com. Just remember, the song must have made the Top 40 pop chart list to be considered for inclusion. However, I am also happy to hear about other conservative songs in the rock genre.
P.S.
Following are some also-rans that didnt make my cut.
Eddie Cochran, Summertime Blues (#8, 1958): libertarian
Everly Brothers, Wake Up Little Susie (#1, 1957): culturally conservative
Norman Greenbaum, Spirit in the Sky (#3, 1970): religious
Mickey Newbury, An American Trilogy (# 26, 1971): patriotic
The Shirelles, Soldier Boy (#1, 1962): patriotic
Bobby Vinton, Mr. Lonely (#1, 1964): patriotic
Al Wilson, The Snake (#27, 1968): explains liberalism
The Winstons, Color Him Father (#7, 1969): pro-familyP.P.S.
Some offbeat conservative/libertarian album cuts by major rock groups:
Blues Traveler, Support Your Local Emperor, Travelers and Thieves (1991)
Metallica, Dont Tread on Me, Black Album (1991)
Rush, Something for Nothing, 2112 (1976)
Merle rules
BTTT
I went to see Neil Diamond at Madison Square Garden not too long after 9/11. The "curtain" in front of the stage was a giant American flag (they pulled it straight up to raise it) and he opened with "America". The concert was excellent.
Well, at least he didn't include "Born in the USA."
The Beatles, Revolution
There are other lyrics in the song that are far more conservative than the verse he selected:
You say you'll change the constitution
Well you know
We all want to change your head
You tell me it's the institution
Well you know
You better free your mind instead
But if you go carrying pictures of Chairman Mao
You ain't going to make it with anyone anyhow
Thems words to live by, hippies.
Not because of the lyrics - just because Rush Limbaugh took over the music as the theme. My ears perk up whenever I hear it.
I'm sorry, but citing songs like "My Sweet Lord', 'Turn Turn Turn' and 'It's a Man's World' as 'explicitly conservative' is a ridiculous assertion.
I can't believe "Tom Sawyer" didn't make this list! Sounds like the author missed out on the rock scene almost entirely!
Music (I think) ping.
This list is weird.
Barf-o-rama, man!!!!
I'd add Paul Revere and the Raiders' "Kicks," (an anti-drug song) John Cougar's "Small Town" which celebrates Middle America, and Huey Lewis and the News' "Hip To Be Square," among others.
bump for a later read.
WTH let Madonna in there?
It's the song not the artist that's being reffered to.
Yeah, I think he blurred the lines with music that was specifically religious. Conservatism doesn't have to be religious.
There should be some stuff by the Nuge on here, or certainly something from Alice Cooper (check out "The Last Temptation" album.)
I always preferred Neil Sedaka.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.