Skip to comments."Suicide Killers:The psychology behind suicide bombings"
Posted on 12/10/2005 1:48:45 PM PST by Dick Bachert
Below is a transcript of an interview with a French film maker who has released his seventh film called "Suicide Killers." It is well worth the read. I received it from a friend of mine in Iraq; references have been removed for obvious reasons. September 12, 2005 By Pierre Rehov, French Documentary Filmmaker
On July 15, MSNBC's "Connected" program discussed the 7/7 London attacks. One of the guests was Pierre Rehov, a French filmmaker who has filmed six documentaries on the intifada by going undercover in the Palestinian areas.
Pierre's upcoming film, "Suicide Killers," is based on interviews that he conducted with the families of suicide bombers and would-be bombers in an attempt to find out why they do it. Pierre agreed to a request for a Q&A interview here about his work on the new film. Many thanks to Dean Draznin and Arlyn Riskind for helping to arrange this special interview.
What inspired you to produce "Suicide Killers," your seventh film?
I started working with victims of suicide attacks to make a film on PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder) when I became fascinated with the personalities of those who had committed those crimes, as they were described again and again by their victims. Especially the fact that suicide bombers are all smiling one second before they blow themselves up.
Why is this film especially important? People don't understand the devastating culture behind this unbelievable phenomenon. My film is not politically correct because it addresses the real problem-showing the real face of Islam. It points the finger against a culture of hatred in which the uneducated are brainwashed to a level where their only solution in life becomes to kill themselves and kill others in the name of a God whose word, as transmitted by other men, has became their only certitude.
What insights did you gain from making this film? What do you know that other experts do not know? I came to the conclusion that we are facing a neurosis at the level of an entire civilization. Most neuroses have in common a dramatic event, generally linked to an unacceptable sexual behavior. In this case, we are talking of kids living all their lives in pure frustration, with no opportunity to experience sex, love, tenderness or even understanding from the opposite sex. The separation between men and women in Islam is absolute. So is contempt toward women, who are totally dominated by men. This leads to a situation of pure anxiety, in which normal behavior is not possible. It is no coincidence that suicide killers are mostly young men dominated subconsciously by an overwhelming libido that they not only cannot satisfy but are afraid of, as if it is the work of the devil. Since Islam describes heaven as a place where everything on earth will finally be allowed, and promises 72 virgins to those frustrated kids, killing others and killing themselves to reach this redemption becomes their only solution. What was it like to interview would-be suicide bombers, their families and survivors of suicide bombings? It was a fascinating and a terrifying experience. You are dealing with seemingly normal people with very nice manners who have their own logic, which to a certain extent can make sense since they are so convinced that what they say is true. It is like dealing with pure craziness, like interviewing people in an asylum, since what they say, is for them, the absolute truth. I hear a mother saying "Thank God, my son is dead." Her son had became a shaheed, a martyr, which for her was a greater source of pride than if he had became an engineer, a doctor or a winner of the Nobel Prize. This system of values works completely backwards since their interpretation of Islam worships death much more than life. You are facing people whose only dream, only achievement is to fulfill what they believe to be their destiny, namely to be a shaheed or the family of a shaheed. They don't see the innocent being killed, they only see the impure that they have to destroy.
You say suicide bombers experience a moment of absolute power, beyond punishment. Is death the ultimate power? Not death as an end, but death as a door open to the after life. They are seeking the reward that God has promised them. They work for God, the ultimate authority, above all human laws. They therefore experience this single delusional second of absolute power, where nothing bad can ever happen to them, since they become God's sword. Is there a suicide bomber personality profile? Describe the psychopathology. Generally kids between 15 and 25 bearing a lot of complexes, generally inferiority complexes. They must have been fed with religion. They usually have a lack of developed personality. Usually they are impressionable idealists. In the western world they would easily have become drug addicts, but not criminals. Interestingly, they are not criminals since they don't see good and evil the same way that we do. If they had been raised in an Occidental culture, they would have hated violence. But they constantly battle against their own death anxiety. The only solution to this deep-seated pathology is to be willing to die and be rewarded in the after life in Paradise. Are suicide bombers principally motivated by religious conviction? Yes, it is their only conviction. They don't act to gain a territory or to find freedom or even dignity. They only follow Allah, the supreme judge, and what He tells them to do. Do all Muslims interpret jihad and martyrdom in the same way? All Muslim believers believe that, ultimately, Islam will prevail on earth. They believe this is the only true religion and there is no room, in their mind, for interpretation. The main difference between moderate Muslims and extremists is that moderate Muslims don't think they will see the absolute victory of Islam during their life time, therefore they respect other beliefs. The extremists believe that the fulfillment of the Prophecy of Islam and ruling the entire world as described in the Koran, is for today. Each victory of Bin Laden convinces 20 million moderate Muslims to become extremists. Describe the culture that manufactures suicide bombers. Oppression, lack of freedom, brain washing, organized poverty, placing God in charge of daily life, total separation between men and women, forbidding sex, giving women no power whatsoever, and placing men in charge of family honor, which is mainly connected to their women's behavior.
What socio-economic forces support the perpetuation of suicide bombings? Muslim charity is usually a cover for supporting terrorist organizations. But one has also to look at countries like Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Iran, which are also supporting the same organizations through different networks. The ironic thing in the case of Palestinian suicide bombers is that most of the money comes through financial support from the Occidental world, donated to a culture that utterly hates and rejects the West (mainly symbolized by Israel).
Is there a financial support network for the families of the suicide bombers? If so, who is paying them and how does that affect the decision? There used to be a financial incentive in the days of Saddam Hussein ($25,000 per family) and Yasser Arafat (smaller amounts), but these days are gone. It is a mistake to believe that these families would sacrifice their children for money. Although, the children themselves who are very attached to their families, might find in this financial support another reason to become suicide bombers. It is like buying a life insurance policy and then committing suicide. Why are so many suicide bombers young men? As discussed above, libido is paramount. Also ego, because this is a sure way to become a hero. The shaheeds are the cowboys or the firemen of Islam. Shaheed is a positively reinforced value in this culture. And what kid has never dreamed of becoming a cowboy or a fireman? What role does the U.N. play in the terrorist equation? The UN is in the hands of Arab countries and third world or ex-communists countries. Their hands are tied. The UN has condemned Israel more than any other country in the world, including the regime of Castro, Idi Amin or Kaddahfi. By behaving this way, the UN leaves a door open by not openly condemning terrorist organizations. In addition, through UNRWA, the UN is directly tied to terror organizations such as Hamas, representing 65 percent of their apparatus in the so-called Palestinian refugee camps. As a support to Arab countries, the UN has maintained Palestinians in camps with the hope to "return" into Israel for more than 50 years, therefore making it impossible to settle those populations, which still live in deplorable conditions.
Four-hundred million dollars are spent every year, mainly financed by U.S. taxes, to support 23,000 employees of UNRWA, many of whom belong to terrorist organizations (see Congressman Eric Cantor on this subject, and in my film "Hostages of Hatred"). You say that a suicide bomber is a 'stupid bomb and a smart bomb' simultaneously. Explain what you mean. Unlike an electronic device, a suicide killer has until the last second the capacity to change his mind. In reality, he is nothing but a platform representing interests which are not his, but he doesn't know it. How can we put an end to the madness of suicide bombings and terrorism in general? Stop being politically correct and stop believing that this culture is a victim of ours. Radical Islamism today is nothing but a new form of Nazism. Nobody was trying to justify or excuse Hitler in the 1930s. We had to defeat him in order to make peace one day with the German people. Are these men traveling outside their native areas in large numbers? Based on your research, would you predict that we are beginning to see a new wave of suicide bombings outside the Middle East? Every successful terror attack is considered a victory by the radical Islamists. Everywhere Islam is expands there is regional conflict. Right now, there are thousands of candidates for martyrdom lining up in training camps in Bosnia, Afghanistan, Pakistan. Inside Europe, hundreds of illegal mosques are preparing the next step of brain washing to lost young men who cannot find a satisfying identity in the Occidental world. Israel is much more prepared for this than the rest of the world will ever be. Yes, there will be more suicide killings in Europe and the U.S. Sadly, this is only the beginning
I believe there is real insight in this article. And the comment about how we didn't try to justify Nazism or explain it, we just simply defeated it is exactly right and applies here.
God has an answer to this erroneous concern and the answer is "faith".
Psycho analysis without a base of "faith" is as erroneous as the actions of the mislead ones.
A simple solution which is placed upon tn the back burner is lost in political rhetoric for personal concerns of politicians.
This is a great article.
"Each victory of Bin Laden convinces 20 million MODERATE Muslims to become extremists. Describe the culture that manufactures suicide bombers. Oppression, lack of freedom, brain washing, organized poverty, placing God in charge of daily life, total separation between men and women, forbidding sex, giving women no power whatsoever, and placing men in charge of family honor, which is mainly connected to their women's behavior."
And our sick left want to pull out of Iraq and give Muslims victory! Words cannot express my disgust with the left especially how they are undermining our military. Our men and women risk their lives to stop this. You'd think our military is the devil - no it's Islam!
I hope others read it. It makes sense in a sick sort of way. By any standard you have to be a sick person to be a Muslim.
I don't know where you stand spiritually ... but this has the ear markings of end times ... complete with people endorsing evil from ALL perspectives.
I don't want to be here when the body of Christ is removed with the Holy Spirit, the Restrainer. The thought of being here with all goodness gone is to scary to ponder.
Pierre Rehov is terrific.
As a Frenchman he was able to infiltrate Jenin after Operation Defensive Shield (2003) and get raw footage of Palestinians admitting and demonstrating how they staged Israeli atrocities. ("Road to Jenin"). He spoke French and was accepted as a co-conspirator because of that, a silent commentary on the French affinity for staged Palestinian footage hostile to Israel.
In "Holy Land: Christians In Peril" he shows the Muslim treatment of Christians in Palestinian territories.
In "Hostages of Hatred" he exposes the UN's '$ for Palestinians' scam, dwarfs Oil for Food.
Muslims have plenty of "faith"...just in the wrong spiritual entity. Islam's allah isn't God (the Creator), but, in islam, allah has designed a brilliant mechanism for the building of unbearable sexual frustration in young men and then directing that dark energy on the destruction of God's handiwork.
A failure to understand the enemy may mean an inability to identify its Achilles heel.
Bump for later read.
Great article. Thank you for posting this. I just wish that Condi Rice and President Bush would read this and finally understand why their policies towards Palestinians and Israel will not work.
Well said my FRiend and to compare these two entities is like comparing night to day.
Disappointingly, a prestigious festival such as Sundance seems to go out of its way to present only one side of the Israeli/Palestinian story. So despite Rehovs record of accomplishment, which includes some international recognition, particularly with The Road to Jenin, Lisa Magnus, Rehovs North American representative, fellow editor and collaborator, told me that Sundance will not even return her calls or even pay her the small courtesy of acknowledging receipt of public relations packages.
This interview can be found at:
One might wonder why is it called the war on terror rather than the war against extremist muslims? Why won't the POTUS nor any congress critter nor any fed agency call this war for what it is?
Does anyone here believe we are fighting a war against some other unidentified/unknown group/s or entities?
Mr. President, believe these words, Islam is not a religion of peace. And to say so is an insult to our intelligence.
"All Muslim believers believe that, ultimately, Islam will prevail on earth."
READ THEIR BOOK, READ THEIR BOOK, READ THEIR BOOK, READ THEIR BOOK, READ THEIR BOOK, READ THEIR BOOK, READ THEIR BOOK,
How do you recognize an Islamic moderate?
He is the one screaming "Death to extremists!"
I dont want to have insight, I want them and the lair that the came from eliminated.
I got this email a couple of days ago and it seems sort of fitting:
Everyone seems to be wondering why Muslims are so quick to commit suicide.
Let's see now:
No tailgate parties.
No Home Depot.
No hot dogs. No burgers.
More than one wife. (HELLO, ARE YOU CRAZY?)
Rags for clothes and towels for hats.
Constant wailing from the guy next-door because he's sick and there are no doctors.
Constant wailing from the guy in the tower.
No chocolate chip cookies.
No Girl Scout cookies.
You can't shave.
Your wives can't shave.
*You can't shower to wash off the smell of donkey cooked over burning camel dung.
*The women have to wear baggy dresses and veils at all times.
*Your bride is picked by someone else.
*She smells just like your donkey, but your donkey has a better disposition.
*Then they tell you that when you die it all gets better!
I mean, really, IS THERE ANY MYSTERY HERE?
These people need to be destroyed before they eventually take over the world. The brainwashing is incredible.
Another place to read about this is Leon Uris book, The Haj. It tracks the hatred through a family of Palestinians and offers several of the incites in this article through historical fiction.
Pierre got a little lost in sex and feminism. Other than that, it was a pretty good piece.
I don't think the Freud weapon will work as well against Muslim fanatics as it does against fat, soft Western suburbanites.