Posted on 12/13/2005 2:30:52 PM PST by Ultra Sonic 007
By the way, who did the recording? I have a great recording of the Jungle Books in MP3 Format from Worldtainment. You get a whole book on one disk. All in one voice, but their readers are marvellous.
http://www.worldtainment.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=worldtainment&Product_Code=yr09&Category_Code=4
Am I the only one who wonders why a girl in the role of the lead character has to be portraited as an ersatz male? [a.k.a. "tomboy"] Or do "they" consider a girl character portrayed as a girl....and no, not necessarily in a dress...to be hopelessly square?
A cross between him and Kim Possible.
This doesn't actually look that bad. It's certainly not as disturbing as the "Loonatics" makeover Warners did on Bugs and the gang.
You have to remember the time of the original stories, which was the 1920's. Children did not dress as they do now.
I'll have to hunt for it and get back to you!
"Am I the only one who wonders why a girl in the role of the lead character has to be portraited as an ersatz male? [a.k.a. "tomboy"]"
It's regarded as "empowering" within Progressive circles. Why, I have no idea.
What's the point if she isn't also black and lesbian?????? Am I the only one here offended by the lack of inclusion??
"What's the point if she isn't also black and lesbian?"
They're saving that to "breathe some fresh air" into the timeless Snow White.
What they need to do is leave the Pooh stories alone and create all new stories with all new characters and call it something else. Begin with a brand new idea from the beginning. Don't use classic stories like Pooh as a launch pad into something else. I am surprised at their lack of creativity on this one. Give it a year or two and it will probably die out completely anyway.
Girls have to be empowered and boys have to be neutered. Those are the Rules.
"In the original pre-Disney illustrations, Christopher Robin looked quite like a girl."
That was the style among those Victorian/Edwardian artists. Actually, POOH was written later (in the 1920s, I believe), but styles don't change overnight.
"Am I the only one who wonders why a girl in the role of the lead character has to be portraited as an ersatz male?"
The PC police has a fear & loathing of femininity. Even the more attractive-looking characters have to have a hard edge, nowadays.
When I was a kid, the feminine cartoon characters were soft (as well as pretty). The new ones -- blecch!
:-)
"...you took your gun with you, just in case, as you always did..."
- _Winnie_the_Pooh_, Narrator to Christopher Robin
"Christopher Robin, you must shoot the balloon with your gun. Have you got your gun?"
"Of course I have"
- _Winnie_the_Pooh_
Not the only references to him being armed. (Awright, it was a pop-gun, but the kid's what, six?)
;)
If they're timeless, why would they need a breath of fresh air? What's wrong with Christopher Robin? Good grief, plus the girl looks like Jimmy Neutron, LOL.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.