Posted on 05/23/2006 9:23:31 AM PDT by Mr. Silverback
On May 12, Hwang Woo-suk, the “disgraced cloning scientist,” was indicted on charges of fraud, embezzlement, and ethics violations.
The scientific community has rightly distanced itself from Hwang over his falsification of data. But there is still one thing that his efforts and much of the biotech industry share in common: a utilitarian disregard for the dignity and sanctity of human life.
Prosecutors charge that Hwang used falsified data showing cloning success to defraud investors of at least $2 million. However, the real outrage lies in how Hwang obtained the eggs for the research whose results he falsified. The media referred to “junior researchers” having “donated” their eggs. In this case donated is a euphemism, suggesting a voluntary transaction between equals—not the case here.
For starters, there are reports that Hwang and his senior associates “applied pressure to team members” to donate their eggs. One researcher reportedly told Hwang she wouldn’t do it, to which he replied, “Why not?” She then went through the procedure “out of worry” for her professional prospects.
Even without overt pressure, junior researchers are, as the New York Times put it, in a “dependent relationship” with their superiors—thus, vulnerable. Especially is this true “in the strict hierarchy of a scientific laboratory in a Confucian[-influenced] society like South Korea,” where “junior members often feel great pressure to please their superiors.”
Hwang’s taking advantage of his researchers is emblematic of efforts to do anything to clone human beings and to do embryonic stem-cell research. The physical differences between adult women and human embryos should not obscure the utilitarian calculus involved. Neither should it matter that Hwang was, by all accounts, an egomaniac, while other researchers are depicted as altruistic visionaries. The clear point is that those least able to resist—whether subordinate researchers or human embryos—are expected to sacrifice themselves for some “greater good.”
This is the issue in a measure pending in Congress to allow federally funded research on embryonic stem-cells obtained from frozen embryos. The treatment of these embryos, who were created for in vitro fertilization, represents utilitarian logic at its “finest.” They were abandoned when they no longer served their original purpose. So now we can destroy them to fulfill a new purpose. The justification for this proposal amounts to: “They shouldn’t go to waste.”
Sadly, in a culture shaped by utilitarianism such as ours, when Christians insist that human life—at any stage—is not a “waste,” we are labeled fanatics. When we argue that “progress,” however defined, should not be purchased at the expense of the most vulnerable among us, we are made out as “enemies of the future.” It does not matter that, to date, no treatments or cures have come from embryonic stem-cell research. It’s our insistence on the sanctity and dignity of the human person that offends the prophets of progress.
But that insistence is the only reliable protection against the abuses that took place in Hwang’s laboratory. In a world where some human life is expendable for the “greater good,” there is nothing that protects the weak or, for that matter, protects any of us.
This is part five in the “War on the Weak” series.
If anyone wants on or off my Chuck Colson/BreakPoint Ping List, please notify me here or by freepmail.
BreakPoint/Chuck Colson Ping!
If anyone wants on or off my Chuck Colson/BreakPoint Ping List, please notify me here or by freepmail.
ProLife Ping!
If anyone wants on or off my ProLife Ping List, please notify me here or by freepmail.
(In my best Butthead voice) "He said Hwang".
Please FreepMail me if you want on or off my Pro-Life Ping List.
My son's 8 grade science teacher asked about information on embryonic vs. adult stem cell research. Do you have a link to a web site or an article that has a good info on what has been achieved with the use of adult stem cells and the failures of the embryonic stem cells research? The teacher has his heart in the right place but needs to be equipped.
Thanks!
(In my best Butthead voice) "He said Hwang".
_______________
heehee.
Utilitarian ethics at its finest: the sagas of Beavis and Butthead. Can a society that celebrates idiocy be expected to advance high ethical standards? (heehee. He said high.)
Below is an outdated version, but the same website probably has an updated version, with MANY, MANY more cures, or improvements from Adults Stem cells.
Embryonic stem cells have never helped one single person, even a little bit - NEVER. Only pie-in-the-sky promises.
Current Stem Cell Treatments
Adult Stem Cells v. Embryonic Stem Cells
Adult Stem Cells
1. Brain Cancer
2. Retinoblastoma
3. Ovarian Cancer
4. Merkel Cell Cancer
5. Testicular Cancer
6. Lymphoma
7. Acute Lymphobolastic Leukemia
8. Acute Myelogenous Leukemia
9. Chronic Myelogenous Leukemia
10. Juvenile Myelomonocytic Leukemia
11. Angioimmunoblastic Lymphadenopathy with Dysproteinemia
12. Multiple Myeloma
13. Myelodysplasia
14. Other Cancers
15. Neuroblastoma
16. Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma
17. Hodgkin's Lymphoma
18. Renal Cell Carcinoma
19. Various Solid Tumors
20. Soft Tissue Sarcoma
21. Scleromyxedema
22. Multiple Sclerosis
23. Crohn's Disease
24. Rheumatoid Arthritis
25. Juvenile Arthritis
26. Systemic Lupus
27. Polychondritis
28. Systemic Vasculitis
29. Sjogren's Syndrome
30. Behcet's Disease
31. Myasthenia
32. Red Cell Aplasia
33. Autoimmune Cytopenia
34. X-Linked Lymphoproliferative Syndrome
35. X-Linked Hyperimmunoglobuline-M Syndrome
36. Severe Combined Immunodeficiency Syndrome-X1
37. Sickle Cell Anemia
38. Sideroblastic Anemia
39. Waldenstrom's Macroglobulinemia
40. Aplastic Anemia
41. Amegakaryocytic Thrombocytopenia
42. Chronic Epstein-Barr Infection
43. Fanconi's Anemia
44. Diamond Blackfan Anemia
45. Thalassemia
46. Stroke
47. Osteogenesis Imperfecta
48. Sandhoff Disease
49. Corneal Regeneration
50. Hemophagocytic Lymphohistiocytosis
51. Primary Amyloidosis
52. Limb Gangrene
53. Surface Wound Healing
54. Heart Damage
55. Parkinson's Disease
56. Spinal Cord Injury
Embryonic Stem Cells
N/A
http://www.stemcellresearch.org/facts/treatments.htm
thanks for the list/link
Thank you!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.