Posted on 09/03/2006 12:47:12 AM PDT by neverdem
Speculation.
Interesting that the latest significant evolutionary advancement of mankind is the development of a belief in God.
No other animal has it, it is very recent, and it is almost singularly responsible for the creation and advance of civilization.
The most Enlightened and advanced humans believe in God. (Atheists are retro and share the property with the animal kingdom, who are also atheist._
I guess you missed the latest poll, majority of Americans now believe in evolution. Apparently we are now on that path to 'survival', that is if the funding doesn't dry up.
Duplication is a particularly powerful mutation.
Oh? And how do you know that animals are atheists?
I would love to know what methodology you used to divine the religious beliefs of, say, dogs.
When Earth Turned Bad: New Evidence Supports Terrestrial Cause Of End-Permian Mass Extinction
FReepmail me if you want on or off my health and science ping list.
Interesting that you interpret it thus. The principal brain function that separates humans from other animals is abstract thinking -- something beyond stimulus and response that leads us not just to observe that things as they are, but to wonder how and why they are as they are.
That level of abstraction leads both to religion and to science. Different people find different answers. The evolutionary advance is the one that raised the questions.
It is possible, though I personally doubt it, that other animal species have the capacity to contemplate abstract questions and form philosophical abstracts to answer them, but we don't know it because we haven't yet managed to decipher their language.
Humans are almost certainly the only species that has managed to record its knowledge in a persistent form, so that each generation can began where the last left off rather than starting over.
Speculation.
You misspelled, "supported by a vast amount of evidence and research".
What's mere speculation is your opinion on this topic.
Being that every human is contained within the 'animal kingdom' that's not surprising.
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Mammalia
Order: Primata
Family: Hominidae
Genus: Homo
Species: Sapien
Since all animals are atheist, therefore all H. sapien (it means 'human' for those of you in Pensacola) are also atheist?
Then again, maybe not. Ponder this classic observation:
"Primates often have trouble imagining a universe not run by an angry alpha male" -- AnonThat alone could be the source of the instinct to seek someone to obey/follow/submit to, and that would not be limited to humans. It certainly fits in a great number of ways.
It also explains why my dog worships me, and my cat doesn't. Creatures which have evolved a social structure revolving around an alpha-male (like dogs, as well as humans and other primates) will be "hardwired", instinctually, to expect and want a "ruler" to whom they give their allegiance and turn to for protection and permission.
Similarly, Arthur C. Clarke has suggested that man looks for a god because of the instincts which help us survive as a species having a long childhood. To keep kids from wandering off on their own too soon and getting eaten by the tigers beyond the safety of the tribe (and so on), humans, primates, and other animals with a long nurturing time have instincts which instill in the young feelings involving turning to your parents for protection and sustenance, looking up to them for guidance on how to live, fear of straying too far from them and being alone, respect for their position of power over you, etc. etc. etc. After growing up and/or leaving home, however, these instincts leave a yearning to continue to look up to some more powerful, protective nurturer/rule-giver. And a belief in a watching-over-me deity would fulfill this need for some people. Is it mere coincidence that so many gods are described in terms which are variations of "heavenly father", "our father who art in heaven", "god the father", etc.?
and it is almost singularly responsible for the creation and advance of civilization.
You're kidding, right? There are many things that are responsible for the "creation and advance of civilization", but a belief in one or more deities is *way* down on the list. Nothing beats a good education, but for a layman's intro you could do worse than reading the book "Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies" by Jared Diamond.
The most Enlightened and advanced humans believe in God. (Atheists are retro and share the property with the animal kingdom, who are also atheist.
Oh, excuse me, I mistook you for someone who wanted to have an actual discussion of the article, instead of someone who just wanted to make himself feel good by patting himself on the back as one of the "most Enlightened and advanced" while insulting millions of other people as being little better than animals. I won't make that mistake again.
Prove it.
Since animals are incapable of higher cognition, the worst they can be accused of is agnosticism.
No other animal has it....
Prove it.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Please ping me if proof of this is ever offered, I expect to live maybe twenty to thirty more years.
Dream on.
"Atheists are retro and share the property with the animal kingdom, who are also atheist._
"
You know, saving your insults for another venue might well be a good idea. Since human beings are also animals, your point is poorly constructed. It's also unseemly.
Told you that did they?
I think it would be more proper to say that they are probably agnostic. Atheists believe there is no God. Agnostics don't have an opinion either way.
Many of the early civilizations. Roman, Greek, Persian, various Chinese and Indian civilizations, believed in many Gods, or revere some (possibly mythical but still human) person.
What a dumb comment.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.