Posted on 08/07/2007 11:34:43 AM PDT by Responsibility2nd
DAVENPORT, Iowa (AP) - Republican presidential candidate Rudy Giuliani said Tuesday that whether he was a practicing Catholic was a personal matter as he declined to answer questions about his religion. Addressing a town-hall meeting in Iowa, the former New York mayor was asked whether he considered himself a "traditional, practicing Roman Catholic." An audience member also called on Giuliani to discuss the role his faith played in making decisions on issues such as abortion.
"My religious affiliation, my religious practices and the degree to which I am a good or not so good Catholic, I prefer to leave to the priests," Giuliani said. "That would be a much better way to discuss it. That's a personal discussion and they have a much better sense of how good a Catholic I am or how bad a Catholic I am."
Giuliani is alone among the major Republican candidates in favoring abortion rights, a practice that the Catholic Church opposes. Some church officials have suggested that candidates who favor abortion rights should be denied the sacrament of communion.
On a personal level, Giuliani has been married three times, with one annulment and one divorce. Catholics who are divorced and have remarried are not permitted to receive communion.
In two days of campaigning in Iowa, Giuliani has sought to focus attention on adoptions and improving the quality of life for children. Yet, he has faced questions about his personal life, dealing with queries about his 17-year-old daughter's political preference on Monday and his religion on Tuesday.
The first questioner at the town-hall meeting mentioned President Bush's success in winning the support of Catholic voters and pushed Giuliani to explain his religious faith.
"That's a matter of individual conscience," Giuliani said. "I don't think there should be a religious test for public office."
That answer didn't satisfy questioner Thomas Fritzsche of Davenport, Iowa.
"Of course he didn't answer my question," said Fritzsche.
Giuliani said he's the only Republican who can compete throughout the country without writing off traditionally Democratic states.
"I can make this campaign a nationwide campaign," Giuliani said. "We have only run in certain states."
Giuliani met privately with law enforcement officials who run anti- drug programs, and he told about 300 people at the town hall meeting that it was essential to expand the nation's anti-drug effort. He said no other presidential candidates has his experience fighting drugs.
"It's something I understand really well," said Giuliani, noting his experience as a prosecutor and mayor of New York City. "I've been doing this kind of work longer than I've been in politics."
Giuliani also offered his prediction about whom Republicans will face in the fall election.
"I suspect it will be a Hillary Clinton-Barack Obama ticket," he said. "Their views are pretty much the same."
LMAO...
I'm not Catholic, but even I could tell Rudy how good a Catholic he is.
I haven’t been an active Catholic for a long time, but I could be a better “Catholic” than Rudy.
The first Catholic the GOP ever nominated. Cheers?
What an ignorant comment. Hitler was a self-described pagan. There are evil people everywhere in every group, race and religion. Citing a few examples does nothing but sow hard feelings and conflict.
It’s interesting that religious affiliation is a big issue with Guiliani and Romney, but not Obama. I guess it’s like having a past with the KKK; it’s only relevant if you’re a Republican.
except for abortion and divorce/adultery, he could make a pretty good catholic someday.
JulieAnnie and San Fran Nan are on equal footing when it comes to Catholicism. They are CINO’s.
Pelosi should just do what I did, and admit she doesn’t believe in it anymore.
Rudy has every right to decline to discuss his religious practices with the public. The public, in turn, has every right to consider his refusal to discuss his religious practices when they decide who to vote for.
Hitler was raised in a Catholic family but specifically rejected the Church (and Christianity in general) as an adult.
As for Mussolini... wrong again.
Castro is the product of Jesuit schooling...
Unfortunately, the Jesuits have become very liberal in their ideology. That has nothing to do with Castro, though, who said, "I have never been a believer." Going to Catholic school does not make one Catholic.
Care to try your smear again?
Let's cut out the Catholic bashing crap, that happens to be part of the left's playbook.
We already know what Rudy's religion is, and it isn't Catholic.
This is why you find many boomers who call themselves "Catholic" even if they haven't been in a Church in years, while many folks in my age group (I was born in 1976) are not afraid to declare nonbelief, even if they were baptized.
I was born 6 years after you, and I was baptized too. Despite my non-belief, I have nothing against the church.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.