Posted on 01/08/2008 5:55:09 AM PST by SJackson
Wherever you have a Muslim community, you'll find trouble, you'll find friction, you'll find national-religious demands, and you'll find terror. Isn't that so? No, it isn't, at least not where the Muslim community in the United States is concerned.
At a time when European countries are debating among themselves about how to deal with the burgeoning extremism among their Muslim immigrant communities and how to contend with the dangers to their national security and culture from those who demand official recognition of their separate culture, there is no sign of similar unrest in the US. Close to a million Muslims live in America in peace.
Whereas in Europe acts of terror are initiated by local Muslims, the perpetrators of the terror attack on the World Trade Center were not aided by a single Muslim-American collaborator.
Strident demands to institute Shari'a law for Muslims are being heard in Europe, and even in Canada - but not in America, where no one has demanded that Arabic be recognized as an official language. Moreover, Muslim-American notables accentuate their loyalty to the US, and, unlike their European counterparts, publicly condemn Islamist terror and declare that they are proud of their loyalty to their new homeland.
A PUBLIC-OPINION survey conducted by the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) in 2006 to gauge the views of Muslim voters showed that 84 percent said Muslims should strongly emphasize shared values with Christians and Jews; 77% said Muslims worship the same God as Christians and Jews; 89% said they vote regularly; 86% said they celebrate the Fourth of July and 64% said they fly the stars and stripes. Nothing similar can be found in European surveys.
What is the explanation of this dramatic contrast? True, the Muslim minority in the United States represents a much smaller proportion of the population than in Europe, but that alone cannot explain the distinct dissimilarity.
THERE ARE five fundamental differences between Europe and the United States.
First, the US has been a land of immigration from its inception and has a great deal of experience in absorbing immigrants from other cultures, while in Europe, the phenomenon of immigration is relatively new. The US is also more selective than Europe in choosing which immigrants they allow into their country.
Second, the US maintains maximum, if not absolute, separation between religion and state, making religion an individual matter. That means there is no room for Muslim-religious demands. In Europe, even in those states that do not have an official religion, religion is still very influential - perhaps with the exception of France - in the areas of education and public life.
Third, the United States has a tradition of individualism: It is the individual that stands alone facing government; the individual pledges his allegiance to the flag and the constitution when he becomes a citizen; the individual can conduct a dialogue with the government on his own and has no need for an intermediary, such as the Muslim Councils established in Britain and France.
FOURTH, the immigrant to the United States knows that his economic fate is up to him and his own efforts: He knows that he is immigrating to a country where he has the chance of becoming rich, of becoming a celebrity. The immigrant to Europe is motivated, among other reasons, by the opportunity to become eligible for national welfare. However, when the welfare payments are provided, the immigrants discover that they are not sufficient to actually put them on a par with the veteran population.
Fifth, multiculturalism is recognized in both cultures, but in the United States, the concept is limited to certain specific areas: tolerance, recognition of other cultures and of the need to have affirmative action and diversity in education and employment. In Europe - and especially a short time ago in Britain, Holland and Scandinavia - multiculturalism has been translated into group cultural rights, which isolate the immigrants from the majority population.
Because of all these things, scholars and political leaders in Europe are now turning their gaze to America to learn from it about how to absorb Muslim immigrants.
IN ISRAEL, the situation is of course quite different, largely because of the conflict and the extremist anti-Israeli stance taken by the Israeli-Arab leadership. But the American example is significant: The most important question of all, for us too, is whether there is any chance that the Arab world will ever make its peace with modern democratic values, which place the emphasis on individual freedoms, thought and expression, redirecting religious injunctions to the private domain.
The democratic world stands on two principal pillars: the Jewish pillar - that all humans are created in God's image - and the Greek pillar, which encourages criticism of accepted thought.
So far, not a single Arab society has accepted these two foundations. On the contrary, Arab societies are increasingly moving in the direction of oppressive extremism and suppression of all independent thought and freedom.
In his books, Albert Camus, a North-African Jew who fought against French colonialism, expressed his abhorrence of the anti-modern trend of the Arab-Muslim world, but in an interview with L'Express he said, "The Arabs will have no choice but to accept the values of the West." Were he alive today, he could point to the Arab and Muslim community in the United States as a case in point, proving that under proper governmental conditions, the Arab-Muslim individual differs not at all in his aspirations for modern democracy and freedoms from his Western counterparts.
In this area, Israel can learn two things from America: the need for all immigrants and those receiving citizenship to take an individual oath of allegiance, and the importance of making the economic changes necessary to enable every Israeli Arab to advance economically, without being suffocated by red tape.
The writer is a professor of law at the Interdisciplinary Center (IDC) Herzliya, a former minister of education and MK, and the recipient of the 2006 Israel Prize in Law.
High Volume. Articles on Israel can also be found by clicking on the Topic or Keyword Israel. or WOT [War on Terror]
----------------------------
Because there’s not enough of them having infiltrated yet.
They know we won’t put up with their cr@p; they saw the reaction after 9/11 where people were getting targeted.
As long as we show them that we, as a people, have the wherewithal to deal with their nonsense, we’ll be safe. Let our guard down and we’re doomed.
Bet those 2 girls from Dallas would have liked to have known that!
SIXTH: I’m heavily armed and will shoot the Islamic SOB’s if they start any BS in my neighborhood.
...Or could it be because the Muslims in the USA know that because there is a thing called the 2nd Admendment, Americans can keep and bear arms, not just those in the military or police departments and thus the US Muslims must learn to mind their p’s and q’s.
Probably the ones who fist came here came to get away from the nonsense going on in the middle east. Now some are coming to bring the R.O.P. here.
The was a Pro-Hamas rally on Boston’s City Hall Plaza last year when the Katushkas were coming in heavy. A Jewish cameraman was filming and got beat up on camera. The cops told him it was his fault for being there.
Yes nice good soft usual fairy tale!
Did the author of this nice speech ever heard something about american citizens who converted to islam and became islamist activists...?
US muslims are just waiting for the right moment!
Don’t worry libtards
Why the muslims live in peace in the United States?
2nd Amendment.
The one city where they have a sufficient percentage of the population is Detroit... not exactly a haven of peace and understanding.
It isn't all peaches and cream. There are Muslim foot baths being installed in a new airport terminal here in Indianapolis. In some large cities in this country it is now acceptable and legal for a Muslim cab driver to discriminate against passengers based on religion, sex, ethnicity AND behavior, disabilities, animals, etc. (I have not heard the ACLU is suing the cabbies yet). There are extremists here in the US and, while no where near likeness to Europe, we have our own issues. Here the dangerous or borderline groups use our own system against us. They are a little wiser. Muslims cause an uproar on a plane, get themselves kicked off in order to make a media monster about Muslim prejudices AND SUCCEED. To keep the story alive, they SUE. A Muslim drives into a crowd of people for revenge about Iraq. He is protected by the constitution and is just in sane. No doubt the lion share of our American Muslims aren't trying to kill us. But I do not hear a very loud cry of support out there for America from Muslims. I haven't seen Muslim rallies proudly waiving the American Flag in Michigan. I don't see Louis Fara'con' out there decrying the evil SOBs that blow up women and children. There is a huge propaganda coup to be had if American Muslims were more vocal about their 'disdain' of terrorism.
“Probably the ones who fist came here came to get away from the nonsense going on in the middle east.”
Exactly. That’s not to say that there aren’t extremists here, but I have a feeling most who live here just wanted a better life away from the stranglehold of Islamic law in their home countries.
There’s roughly 500,000 muslims in NYC — a place with strict gun control laws.
“Why US Muslims live in peace”
Just a guess but the author missed the muslim taxi driver killing his two daughters last weekend.
Where was there living in peace again?
There maybe Islamist activists who are converts, but even they are not crazy, they know that there are CCW armed Americans and IF they value their lives leave those Americans enough alone.
That also includes the Arab Christians who know first hand directly or from family history what living under Muslim governing is like and value freedom bigtime.
That public declaration, however, is but a whisper.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.