Posted on 09/25/2008 12:27:08 PM PDT by 2ndDivisionVet
THERE'S A REASON voters in presidential races tend to shy away from electing senators. The primary skills of a legislator--talking, compromising, "representing"--are different from those of an executive--deciding, choosing, "executing." There are individuals who have the ability both to deliberate patiently and act energetically--but it's a rare combination. The best legislators tend not to be great executives, and vice-versa.
This year, for the first time in U.S. history, both major party nominees for president are sitting senators. The winner may be the one who can convince some portion of the electorate that he's less "senatorial," and more "presidential," than the other.
That's why McCain's action Wednesday--announcing he would come back to Washington to try to broker a deal to save our financial system--could prove so important. The rescue package that was so poorly crafted and defended by the Bush administration seemed to be sliding toward defeat. The presidential candidates were on the sidelines, carping and opining and commenting. But one of them, John McCain, intervened suddenly and boldly, taking a risk in order to change the situation, and to rearrange the landscape.
Of course his motives were partly election-related. But "the interest of the man must be connected with the constitutional rights of the place." If candidate McCain, for whatever mixed motives, ends up acting in a way that results in a deal that is viewed as better than the original proposal, and that seems to stabilize the markets and avert a meltdown--he'll benefit politically, and he deserves to. For McCain will have acted presidentially in the campaign--which some voters, quite reasonably, will think speaks to his qualifications to be president.
As for the question of Friday night's debate, which some in the media seem to think more important than saving the financial system--if the negotiations are still going on in D.C., McCain should offer to send Palin to debate Obama! Or he can take a break from the meetings, fly down at the last minute himself, and turn a boring foreign policy debate, in which he and Obama would repeat well-rehearsed arguments, into a discussion about leadership and decisiveness. And if the negotiations are clearly on a path to success, then McCain can say he can now afford to leave D.C., fly down, and the debate would become a victory lap for McCain.
So the action of these few days becomes more important than the talk of that hour and a half Friday night. One could even say the contrast between the two men in action becomes the true debate over who should be president. The media, being talkers and debaters, love debates, overestimate their importance, and are underestimating the possible effect of McCain's dramatic action. In the debate itself, McCain should mock the media's greater concern for gabbing than solving our economic problems, and should associate Obama with such a talk-heavy media-type approach to politics. If the race is between an energetic executive and an indecisive talker, the energetic executive should win.
McCain should offer to send Palin to debate Obama!
bttt
“..associate Obama with such a talk-heavy media-type approach to politics”
I bet Obamachev doesn’t have a lot of influence in his own Dem caucus being a freshman. Even though McCain is annoying, I bet he could sway Dems and Republicans.
I would even go so far as to say Master debaters.
Bill Kristol: “A Presidential McCain - McCain’s bold move could reframe the election—and win it”
Said the same thing about Palin pick as VP. Bill is easily impressed by McCain.
What has Senator Obama done to impress you?
Lol, and thats all I got to say.
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." - Manuel II Palelologus
He always has been. He was clearly in the McCain camp back in 2000. Still, he’s a perty smart cookie
I hope he’s right, more importantly I hope we get the right bill, I don’t know what experts they have working on it, I certainly don’t expect pols to understand how to fix the mess. I don’t know myself, but I do always seek out the best minds when I have a problem, and a check of what has worked historically. That’s why I would rather be governed by 535 “uneducated” people from the phone book with common sense.
Always better to read something from Bill Kristol than to have to listen to that annoying voice of his. I always find myself wanting to go Vito Corleone on him, “stop crying and act like a man”.
And I hope McCain comes out against the DEM plan and explain why....and NAME NAMES!
I don’t know how well she would do...Katie Couric stumped her a couple of times.
John McCain is like the world’s scariest, death-defying roller coaster....just when you think you’re going off the rails with him, the roller coaster slows to a velvety smooth landing.....
Agreed.
This election will be decided by Independents in 5-8 key swing states and they’re by and large paying attention and intelligent voters. I think this move by McCain will impress them as being decisive and focusing on the right priorities.
Meanwhile Obama is too busy prepping for a debate to be bothered....”Call me if you need me” is hardly a Presidential response to a crisis.
isn’t it interesting that joe “stand up, chuck” biden has been noticably quiet on the ‘crisis’ ?
In 2004, on Fox Sunday, the weekend before the election, Kristol was the only one that said Bush would win in the Round table discussion. Wallace, Berger, Williams etc said Kerry would win.
““If you need me you can call me.”
If your phone don’t ring you’ll know it is the American people.
Call me if you need me.
“Who said anything about safe? Of course he isn’t safe. But he’s good.”
McCain seems to be getting some “guidance”.
“I don’t know how well she would do...Katie Couric stumped her a couple of times.”
I haven’t seen the interview yet, which questions stumped Governor Palin?
I didn’t see any of it and haven’t heard any snippets...what happened?
And now a special request and dedication, going out to Mr. Barack Obama, hard at work studying for his big debate down in Florida...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YAbxTAGzdOg
She challenged Palin to names specific regulation that McCain had pushed for in his senate career. She was stumped...
Go to http://www.redstate.com/ to see excerpts of the interview....cheers!
maybe because he’s ‘for’ deregulation?
has this thing even aired yet?
You know...it's not even non-Presidential. It's non-Senatorial. Both Houses are meeting to head off acrisis and he can't put off his debate prep to go to Washington and do his J.O.B.? This buffoon should be run out of town on a rail!
Bill is easily impressed by McCain.
Thank God.
Imagine asking Obama’s running mate the same question.
Sending Governor Palin is clearly an idea with great appeal, and it's occurring to many people.
Absolutely classic :) and I spit out my coffee on my keyboard, lol. Every time I read Nobama’s response - the old song “Call me, don’t be afraid, you can call me... I don’t remember who sang it though. Would make a good youtube presentation though.
Beautiful!
not sure..found it at redstate.com. I think there was some heavy editing as well....
The rescue package that was so poorly crafted and defended by the Bush administration
heh heh heh :)
I wasn’t sure about having Palin debate Barry until Kristol mentioned. Now, I’d say why not? I don’t expect her to slam Barry. I don’t expect her answer every question correctly. I am sure she will stumble. As a governor, her job is to look after her state not international affair. When Barry announced to run for the election after only 143 days in the senate, he didn’t have much knowledge of foreign affair either. What Barry knows now is from his 300 foreign affair tutors. What I like her the most is her boldness which Barry lacks of. She put her butt on every single bill she passed.
Obama’s like a college kid who didn’t study all semester and is now cramming like crazy the night before the final. Of course he’s messed up by this.
she’s not a washington insider. why would anyone expect her to know those things?
Bill is easily impressed by McCain....
As a fighter pilot, This is the second time that McCain has gotten inside Obama’s OODA loop. He has a missile lock on him right now and Bill is right. McCain could flame him.
Like walking into the debate and saying the economic crisis is so important that they should discuss economics instead of foreign policy...watch Obama and all of his prep go down in flames.
McCain picking Palin was the first time and this Washington crisis meeting was the second. In both cases Obama has found himself flat footed and trying to orient himself for a response. In both cases,he has not acted effectively.
OODA loop is Observe-Orient-Decide-Act.
The pilot that has the fastest loop wins.
LOL. It’s hilarious. Obama needs three intensive days just to prep for the debate. He needs to settle on his positions and have his handlers tell him what he believes.
The debate is simply not McCain’s priority, and he sure isn’t trying to memorize his answers. He already knows what he believes.
James Taylor’s “You got a Friend” would make for a nice backdrop for a youtube video.
UltraKonservativen wrote: ...This is the second time that McCain has gotten inside Obama’s OODA loop....
It’s not just speed of response, it’s also recognizing critical vs not important.
McCain realizes that the Titanic has a big hole in it, and he is trying to organize an effort to get it plugged.
Professor Obama wants to debate the conduct of the crew, the design of the ship, how to prevent future collisions...
All talk, no action.
Obama is frozen/passive when having to deal with unexpected events.
Just like he’s not so good when he’s off the teleprompter.
he’s got a pretty nice jumpshot, other than that he prowess in selecting the right people to use to further his career looks pretty good.
Couric’s question was designed to stump - a clear “gotcha” question, and Couric had a smart-ass smerk when she asked it! I bet she wouldn’t ask Biden to name any legislation of Obamas! Who gives a rip if Palin hasn’t committed McCain’s entire legislative history to memory!
“Bill is easily impressed by McCain.”
Mr. Kristol is FINALLY listening to his mother, who is one of my heroes. We can all hang together, or we can all hang separately.
(Do your own homework and look her up.)
LOL! Which candidate is more Presidential and which is more Senatorial?
It’s really odd that McCain wins both questions!
Send Palin!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.