Skip to comments.'Tucson Citizen' To Close Saturday--After 138 Years (Official Dinosaur Media WakeŽ)
Posted on 03/15/2009 5:55:27 PM PDT by abb
Marshal Wyatt Earp's fabled 1881 shootout at the OK Corral in Tombstone was reported this way:
"A day when blood flowed as water, and human life was held as a shuttlecock, a day always to be remembered as witnessing the bloodiest and the deadliest street fight that has ever occurred in this place, or probably in the territory."
For nearly 140 years, the Tucson Citizen has told the stories of Southern Arizona, but on Saturday, March 21, the state's oldest newspaper will tell its last -- its own.
Gannett Co. Inc., the nation's largest newspaper publisher, announced in January it would close the Citizen if it didn't find a buyer for certain assets. Robert J. Dickey, president of Gannett's U.S. Community Publishing, said the paper was losing money and was a drain on Gannett operations.
The Citizen becomes the latest casualty of a newspaper industry struggling to survive despite the tough economy, dwindling advertising revenues and Internet competition. The battle has been especially tough in two-newspaper towns.
E. W. Scripps Co. closed the 150-year-old Rocky Mountain News, one of two daily newspapers in Denver, in February. Hearst Corp. has said it will close or sell the San Francisco Chronicle if it can't slash expenses, and has laid out plans to close the Seattle Post-Intelligencer if a buyer isn't found before April.
Four newspaper companies, including the owners of the Los Angeles Times and Chicago Tribune and The Philadelphia Inquirer, have sought Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in recent months.
The Citizen, an afternoon newspaper, has struggled for years against the Arizona Daily Star, a 117,000-circulation morning newspaper owned by Lee Enterprises. During the Citizen's heyday in the 1960s, circulation was about 60,000; today, it's 17,000.
Editor Jennifer Boice said the Citizen's closure is a loss for the Star, the community and journalism.
"It's a loss because what we do makes the Star better, the Star makes us better, and because of that, the community gets better information," said Boice, who started at the paper 25 years ago as a business writer. "It's more than the sum of the parts."
The Arizona Citizen was founded on Oct. 15, 1870, by John Wasson, a newspaper man from California, with behind-the-scenes help from Richard McCormick, the territory's governor and later territorial delegate to Congress.
The paper changed ownership several times over the next 100 years until Gannett bought it in 1976, just a few years after a U.S. Supreme Court case involving the Citizen led Congress to pass the Newspaper Preservation Act and new rules for joint-operating agreements for competing newspapers doing business together. Gannett also changed the name to the Tucson Citizen.
During its lifetime, the Citizen reported on Arizona's biggest stories, including the 1881 gunfight at the OK Corral and the 1934 arrest of bank robber John Dillinger and three other gang members hiding out in Tucson.
"It has such a long history," Arizona historian Marshall Trimble said. "That makes it part of Arizona history, and it's just another piece of our history that's going away."
Michael Chihak, the Citizen's former editor and publisher who retired last summer, spent a significant portion of his life with the paper. His grandfather was a pressman at the Citizen in the 1940s. As a boy, Chihak delivered the paper on his bicycle and was a high school stringer. He later became a reporter and editor, working for other news organizations along the way, and returned to the Citizen as its publisher and chief executive in 2000.
"It was more than a career, more than a job, it was part of my life," said Chihak, who is now executive director of a nonprofit foundation in San Francisco.
He said it's heartbreaking to see the demise of the Citizen, and "the loss of all the jobs of the finest journalists I knew."
Newspapers remain at the forefront of gathering and disseminating information, Chihak said, "but obviously the emphasis has shifted to other means of distribution, and of gathering, for that matter."
More than 60 newsroom employees will lose their jobs because of the closure, but Tucson Newspapers Inc., which oversees the Gannett-Lee Enterprises business operations under the JOA, will continue until at least 2015.
Star publisher John Humenik couldn't comment on the Citizen's closure because of pending legal issues related to the JOA, but Lee spokesman Daniel Hayes said, "it's always unfortunate when a community voice is lost."
The final Citizen will be a 24-page commemorative edition delivered on Saturday. About 20,000 copies will be printed and available in news racks for a couple of days.
The Citizen's staff continues to work as hard and as skillfully as ever in its waning days, said Bruce Johnston, who joined the Citizen 36 years ago.
"We're professionals," he said. "We're treating every day like it normally is, even though there's a lot of gallows humor around here."
Except for the stacks of boxes and large trash bins lining the newsroom to catch years' worth of notebooks and paper stacked atop desks, it was business as usual. Reporters continued to call sources, plan coverage and share laughs.
But they also shared tidbits about mostly fruitless job searches, punctuated by sighs and knowing nods as they prepared for their final week at their newspaper -- and for many, likely their final week in the business.
Associate Editor Mark Kimble, a 34-year veteran, said he worries about what closures like the Citizen's mean for the future of journalism.
There are "fewer sets of eyes looking at what government is doing and keeping an eye on the things that I think we all take seriously," Kimble said. "That's very unfortunate."
With writing like that, no wonder they're belly-up. A shuttlecock?
In the mid to late 1980s, the Citizen began to dramatically shift 'centerwards', which is to say compete with the Red Star for the lefty audience. Eventually, by 1990 or so there was no way to tell the difference between the editorial stance of the two papers, and since the Star had been doing the liberal thing longer and better, people stopped buying the Citizen.
The online commentary on the Citizen site has been filled with comments like mine, and of course they arrogantly poo-poo it all. Ah well, come next Sunday, I will be employed still, and they will not.
The Citizen has been dead since the TNI “two newspapers one office move”. All the best writers were always on the Star because morning papers are more prestigious, the Star had the better comics page, really the only reason there was to buy the Citizen is if you were looking for the movie schedule and the Star was sold out.
A not-so-fond farewell to the lame-stream media.
Nelson Muntz saya, “ Ha, ha...”
Is is bad form to laugh ?
Another Dem paper bites the dust (in AZ, that’s literal).
I agree with your evaluation. I have lived Tucson since the early 80's and have witnessed the Citizen's morph into the same lame leftist paper as the Red Star. The Star would be wise to give both sides of the local stories.
20,000 copies for a commemorative issue, and the population of Pima County (Tucson and it's surrounds) is over 1,000,000
Well darn! I didn’t have them on my Newspaper Dead Pool list!
The employees who are talented will find work if they are talented and willing to be objective. I imagine Rupert Murdoch's print and tv divisions would most likely salivate at a chance to get true journalists not corrupted by socialist agenda who are pushing things like "social and economic justice,whatever the hell that means.
I used to deliver that paper as a boy growing up in Tucson!! That and the Star too. It paid for my first car, so although both papers turned into leftist rags (like most dailies), I have some mixed feelings at its demise...
Did the Tucson Citizen endorse Obama?
You never knew the badlands were called that because outlaws played so much badminton?
LOL - good one! You can just see the Earps going out on a Saturday with their net and raquets, right?
The Citizen was still in print? Who knew?
“A day when blood flowed as water, and human life was held as a shuttlecock ...”
Tax Chick said: “With writing like that, no wonder they’re belly-up. A shuttlecock?”
Well that was said back in 1881! Hopefully their writing had improved from that, perhaps until Gannett took over.
Yes, I knew that. As to whether their writing improved after that, I couldn't say. Most of their present (soon to be former) employees probably wouldn't recognize a shuttlecock if it landed in their latte.
My Mom subscribed from 71 until her death. I haven’t paid any attention to either Tucson paper in years. The local news is usually depressing (’another tax initiative passed with strong support to build sidewalks that no one will ever use’ - OK, that last part WASN’T there). The national news is covered better on the Internet.
Sorry, but I think the major media, including the Citizen, have been in bed with the politicians for 30-100 years.
I don’t need them as a watchdog, because they never barked...
As far as I recall, they have only endored Dem presidential candidates since Clinton