Skip to comments.At Least 36 Died in Washington State in 2009 Under New Assisted Suicide Law
Posted on 03/04/2010 7:38:34 PM PST by DemonDeac
" At least 36 terminally ill people died last year after taking lethal medication prescribed by doctors under Washington States new physician-assisted suicide law, according to a state report released Thursday, the first since the law went into effect a year ago.
A total of 63 people filled prescriptions for lethal medication, but not everyone took it. All those who did take it died. Some people who did not take it died from other causes."
"Oregon, whose law went into effect in 1998, also released its annual report this week. The Oregon Public Health Division said 59 people died last year from lethal medication prescribed under the law; 95 prescriptions were filled. A total of 460 patients have died under the law in Oregon."
(Excerpt) Read more at nytimes.com ...
But do we know that those who supposedly bought it were the patients? Do we know that those who died weren’t murdered?
Here’s the problems with assisted suicide. First off, it’s murder, second it’ll do just what abortion did. Abortion started out to be only in the first trimester and only under strict terms. Now it’s a free for all and you can have an abortion at anytime for any reason. When will assisted suicide be a government mandate for certain reasons? And from a person who has known illness and felt horrible at how it was affecting my family. It would be really easy to talk someone in to suicide when they are the most vulnerable.
Someday, the government will quietly begin withholding medical treatment from, say, fathers who haven't paid their child support, or some other group everyone hates. And bit by bit...
Doctors who get a taste for killing their patients will, given the opportunity, kill even more of them than allowed.
Do we know they didn’t get these poisons and kill others with them, or sell them to others to poison other people?
The news in Washington must be keeping it all under wraps because I have not heard of any.
Don’t medicos have something analogous to “Oath Keepers”? This is a political issue. Probably most actual doctors there are aghast.
I need a shower just thinking about this story.
I figure honest doctors can figure out what to do with these creatures.
Thats simply wrong.
I hope and pray that if I become terminally ill and in constant pain, there is a zealot standing by to ensure that I die in mind rending agony rather than on my own terms.
Ironically, I, who would be willing to put up with such “agony” for reasons of my faith, would be denied a doctor who would honor MY wishes because he or she left an euthanasia state in disgust after attempting to roll back the situation. We have socialists here parading as heroes of freedom.
P.S. Grunt, a lot of people who find themselves in unbearable emotional or physical pain have not been adequately treated. Killing yourself is the chicken way out. I have no beef with treatments that may shorten life as a side effect if their primary purpose is the palliation of emotional or physical pain. I have a yakalo size beef with people who want to anti-constitutionally restrict the interstate practice of physicians in order to maintain some virtuous boycott.
Do not worry. I look forward to suffering wrenching pain so that your values are upheld.
How disappointed you would be if you just keeled over from a heart attack.
“How disappointed you would be if you just keeled over from a heart attack.”
Well it WOULD completely destroy my soapbox.
“As a practical matter we need to prohibit physicians who’ve worked in Montana, Wyoming, Idaho, Washington or Oregon from being employed elsewhere in the country.”
Why? The overwhelming majority of them have not participated in an assisted suicide. Why punish them too?
They know what they have to do to resolve the dilemma. They must be given every incentive to do so.
These creatures must first be reduced to the level of shamen, rootworkers and witch doctors.
Folks who work in a regime where it’s NORMAL for doctors to kill their patients can no longer be trusted.”
How many doctors are there in the state? Has to be thousands and thousands. How many were involved in these 36 cases? A dozen? Two dozen? Can’t say that its a normal part of the duties of a doc.
It's not like I'm demanding purity of association, but I'd like to make sure none of these guys treat me.
So, all those who take and keep an oath (original Hypocrates, or equivalent) must be exempt, no exceptions. I would choose at once the doctor that you’d want to use governmental apparatus to reject just because he or she first tried to remedy, then fled, a territory where the politicians legislated that doctors may kill.
Even the least afflicted leper may not leave the colony.
Now we have effective treatments that is bygone.
And I will be glad to sue you nine ways from sunday if you try.
There's no claim on your part, and your last response was INCOHERENT.
And your analogy is bassackwards anyhow. Anyone who tried to remedy the situation while remaining clean is by even your tortured mind definition, not a leper.
I will sue you for restricting commerce between the states, using the Federal apparatus.
Don’t worry. I’ll be more than happy to protect you from the “killer docs”.
And yes indeedy there is a claim on my part. I want to hire the doctor, you git out the way!
Take a trip to Portland if you want a “killer doc” or one of her friends.
Tenth Amendment stuff.
Hanging around with "killer docs" is a disease.
The tenth is next to a dead letter today so you are purporting to stand on a bent splinter. I will have your arse in court.
How do you propose to carry this out anyhow? You come carpetbagging into my state, you should by all means expect to be kicked out post haste in shame because your agenda is so ludicrous on its face. You do not even understand how it came to be in Oregon. This was not a motion of a majority of the medicos. This was consumer-driven and went over the doctors’ heads to the legislature.
You ignore that this was a consumer driven movement. Every single doctor in Oregon could have said no and the legislature would still have okayed it.
If it is a disease than get away from me cause I am leprous and will make you so. In fact, being in a country that voted for Obama is a disease. Get away from me.
I just don’t want to take the risk that some doctor comes to Virginia but back in Oregon, et al, he was a “killer doc”. Best that we keep them all out of here.
How did you think it came to pass that states license doctors? Do you think they just pulled the authority out of the thin air or something? It’s a tenth amendment question ~
“Dont worry. Ill be more than happy to protect you from the killer docs.”
Thank goodness. the last thing anyone should have is a peaceful, quiet and painfree death. Screaming agony for me!
“Why? The overwhelming majority of them have not participated in an assisted suicide. Why punish them too?”
If you are part of a group that does what some believe are bad things (and I am not 100% on board with the practice) then the whole group deserves to be punished?
My chosen headline for this:
“Doctors” murder patients under the color of “law”