Skip to comments.Graham Pushes National I.D. Card
Posted on 03/12/2010 6:21:58 AM PST by b4its2late
Senator Lindsey Graham, ever the faithful follower of uber-RINO John McCain, scored three RINO initiatives in just one week.
Reminiscent of the "the band's getting back together" scenes from the movie "Blues Brothers", Graham and McCain reached back to the good old days of bipartisan shafting of conservative judicial nominees and offered the Democrats another "Gang of Fourteen"--this time to shaft the public with a bipartisan Obamacare bill.
The offer must have been tempting to the Democrats who remember how "bipartisan leadership" from Graham and McCain spiked conservative guns when the Republicans were in the majority in the Senate. But this time around, the action on Obamacare is in the House. Senate Dems said no -- maybe next time.
Graham tried again.
With the House version of the "cap and trade" global warming tax frozen stiff in the Senate, Graham urged the GOP to stop demonizing climate change.
He told The New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman that calling climate change into question puts "at risk the party's future with younger people". Graham explained "I have been to enough college campuses to know if you are 30 or younger this climate issue is not a debate. It's a value." Graham called for bipartisan leadership to enact the climate change legislation.
Progressive bloggers seized on these remarks to try to unfreeze "cap and trade" in the Senate--or build support for Obama's alternative plan to have the EPA dictate a "cap and trade" regulation and tax scheme without Senate approval.
Meanwhile, Dem Senator Jay Rockefeller and other Democrats sought to block the EPA move to regulate carbon dioxide as a health hazard (on behalf of the 44% of American electricity generated in coal fired power plants.) Democrat Senator Chuck Schumer also asked Obama to stop stimulus grants for "green power" projects after learning that a wind farm in Texas was owned by a foreign firm and the stimulus money would stimulate jobs in China and Japan where the turbines were made.
So, no new "Gang of Fourteen" on "cap and trade." Graham tried again.
President Obama promised Latino activists a new illegal alien amnesty bill--last year. Mired in the health care "reform" debacle, neither the President nor his party wanted another partisan stand off. Senator Chuck Schumer had promised an immigration "reform" bill by last Thanksgiving but had produced nothing.
Lindsey Graham to the rescue.
Graham and Schumer have been meeting on a "new" bipartisan immigration bill. The President beamed his approval, and the new Gang of Two had a press conference to announce the breakthrough.
The "new" immigration bill includes a "path to citizenship" for illegals, border security, and biometric I.D. cards for every American to insure that only those here legally can get jobs.
Meet the new bill--same as the old bill. Since 1986, Americans have been promised some variation of the three legged stool--amnesty, border protection, employer sanctions. Every time a bill passes, the illegals get the amnesty, the border remains open, and millions more illegally enter the country.
In 2007, the McCain/Kennedy bipartisan Immigration "Reform" bill was supported by the leadership of both parties in Congress and by the President. It contained the same three components. It was defeated because the public "won't be fooled again."
The public was right to be skeptical. Following that bill's defeat, both Bush and Obama failed to control the border (the Boeing "virtual border" is an expensive flop) or verify employment eligibility (e-verify is said to have a 54% failure rate).
Graham says this time will be different. The "path to citizenship" will have to be earned by registering, paying a fine, paying any back taxes, and waiting in line.
Once again--we've had this debate. Many illegals do not want to become citizens. They just want to work and send home some money and go back home when they have enough. Many others are content with the current situation. As illegals, they can escape taxation, get welfare through their U.S. born kids, and still work here. Who needs "citizenship"?
Even worse, the "new" bill will still amnesty all illegals with a "temporary" visa while they are in line for citizenship. This visa removes any incentive to get in that line.
But there is something new and more dangerous in the Graham/Schumer bill.
To ensure that only people legally in the U.S. can work here, the bill will propose a biometric I.D. for EVERY AMERICAN before anybody can get a job.
Graham, apparently too desirous of playing a role in a in his own remake of "Inglorious Basterds", wants you to show him your Papers before you can work in your own country.
Opposition to this tyranny will come from all parts of our divided political spectrum. In a truly free country, the right to work cannot be granted (or withheld) by the government.
Graham wants to solve the problem of 11 million (or more) illegals working here by restricting the right to work of over 300 million who live in the "land of the free" legally. This is the TSA approach. We know who the terrorists are likely to be, but we will pat down and invade the privacy of all airline passengers to show how "fair" we are.
Worse, what does "biometric" mean ? Apparently, this I.D. debate is going on in many other countries as the technology allowing government to monitor our every move gets more feasible.
A biometric card allows government to include a lot of information about you on the card. How long before you must show the card to get health care ? Education ? Or to Vote ? Remember that the Social Security card morphed into an I.D. when proponents in the 1930s called such fears paranoid ?
Graham wants a SS card on steroids. He told the Wall Street Journal, "We've all got Social Security cards. They're just easily tampered with. Make them tamper proof. That's all I'm saying."
Practically speaking, there is no tamper proof card. The same technology that reassures Graham is available to others to tamper with the card and game the system.
This time, Graham's bipartisanship is a real threat to liberty.
Graham's RINO tactics will enable the President to turn illegal aliens into documented Democrats. And in the process, hand the Federal Government yet another way to monitor and control our lives.
The real solution is the same as it has always been. Congress must secure the border first, and enforce e-verify. Illegal immigration is a problem caused by Federal non-enforcement of existing law.
Liberal Lindsey Graham is -- like Rahm Emanuel -- trying to use a crisis to political advantage. But unlike the crises Emanuel peddles -- which are concocted -- the immigration crisis is real. And solving it need not be done by shredding the Constitution as Sen. Graham would do.
Why do the good people of South Carolina keep re-electing this guy? For that matter, whats so wrong with Arizona that they keep inflicting John McCain on us?
Graham and O’Reilly are apparently sharing the same bed.
Yes, I know. Sick.
Graham is going to wind up being like Spector... I bet that if he stays in office long enough, he will eventually switch over to the Democrat side... just do it now and get out of our house.
Hey, uber-RINO Graham, why don’t you propose that we all get marks on our forehead or hand. Let’s just get on with it. Is there no end to the effort by government enslave every human?
I will submit my DNA to the government right after they enforce the immigration laws.
What happened to our right to remain silent? With the chip they would know everything about us without us saying a word.
Would cops have scanners so they could identify people in a crowd?
O’Reilly kept saying last night - tamper-proof - chip.
I emailed him:
Is tamper-proof the same as unsinkable?
I don’t like this idea at all.
A national ID card will be quickly followed by a national police force - or should I say ‘preceded?’
If they add a requirement to pass a 100 question test written in English only, covering the Constitution, and basic civics. I am all for it. If you fail deported on the spot, (don't care if you were born here or not). I say start with the congress critters and work down.
I cannot post the words that I would use to describe this treasonous Linseed.
Your papers please.
P!$$ off the wrong person, no Biometric ID Card or it is invalid. No thanks.... Just like Real ID, another P.O.S bill.
You oppose the Mexican invasion. You oppose the theft of elections.
Until there is an national ID card, neither of the above can be solved. To have America, we must identify Americans
Remember this story every time you see someone defending the RINO’s
It seems Graham started talking conservative again during the primary and voters forgot his past abominations. McInsane is trying the same formula, but he has some quality opposition.
The cards will be fairly easy to reproduce and the supporting IT infrastructure easy to hack. For $5, every illegal alien will be able to get one from the local ACORN thug.
Freepers on the other hand will find themselves mysteriously deleted from the database due to some software bug.
No, this isn't sarcasm, and yes, I am serious.
So what is in this for Windy and by extension lord McCain? I do not believe that Windy does anything that he does not first get the lord’s blessing.
So we have to make a choice. Either we surrender our own liberty to make it possible for the government to enforce immigration laws, or we just let the illegal aliens stay as long as they can get their hands on some kind of phony documentation that will convince an employer (who really doesn't care if he is hiring illegal aliens) that they have a right to work here.
What is our alternative? Pass a law that requires only illegal aliens to have national ID cards? Yeah, that'll work.
Behold, the new John McCain.
Not just the next thing, this is a KEY component to the healthcare bill that's not a bill.
Remember, Pelozi said, "Diet, not diabetes". This card will be required to be presented when buying food. Once the rest of the population has an 'interest' in you being 'healthy', they will have a say in what you eat.
Rationing salt, butter, fats, soda, sugar, alcohol, meat... all will be tied to the 'public good' either because of health or the environment.
Not the ideals of liberty our forefathers fought for.
What an utter disappointment.
I carry my U.S. Passport. I had to present it along with my drivers licence to get a PO Box last December. We don’t need ID cards if we have a VALID U.S. Passport!
In every country that I have worked I have had to present a VALID nation ID and my U.S. Passport.
Eexpanding the Passport Office would work. BTW, when I lost my passport a few years ago I had ot present my LONG FORM BIRTH CERTIFICATE to get a new one issued!
This is a false choice.
The government already has every tool it needs to enforce the immigration laws.
No ID card is incapable of being faked.
And no ID card is a substitute for a lack of the will of the Federal government to enforce the law.
Both parties in Congress have failed to protect the people and States from invasion, as required by the Constitution.
This card has one purpose—control.
And Americans need to say “ENOUGH!”
Will this card have a number on it?
Reminds me of Gattaca. I’ve served my country in various ways for most of my adult life. I’m afraid I would have to decline participation in a National ID Card program. And I mean that sincerely.
“We know who the terrorists are likely to be, but we will pat down and invade the privacy of all airline passengers to show how “fair” we are.”
The crux of the problem: The TSA et al are so worried about being criticized that they’re putting scarce resources into ludicrous and ineffective “security measures”. Makes me wanna puke.
Its time to kick Lindsey Grahamnesty out of the GOP. As long as the GOP allows Lindsey Grahamnesty to stay in the party...I will not register as GOP anymore. I am not going to waste this conservatives time staying with a party that allows Liberal Treasonous Anti-Americans to stay in it.
Lindsey needs to take his a### and move it to Mexico...and take Juan McAmnesty with him
“Is tamper-proof the same as unsinkable?”
Bumper sticker of the year, my friend! Well said.
I agree - it’s only WHEN will he crossover to his true Alinsky party. Hopefully, it will be after Nov elections so we can milk him for as much as possible.
Yes, your Cholesterol number to identify what foods are acceptable for your needs
Graham is on the radio with Mike Gallagher right now.
Graham is on the radio with Mike Gallagher right now.
Here is our dilemma. If we as Patriotic Americans want to make sure that our country is not overrun by illegal aliens, then there must be a verifiable way to identify them and deport them. So how do we do that without trampling upon our own liberties?
It would take just a few of us, VOLUNTARILY, to wear ICE hats and clothing...and start yelling MIGRA MIGRA. You can pick out the illegals real easily....they will be the ones RUNNING AWAY. With law enforcement nearby to round them up....you gather up illegals.....with little effort....AND NO SURRENDER OF AMERICAN RIGHTS.
People like Lindsey Graham, John McCain, La Raza/Hispanic Ku Klux Klan, and others who support Illegal Alien Amnesty....are nothing more than ANTI-AMERICAN BIGOTS. You do not need to trample on American citizen rights to deport and kick out Illegal Aliens
Damn. I guess I am not getting fries with that.
These people are merely control freaks.... in fact its becoming obvious that their response to We the People’s outrage over their negligence is to double-down on more attempts to control us before we deal with them as should be done.
I do not get Gallagher in Orlando....so maybe you can summarize for us.....although not a big Gallagher fan, especially after he spent time coddling that satanic Fred Phelps from that Westboro Cult. Treasonous Grahamnesty should be no surprise
It should remind you of the old Soviet Union and Nazi Germany where work papers were required at all times.
And that phony BO'R loves the idea... shows you were he's at.
“Here's your work permit, Mr. Bill O’Reilly.”
“Oh thanks! This is so neat!”
“By the way, you say things we do not like on your show, so we are revoking your papers... here's a bread line chit. Have a nice day.”
We’ve served together as reserve JAGs, and his work ethic and legal judgment are excellent. I don’t know what he’s thinkin’ on these initiatives, because they fly in the face of national security.
“The real solution is the same as it has always been. Congress must secure the border first, and enforce e-verify. Illegal immigration is a problem caused by Federal non-enforcement of existing law.”
Roger Hedgecock is the best. Try to catch his show, he really gets into the core of issues.
This SOB needs to be fired at the earliest opportunity. Along with the rest of the statist/liberal idiots that seem to congregate in Washington. I’ll never understand how a state that can bring us a senator as great as Jim DeMint can also bring us this moron.
Mark of the Beast- step one.
How about a cartoon . . .
picturing Crackers with a huge mouth stuffed with a hugER stack of ID cards . . .
perhaps with a note that there’s more cards available for other . . . uhhh . . . orifi.
I’ve wondered for years if O’Reilly was a closet globalist stooge taking a ‘middle’ roader position only to come out at critical times on critical issues in behalf of globalism.
God have mercy.
Why are so many folks so ignorant of our leaders’ goals the last 100 years as outlined in their quotes?
I wouldn't be worried so much about that as the RFID they 'forgot' to tell you was in the card.
Agreed in principle, but abuse by tyrants is almost guaranteed. First we have to rid ourselves of those who would destroy our constitutional rights; that may take a while.
I still think the cure is worse than the disease.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.