That's a knee-jerk response. You should read the full decision. It is very clear that the 3rd Circuit Panel did "listen." They read and considered the briefs, cited each of the appellants' claims in their response, and took care to respond to each claim (citing precedents for their decisions) and even acknowledged the appellants' frustration with the whole process.
They read and considered the briefs, cited each of the appellants’ claims in their response, and took care to respond to each claim (citing precedents for their decisions) and even acknowledged the appellants’ frustration with the whole process.