Posted on 12/15/2010 5:58:48 PM PST by Sprite518
PFC Lawrence is accused of premeditated murder for the alleged shooting of Mullah Muhibullah on Oct. 17 while guarding him in Kandahar province, Afghanistan. Mullah Muhibullah was a senior Taliban commander and had been captured by U.S. forces the day before his death. Muhibullah's death was announced by an angry Afghan President Hamid Karzai on Oct. 19. Formal charges were filed against PFC Lawrence the same day, Oct. 19.
(Excerpt) Read more at michaelsavage.wnd.com ...
PFC Lawrence is accused of premeditated murder for the alleged shooting of Mullah Muhibullah on Oct. 17 while guarding him in Kandahar province, Afghanistan. Mullah Muhibullah was a senior Taliban commander and had been captured by U.S. forces the day before his death. Muhibullah's death was announced by an angry Afghan President Hamid Karzai on Oct. 19. Formal charges were filed against PFC Lawrence the same day, Oct. 19.
PFC Lawrence was medivaced out of Afghanistan on Oct. 24, and he arrived at Fort Carson, Colo. on Nov. 6. Though the Army had ordered a sanity inquiry on Nov. 5 to determine PFC Lawrence’s mental status and whether he is suffering from a major mental defect or disease, the Army decided not to wait for that answer before initiating the court-martial process in PFC Lawrence’s case. When the Army scheduled PFC Lawrence’s Article 32 Investigation (the equivalent to a preliminary hearing) for Nov. 29, the defense submitted two separate requests for a delay to enable the psychiatrists to determine PFC Lawrence’s mental status. Both delay requests were denied.
"We are going to an Article 32 for a kid who is hearing voices," James Culp, PFC Lawrence's attorney, said. The Article 32 Investigation proceeded on Nov. 29 and 30. As a result of his medication regiment, which includes the strongest does available of the drug prescribed for the treatment of schizophrenia, PFC Lawrence regularly fell asleep during the legal hearing that would ultimately decide if he will be court-martialed for premeditated murder. The "minimum" sentence for premeditated murder in the U.S. military is confinement for life. The maximum sentence is the death by execution.
Mr. Culp also said he was concerned the Army might be rushing the case to court-martial to appease Karzai. On Dec. 3, President Barak Obama made a surprise visit to Afghanistan to calm the tensions between the U.S. and Afghanistan that had been exacerbated by the killing of Taliban Commander Mullah Muhibullah. On the same day it was reported by Reuters that President Karzai and his brother have received large payments from the Taliban for the release of key Taliban prisoners. Coincidentally, on July 7, 2007, the Pajhwok Afghan News Agency reported that Muhibullah, Mullah Omar’s secretary, had already been captured. Neither U.S. nor Afghanistan officials have released any information about the process by which Muhibullah re-entered the stream of insurgency to kill and maim U.S. forces fighting in Afghanistan.
Less than a week before the shooting, PFC Lawrence was examined by psychiatrists and given drugs for depression and sleeplessness. Days later, he was put on guard duty at a detention center in the Arghandab district of Kandahar province, despite having no training for it.
Even before David requested to be taken for treatment to a combat stress clinic in Kandahar, David was reporting to his mother and father that he was hearing voices that were “freaking him out.” David subsequently reported to his family that his reoccurring hallucinations include seeing soldiers who had died in Afghanistan, including Capt. Dale Goetz. He told his father "... he could see the chaplain with only half a head remaining," Capt. Dale Goetz was a chaplain in the 4th Infantry Division for the 66th Armor Regiment’s 1st Battalion based out of Ft. Carson, Colorado. Capt. Goetz is the first Army chaplain killed in combat in 40 years. Capt. Goetz was David's friend. It was a known fact that David was closer to the chaplain than anyone else in the platoon.
This young man comes from a wonderful family and has very loving, caring parents who are undoubtedly afraid of what lies ahead. This is going to be a lengthy battle. Costs for specialists, travels to and from Colorado and all the costs involved with repeated weeklong stays there, medical evaluations and doctors are adding up.
This family needs help. Please show your support of PFC David Lawrence by making a contribution to his defense fund:
United Community Bank 19710 Stateline Road Lawrenceburg, IN 47025
Please make checks payable to "FOB PFC David W. Lawrence" Contributions can also be sent via paypal using the e-mail address: pfcdavidlawrence@yahoo.com
Any contribution, no matter how small is huge to the Lawrence family. Please keep PFC Lawrence and family in your prayers.
Ping
Wouldn't it be simpler to kill Karzai?
And there's why Karzai was so upset: He was hoping for a big-dollar ransom.
ping
Third eye Karzai, glad the other Mohamm is rotting with Mohmmad..
Bingo!
Agree... The guy is a corrupt thug. Imagine that?
BIngo!
The solution presents itself, and it is so simple!
I say an eye for an eye. Karzai released senior Taliban who were caught, this soldier should be treated and released.
http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE6AT2WG20101201
Bingo!
The solution presents itself, and it is so simple!
Strange, what kind of anti-depressants? Sometimes if given an anti psychotic or an anti dpressant IF the person, (in this case PFC Lawrenc) sometimes the brain will create the spymptomology the medication is supposed to reverse. Depends on a lot. This does happen and then the doctors would be liable for not only mis daignosing but giving a man with possibly nothing more than stress a drug or some type of polypharmacia that created this out of control situation in the first place. Yes, he pulled the trigger BUT he was told these meds, whatever they were would help. They only exacerbated the situation. I don't know law but this sounds very weird
It’s not even about his condition. What PFC Lawrence did I would’ve clearly done myself with a clear conscience.
Although I was not there and in his unit, I have been guarding him, on and off since he came back. I still see him and he is 100% of the time in a drugged and dazed condition that causes him hallucinations, unable to clearly speak or think straight. This to stop him from talking of any other details he knows that may be damaging to the gov.
This is about OUR PRESIDENT and various other politicians being complacent or PAID by the enemy - Karzai. These are the people that should be put on trial as TRAITORS and then EXECUTED.
Him being on guard that day was a completely random act as he was replacing another soldier. So there was nothing premeditated about it.
I agree with your post. it’s sad this PFC Lawrence is so messed up but he killed the enemy and he’s getting an article 32, if he loses that’s jail or out for good no prospects of jobs in a war sh*t full of treason all the way to the POTUS. Sad what you wrote. I wish i could speak openly about the mentally ill( worked a long time with them). What would be your suggestion if you had the power? I’d hate to see this kid at Ft Levenworth for 50 years, he needs help and a place to heal.
Formal news channel let us know that all soldiers in the unit will be asked to be in the trial, however today I found out his trial started on the period they sent him to the “mental hospital”.
I am clearly contemplating sacrificing my freedom for his. Soldiers need to support each other and the Army as a whole to stick it up the politicians’ butts. If I was a 4 star general, I would review the case, cancel the trial and declare him emotionally unstable.
PFC Lawrence did one thing I will never be able to do (med. cond.), avenge my battle buddies fallen in combat. In one 600lbs. bomb, I lost 5 people in my unit, 3 of which I knew, one was my section SSG. And he did much more considering the trades going on, saved the lives of countless soldiers.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.