Skip to comments.Why the Hurry? Obama's Loose Lips May Have Cost Us Valuable Intelligence
Posted on 05/11/2011 6:38:30 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
For a week, people have been asking, Why wont the president release Osama bin Ladens photo? Thats the wrong question. We should be asking, Why was Barack Obama in such a hurry to tell us bin Laden was dead?
The White House says the information in bin Ladens compound is the equivalent of a small college library, potentially containing incalculably valuable and unique data on al-Qaeda operations, personnel, and methods.
Its going to be great even if only 10 percent of it is actionable, a government official told Politicos Mike Allen.
Im no expert on such matters though Ive talked to several about this but even a casual World War II buff can understand that the shelf life of actionable intelligence would be extended if we hadnt told the whole world, and al-Qaeda in particular, that we had it.
Its a bit like racing to the microphones to announce youve stolen the other teams playbook before youve had a chance to use the information in the big game.
But thats exactly what President Obama did. He raced to spill the beans. The man couldnt even wait until morning. At just after 9:45 p.m., the White House communications director, Dan Pfeiffer, informed the media: POTUS to address the nation tonight at 10:30 p.m. Eastern Time.
The announcement came less than three hours after Obama had been informed that there was a high probability that bin Laden was dead and that the Navy SEAL helicopters had returned to Afghanistan.
In other words, it seems that the White House planned to crow as soon as possible. Why? Nobody Ive talked to can think of a reason that doesnt have to do with politics or hubris.
Yes, killing Osama bin Laden would have been a big secret that would have been hard to keep for long. Certainly, Pakistan would grow agitated if we simply said nothing about the incursion, though sweating the Janus-faced Pakistanis with silence for a couple of days might yield its own intelligence rewards. In other words, even waiting 24 hours might generate some interesting chatter. The Pakistanis working with al-Qaeda certainly would have been the first to spread the news that bin Laden was dead or captured.
But the real treasure trove is that college library of intelligence.
And while reports are pouring out from a gloating White House thats leaking like the Titanic in its final hours, one can only assume our analysts have barely begun to exploit the data. Couldnt they have at least tried to give the CIA a week, a day, even a few more hours to look at it all before letting Ayman al-Zawahiri and the rest of al-Qaeda know about it? Why give him the slightest head start to go even further underground?
Operation Neptune Spear was the culmination of years of patient intelligence-gathering. The CIA identified bin Ladens compound nearly ten months ago, in August 2010, and monitored it by satellite and from a secret safe house in Abbottabad at a cost of tens of millions of dollars.
And even that was breakneck speed compared with the years our government spent hunting bin Laden. In 2002, the CIA heard about a possible courier codenamed Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti. In 2004, it learned that he might have worked closely with bin Laden. It wasnt until 2007 that it got al-Kuwaitis real name. It took two more years to track him down to a specific region.
That, of course, barely skims the surface of American patience and sacrifice. Weve spent billions of dollars and lost numerous American and allied lives trying to defeat al-Qaeda. Those efforts have ripped apart our politics, from the debates over waterboarding and what some claim is torture to extraordinary rendition, black sites, and Guantanamo Bay. Some of those techniques and decisions seem to have led us to bin Ladens door.
Surely one more week of harmlessly searching hard drives while the public was kept in the dark wouldnt have been too great an additional burden. The White House would have still gotten their moment to preen and to ride their bump in the polls as far as they could. All they had to do is hold their tongues for a little while longer.
Obama says he wont release bin Ladens death photo for fear that American triumphalism might hurt American interests. Would that he had the same concern when it came to White House triumphalism.
Jonah Goldberg is editor-at-large of National Review Online and a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute
Everything Obama does is to advance his sorry bony a$$.
Good article. Makes a lot of sense.
Rule 1: Always protect methods and sources
Rule 2: Never let them know what you know.
Rule 3: Only violate Rule 1 and Rule 2 in order to mix in some disinformation that you want them to believe.
Rule 4: Never confirm or deny, see Rules 1 & 2.
Rule 5: Never use official channels to when implementing Rule 3, feed disinformation through putative leaks, see rule 4.
Isaiah 3 (New International Version, ©2011)
4 I will make mere youths their officials;
children will rule over them.
Good article. Why the hurry? - To continue building momentum for obama’s reelection campaign. So far, it seems to be working.
A small college library is how big?? What a stupid analogy. Why not just shut your mouth about anything that we gathered.
I wonder if the photos will come out before the election?
I wonder if the photos will come out before the election?
The mission was launched and carried out by Panetta, against CrapMan’s will. The rush by CrapMan to tell the world about it, once it had been successfully completed, was to give his fellow-ragheads a jump on changing tactics, plugging leads, etc. that would be available to the U.S. as soon as the info obtained in the mission was analyzed. If the mission had failed or fallen short in some significant way, CrapMan had a speech prepared in which he would have disowned ANY responsibility for it. And you can take that to the bank!
“Rule 1: Always protect methods and sources”
The prudent use of intelligence requires intelligence, an attribute sorely lacking in this “Mom, look what I did!” bunch of bozos.
I’m surprised Øbama hasn’t yet pulled out a hand puppet of the deceased Osama on the Øbama Tour.
I think, if the mission failed, we would NEVER have known that it took place.
Years ago a mafioso type we knew told us about being questioned by the authorities. They wanted to know if he knew about a certain thing. His answer:
“If I knew... YOU wouldn’t”
Think of the elements involved:
- Divulging as "Breaking News" of one of the most successful 'covert' operations ever, before even getting their internal facts and story straight!
- Turning the 'lights on' the operation BEFORE any review of acquired intelligence (supposedly a "large amount").
- Not even a chance 'TO POUNCE' on any newly discovered/located enemies as a result of newly gathered intelligence.
A real leader who's main primary interest is defending this country, would have held on to this information for far longer than the ONE SECOND that these anti-American socialists tripped over each other in doing.
The first rule of Intelligence Club: You Don’t Talk About Intelligence Club.
I now know exactly which special unit went in, when they did it, how they got there, what they did there, and what they did with the body afterwards. I even know the timeline of events and intelligence which eventually led them to the compound.
I don’t know what Obama got in English 101.
We know much more about Osama than we will ever know about Obama.
I heard some pundit type on the radio the other day talking about how sobering it was for Obama to make the decision to get Osama. Sobering because it could be his “Bay of Pigs”. Not because of the men’s lives at risk, but because of how it might affect him. He was talking like this was a plus to Obama—where he finally graduated to President. It turned me off more from a man I was already completed turned off by.
if anyone still thinks 0bama does anything to help the US, i would be shocked
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.