Posted on 08/16/2011 8:31:43 AM PDT by Clive
What was the cause of the riots in the United Kingdom?
This wasn’t a political riot. There wasn’t anything political about it. It wasn’t even race-on-race rioting. It was races rioting together — rioting against the state, and for themselves.
Last week, renowned British historian David Starkey made this point to the BBC: The rioting was just shopping with violence. People sensed a moment of lawlessness and impunity.
But Starkey’s point was an observation, not an explanation. How did thousands of people in the land of the Magna Carta, the land of liberty and law, simply decide to become petty little gangsters?
Starkey referred to a speech made in 1968 by a politician named Enoch Powell, who had warned about unlimited immigration to the U.K., using the phrase “rivers of blood.” Starkey said the violence predicted by Powell had come true — but it wasn’t race versus race.
It was various races together. “The whites have become black,” he said. “A particular sort of violent, destructive, nihilistic gangster culture has become the fashion.” Uh-oh.
Hundreds of people immediately filed censorship complaints against Starkey and the BBC, and he was widely condemned as a racist.
Perhaps Starkey could have been more careful; he said white had become black — and then immediately became more precise, meaning they had accepted a particular segment of black culture, namely gangsta rap. But his meaning was perfectly clear — to anyone who has listened to rap music, with its glorification of violence and material excess, and who has seen the glamourization of that lifestyle move from ghettos into the cultural mainstream.
What grown men wear hoodies in public? Or their underwear up high and their pants down low? Those aren’t crimes, of course — maybe fashion crimes. But far more serious is the set of values that has been swallowed along with the cultural touchstones of fashion and diction.
Gangsta culture calls women “hos” and “bitches,” a crude misogyny with an undercurrent of a threat of violence. It glamourizes fighting, shooting and even dying in gangland warfare. It holds that the point of wealth is to squander it on bling and champagne.
For some folks, it’s a joke. Take Sacha Baron Cohen, the British comic who created a character called Ali G — a twenty-something white kid trying so hard to be a gangsta.
It was a laugh riot, so over the top it was hilarious. Except that thousands of British kids decided that’s who they wanted to be when they grew up.
As U.K. Prime Minister David Cameron said on Monday, this isn’t just about mimicking some questionable role models. It has become a substitute moral code. Starkey accurately pointed out where it came from, and where it has gone.
When thousands of British thugs decide it’s not a fantasy anymore, but rather a code for living, that’s the time to blow the whistle.
Cameron’s right. This is a slow-motion moral collapse. And the solution is surely not banning rough music or comedy. But being free to talk about it openly, like David Starkey did, is part of the solution, not part of the problem.
In the 60s kids imitated hippies and peace festivals were everywhere... now kids imitate gangstas and crime and destruction is everywhere. The hippie movement looked to emasculate society (peaceful kids with long hair) whereas the gangsta rap looked to a brutalize society with its violent masculinity. Both are a protest against society and both are embraced by the left.
You mean festivals like Altamont?
From the article:”How did thousands of people in the land of the Magna Carta, the land of liberty and law, simply decide to become petty little gangsters? “
Things started going sideways in Great Britain after WWII when they began buying into socialism.
Thanks for posting it.
Save for later
You can’t have Crap without rap.
Yeah, but that festival had Hells Angels as security which was a bad idea — like putting the fox in charge of the hen house.
And wasn’t the Manson Family, technically hippies?
Good add on. This whole thing tells me that the only way to handle rioters is for the general public to get involved and beat the holy hell out of them.
Well, you can classify them in the same way as the Weather Underground: “terrorists” fighting the establishment. Manson was considered a guru (kissed the feet of Brian Wilson). But he thought he was ripped off and snubbed by the music industry and I think he staged the killings to look like it was part of an upcoming race war. Just my theory but I think he was getting back at the cool, hip Hollywood/media culture.
Despite the name Coolio's "Gangsta's Paradise" is a critique of the life-style, not a glorification. The opening lyrics:
As I walk through the valley of the shadow of death
I take a look at my life and realize there's nuthin' left
'Cuz I've been blasting and laughing so long, that
Even my mama thinks that my mind is gone
and the closing chorus
Tell me why are we, so blind to see
That the ones we hurt, are you and me
Tell me why are we, so blind to see
That the ones we hurt, are you and me
and even the tribute reference to Stevie Wonder's Pastime Paradise created by using the same melody and the same ironic use of "paradise", are a warning against the "gansta" life-style, not an invitation to join it.
I see groups of young white males in cowboy styles hanging out in the car wash most evenings. Closing my eyes while listening to them talk amongst themselves transports me to “da hood” - when I can hear them over the vulgarity blasting from their monster trucks.
When there are families with small children present I ask them to turn it down. They do so with a look that says my time is coming.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.