No Firearms Training = No God Given Rights in Wisconsin

Ammoland ^ | 19 October, 2011 | Corey Graff, Wisconsin Gun Owners

[marktwain]

I do not think this bill will get very far. The new CCW law goes into effect on November 1, in 12 days. Once the law has been in effect for a few months, there will be no going back.

I expect some firearms instructors are pushing this law for commercial gain.

[WKUHilltopper]

Gun training?? Criminals apparently need no training. Hell, it’s the original point and click...what’s so hard about that??

[SampleMan]

Gun training?? Criminals apparently need no training. Hell, it’s the original point and click...what’s so hard about that??

I shoot about 500 rds a month. I compete in IDPA pistol defense shoots. And if I get shot, it will likely be by a criminal that has fired less than 10 rds in their life.

You are correct. Firearms are point and shoot, not rocket science. Within 10' it all comes down to a willingness to pull the trigger.

[Condor51]

Well ..... some 'training' can be ... uh ... useful.

For instance, if you have a Revolver gun thingy, you may not know how to open that 'round do-hickey' where those bullet thingys go into. Or are they cartridges? Oh, never mind.. that's too technical. Anywho, even if you figure out on your own how to open 'it' by yourself -- don't try that at home children -- then you're faced the the question of ... Which end of the bullet gizmo do I put them in? The front or back? That's a real dilemma for first-timer idiot gun owners, and all liberals.

And if your first gun is an 'Automatic' ... HOLY CRAP! STOP! You will kill yourself. They are way too complicated for anyone except 'Trained Law Enforcement Personnel'. They have 'clips' and 'magazines' and 'slides' and 'safeties', or grip safeties, or other 'double safeties', and 'loaded chamber indicators' and ... well .. you see what I mean. Just fugetaboutit. Even with 'Training' those are way too complicated for anyone who didn't go to MIT, or ... become a Jail Guard. You'll kill yourself before you open your first box of ammunition. Aka: 'Bullets'.

[Flintlock]

The reason they are called “belly guns” is that they are usually pressed against the bad guy’s belly when they are fired.
“Training” and “accuracy” are not factors, here.

[Celerity]

Are there course requirements now ? Ct’s course requirements aren’t too bad. It usually lasts about 2 hours, 4 if the class is full of stupid people.

[PapaBear3625]

Within 10' it all comes down to a willingness to pull the trigger.

The majority of armed self defense encounters will occur in under 10' of distance.

Business robberies will occur across the distance of a counter. Street attacks will generally occur at arm's-reach distances where the winner will be the one who shoots first.

Training could be boiled down to a pamphlet which says "If you (or an innocent under your protection) are not in danger of death or serious injury, do not draw your gun."

Having more CCWs on the street is a greater social good than having fewer CCWs, even if the fewer have been to class.

[Okieshooter]

Oklahoma requires ab 8 hr. course for CCW and while I understand the concerns about requiring it I am glad that I went through it. As a lifetime gun owner most of the gun safety stuff was just review for me, but I learned a lot about what my rights and responsibilities were when carrying.

There is a lot more to it than just buying a gun, loading it and putting it in your pocket. Many think it makes them into a vigilante and nothing could be further than the truth.

[PapaBear3625]

Oklahoma requires ab 8 hr. course for CCW and while I understand the concerns about requiring it I am glad that I went through it. As a lifetime gun owner most of the gun safety stuff was just review for me, but I learned a lot about what my rights and responsibilities were when carrying.

Pennsylvania does not require any sort of training. I've gone through over 100 classroom hours of formal training over the years, in addition to hundreds of hours of range time. The assumption is that, unless training is mandatory, that people will not get training.

My objection is for government making training a prerequisite for CCW.

[SampleMan]

Well ..... some 'training' can be ... uh ... useful.

Useful and fun. However, all a person actually must know about a double-action revolver is to point the muzzle at the target and pull the trigger until it goes bang.

Like I said, I practice as much as I can, and shoot IDPA, but I know that most gun fights don't require reloading, shooting on the run, taking on 5 bad guys, etc.

We who enjoy firearms like to think of them and our knowledge of them as special and nuanced, but the truth is that guns are utilitarian in nature.

I think of it like this. It is useful to have experience and practice changing flat tires, but when you are out in the wilderness with a flat, it is CRITICAL that you actually have a spare tire and a jack. Along those lines, it is stupid to require people to practice changing tires before they are legally allowed to have a spare tire and jack in their vehicle.

[PapaBear3625]

I went and looked up what news articles there were for Wisconsin CCW. Over here is an article about a local police dept holding classes over the next few weekends. The upside is the class is held by the police dept, so I'm thinking you could submit your paperwork on the day of the class. The downside is that the class is limited to 15 people "first come, first served". We'll see if that produces a bottleneck.

The other downside is the $100 charge for training, on top of the $50 CCW application fee.

[jrd]

does my training in the Army count?

[USS Alaska]

I've had a CCW since the 70s and in my first few years I wondered what would happen if I tried to shoot through a closed window in my car.

I knew a guy with an auto junk yard, and paid him to be allowed to shoot through some windows.

With protective face gear and ear plugs, I sat in a junker and fired out through the windows, and it was OK but even with ear plugs, the noise was deafening.

If required to save my life, I'd shoot with the windows up, but given any choice at least one would be down.

Training is not required to shoot within 10', but the will to pull the trigger with a human being in the sights, is not just a "point and click" and if you pull it, you better use it.

[FateAmenableToChange]

Oklahoma requires ab 8 hr. course for CCW and while I understand the concerns about requiring it I am glad that I went through it. As a lifetime gun owner most of the gun safety stuff was just review for me, but I learned a lot about what my rights and responsibilities were when carrying.

I had a permit in PA with no training, and a permit in another state that accepted demonstration of training in lieu of having to go to the course. To get a permit where I currently live, I had to go through $125 worth of the most incompetent drivel I've heard from any "trainer."

Lines from the "trainer" like: "A .380 glaser is so powerful that it will blow the arm clean off the bad guy if you hit him in the shoulder."

and "In my opinion, Bersa makes one of the finest firearms on the planet. It's good that not too many people know that or they'd cost more."

And then the trainer covered me twice with said loaded .380 Bersa that he had whipped out of his concealed carry holster so that he could show it to the girl in the tight afghan sweater.

Also, they explained the law incorrectly and the legal section of the class devolved into stupid "what if's". 8 hours of my life I will never get back.

Training is good. Mandatory state training is bad. Mandating it won't make it better, and won't educate people who view the training only as an obstacle they have to get through in order to get a permit.

[Dick Tater]

Nice ridiculously hyperbolic example.

And the income tax was only supposed to be on a very few people and 1%-2% max. Why do you assume that once you submit, the rules will not change - and they most surely will?

[LevinFan]

No shlt. At ten feet, my aim is pretty good even without my glasses.

Still, anyone who refuses to be trained and screw up should have the book thrown at them. A few hours training isn’t the end of the world. If something is important to you, you make the time.
The claim about single mothers is not more valid than the claims about voter id laws stealing the right to vote. Everyone on FR tends to think id laws are great, and voting is the most fundamental right well have.

[facedown]

I expect some firearms instructors are pushing this law for commercial gain.

Bingo. I know a bunch of them.

[Jack of all Trades]

All the firearms training that’s going to stick can be accomplished in five minutes by the seller when the gun is picked up.

You just can’t teach common sense, like “hey don’t point that muzzle at me just because your chubby little fingers don’t have the strength to pull the slide back far enough to ensure that it goes into battery!” Seen it.

[Atlas Sneezed]

I had to go through $125 worth of the most incompetent drivel I’ve heard from any “trainer.”

---

I recall the trainer in NV trying to convince Mrs. B. that it would be unlawful to use a gun to prevent being raped.

I’ve had trainers say that it is absolutely immoral and wrong to leave your house with any gun not properly locked up. It would take forever if I did that!

[Atlas Sneezed]

Aside from the kind of safety training that one can condense to a postcard, what’s more important than training is PRACTICE.