I dunno. Ask a priest. My argument had nothing directly to do with Christianity. Since atheism, not Christianity is a significant issue part and parcel of the Emo issue, I brought it up. A relevant topic to the discussion. Christianity is not as the majority of Emos are demonstratively anti religious. I also brought up drug use, nomo/bisexuality, crime, self mutilation, lying, broken homes, and a dozen other issues even more of a problem. But two posters on this thread seem to want to make this about Christianity. You care to explain why that is?
Likewise, the original topic of the thread, murdered Emo kids, has squat to do with other subcultures of kids so what exactly is the point in bring them up here? They are not relevant to the discussion. At all.
Maybe all emos claim atheism (although I hate to make broad brush statements about something like “all participants in emo”) but not all atheists claim emos.
Christianity does matter due to its gospel claims. If somebody’s house is on fire, are you going to say someone with a truck and a hose is not relevant?