I believe you are correct, and that this thread was started with the specific goal of calling the CCP's findings into question and muddying the waters.
I'm done with this one, and there are a couple of n00bs (I know, I know, I'm one too) that I'll be paying very close attention to in the future. LorenC managed to haunt the eligibility threads for quite some time as the retread known as "Obama Exposer" before finally being zotted.
Sometimes I can’t resist feeding them either... Perhaps what I should say is don’t indulge their theories - just confront them with the cold, hard, facts.
As you can see I couldn’t resist one more post to one of the apparent trolls myself, so I suppose one could call me a bit of a hypocrite today. I’m just tired of these paid or volunteer propagandists assuming people are so stupid that they wouldn’t see through half of their BS when they pretend to be so confused, but yet “know so much”. Especially when their buddies come to save them when they get too much flak they can’t talk their way out of.