Racial Litmus Test

The jury will soon decide the guilt or innocence of George Zimmerman, the man charged with murder in the death of Trayvon Martin, but a verdict will not end the debate about this case that has raged from the beginning.

Like the O.J. Simpson trial nearly two decades ago, the Zimmerman trial has become a litmus test on race. And the media have played a major role in pushing race as the underlying issue, to the detriment of all concerned.

From the beginning, the media played up the racial angle. People magazine's coverage was typical. A cover story in April 2012 featured pictures of Martin's childhood as "an adorable tot," "budding scholar" and at family gatherings where, the magazine noted, "he was always the first to arrive and the last to leave."

Only one photograph in the story showed a version of Martin as the 17-year-old George Zimmerman actually encountered the night he killed him: A framed photo of Martin in a hoodie being held by the teenager's grieving parents.

And that hoodie summarized the prevailing media storyline: "On Feb. 26 Trayvon's unwavering taste for hoodie couture may have proved deadly." In other words, if you're young and black and wear hooded sweatshirts, beware: Crazy white people may try to kill you.

Which comes to the issue of George Zimmerman's race. Zimmerman's picture also appeared in the People magazine story as it did ubiquitously: an unsmiling, unshaved man in an orange, jail-issue jumpsuit. When the first stories appeared, Zimmerman was identified as white; only later, when it turned out that his mother was an immigrant from Peru, did most news stories refer to him as a white Hispanic or white and Hispanic.

While Hispanics may be of any race, the media usually treat the term as if it were its own racial category, so the decision to attach "white" to the designation is not common practice. But the designation was important to making race a central issue in the case. If Zimmerman were simply "Hispanic," or had he been black, then the killing would never have become a national story.

The homicide rate for black males 14 to 17 years old is the second highest of any group -- 31 homicides per 100,000 population, compared with only 4.5 percent for whites of the same age in 2008, the last year for which data are available -- exceeded only by the rate for black males 18 to 25, which was nearly three times higher.

Blacks commit the overwhelming majority of black homicides -- 93 percent in 2008, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics. But stories of black-on-black crime don't get much play, nor do stories in which perpetrator and victim are from differing minority groups. But portray the killer as an armed, white man in pursuit of any young black male he thinks might be about to commit a crime, and the case becomes a metaphor for white racism.

Will any of this matter to the jurors? We can only hope not. But no matter what verdict they render, the likelihood is many people will view it through a racial prism. In a poll taken in late May, a plurality of blacks, 47 percent, said they believed that Zimmerman should be found guilty of second-degree murder. Whites were far more likely to believe that Zimmerman acted in self-defense, with most whites saying Zimmerman should be acquitted.

Trayvon Martin's killing was a tragedy. But not every killing involving a black victim is about race, even if the person who pulled the trigger was from a different racial group. If the media had stuck to the facts and not played the race card, the debate over this case might have focused more on ways the death might have been avoided -- which would have included both Martin and Zimmerman behaving differently that fateful night. Instead, the media have encouraged young black men to believe they all have bullseyes on their backs.

The media has been irresponsible in their reporting and how they framed the debate in this case.

Then again, the media puts a liberal spin on everything.

If the race/ethnicity were reversed in this case, it never would have seen a courtroom.

If both had been of the same race/ethnicity, this case would never have seen a courtroom.

If Zimmerman had been black, and Trayvon a “white Hispanic”, this case would never have been in court.

This case didn’t even hit the national news until about a month after it happened. Race baiting liberal bloggers kept pushing the case, and finally, the national media decided to push the story. There’s no way the national media pushes a local shooting case such as this one, without the racial angle they decided to push.

OJ trial - upon acquittal, those celebrating MAYBE got a sideways glance, MAYBE a dirty look...

Zimmerman trial - upon acquittal, those celebrating will get a 6 on 1 beatdown.

Chicago has been known to have up to 50 shootings in a weekend, with some of them actual first degree murders of young black men being chased, hunted and executed with malice. But the media could care less, because the shooters were also black. Blame the guns and the southern states. It’s true; only when it’s white-on-black crime is it a story.

The media is not going to let up all weekend, and next week until there’s a verdict. In case there’s one person who was in a coma for the past few months and hasn’t heard about it yet.

The media want a riot, so they can say things like “years of frustration and anger were unleashed “
instead of “roving bands of savages burned cars, smashed store windows and stole merchandise, and pulled innocent Whites from cars and beat them”

I was on the mall in Charlottesville, VA when the OJ verdict came down. Lots of screaming, whooping it up, a party atmosphere. A local TV station talking head stuck a microphone in my face to ask my reaction. I did react...I told him to get the %&$# thing out of my face. That was as ‘riotous’ as it got on the part of those of us who knew he got away with murder.

the Zimmerman trial has become a litmus test on race.

Actually incorrect.
It is a litmus test on whether we allow politics to lead us by the nose or we follow the rule of law.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.