Skip to comments.Meteor Shower over North America a Dud (Camelopadalids)
Posted on 05/24/2014 10:56:17 AM PDT by Jack Hydrazine
Cape Town: Astronomers and amateur sky watchers across North America went to bed early Saturday disappointed by a meteor shower hyped as "potentially spectacular" that, in the end, was a dud.
The US Naval Observatory described the Camelopardalids meteor shower on Friday as a "potentially spectacular show," but that potential was never fulfilled.
The meteor shower could be seen by people in the United States, Canada and Mexico starting around 0230 GMT Saturday, according to NASA.
A weak showing, combined with passing clouds and light pollution from towns and cities, conspired to turn what many hoped would be a light show extravaganza into a sleepless night of stargazing punctuated by occasional streaks of light.
The best photos posted online on sites like Flickr, including those from NASA, show a sky lit with stars with occasional streaks of light.
NASA had a live feed camera pointed towards the sky, but despite the site's upbeat music there was little to see.
The #Camelopardalis were a bust," read a posting on Twitter. "From 12:45am-4:30am EDT: 12 small faint ones, 1 bright one, & 1 sporadic. I stayed up for this?"
One Twitter user wrote: "#Camelopardalis. More like #Cantopenmyeyelinds when my alarm goes off at 8 am."
In their defense, astronomers weren't entirely sure what to expect from a comet they only discovered in 2004.
"Meteor showers are like the weather. They are a little bit hard to predict," said Paul Wiegert, associate professor at the University of Western Ontario.
This meteor shower originates from the trail of dust behind a small, dim comet known as 209P/Linear. The debris gets tugged into Earth's orbit this year by the force of gravity from Jupiter.
Meteor showers consist of space rocks that burn up upon hitting the top of Earth's atmosphere, producing a bright flash of light that gives the appearance of a falling star.
A key piece of this meteor shower mystery lies in the ancient trail of dust behind the comet, which was produced centuries ago.
Initial predictions were that a few hundred meteors would be visible per hour, or a few meteors per minute -- "not a special-effects extravaganza ... but it is in line with many of the strong annual meteor showers," Wiegert told AFP.
The annual Perseids meteor show that lasts for several days in August is made up of shooting stars that barrel by at a pace of 150,000 miles (241,000 kilometers) per hour.
The Camelopardalids meteors moved slower, traveling at around 36,000 miles (58,000 kilometers) per hour, Cooke said.
The show did not impress "Space Junkie," who wote on Twitter: dear #Camelopardalis ... thanks for the meteor-less yawn factory. take notes from the #persedis this july."
Astronomers flew in from Europe to observe the skies from a remote astronomy base in Saskatchewan, Canada, Cooke said, while others traveled to the US southwest where the forecast was for clear weather.
I fell for this and stayed up late last night and into the early morning. Didn’t see ONE meteor which is unusual for Arizona. LOL! These “scientists” need to stick to telling us about how bad “global warming” is going to be.
I was watching the video right up until the starting time.
I fell asleep about 30 minutes into the max, without seeing even one shooting star.
Granted that was via the internet view, but what a less than exciting event.
I dunno, but for some reason "cameltoe" comes to mind ...
I was going to look, but it was too cloudy here.
I am glad that the skies were overcast in the Denver area. Every time they hype the biggest and best-est ever it’s always a bust.
My husband and I, (Phx, AZ) went out at about 10:20pm, they said we’d be able to see it about 10:30. I figure shooting stars show up fashionably early.
They touted this event in the news several times as going to be big big big...
Stayed out there on our lawn chairs till about midnight, drank champagne. That was the only event of the eve.
Not ONE sighting.
Cloud Out ,here
The only thing I got out of watching the sky last night is a sore neck.
I sat out at 3AM for over an hour. Nice clear skies.
Just like the way they hype movies!
Best ever display was(years ago)viewing the Perseid meteor shower out in the Mojave desert.
Last night was like waiting for The Great Pumpkin : )
Maybe global warming scared the meteors away? LOL!
My favorites are the Perseids and the Leonids.
That’s quite a leap of association, from the stratosphere to the bedroom!
Figured as much. I was going to try to stay up, but decided on bed instead. Looks like I made the right choice.
I counted about 10/hour from 1-3am, and went to sleep.
Listening to the meteor radar this morning about 1 hour after sunrise there were hundreds of pings per hour till about 11am.
So, the forecast was early. Might be worth a look tonight from sunset on.
To be fair, it was reporters who ginned up the story, which is typical. All of the astronomy sites I looked at said it was very questionable.
Listening to Meteors Radio Detection
Live audio feed with instructions.
THE MSFC ONLINE METEOR RADAR
(two audio streams here.)
Listening to it right now and they are still coming in.
Nothing on the Big Island, and it was a beautiful, star-studded night.
“Meteor showers are like the weather. They are a little bit hard to predict,” said Paul Wiegert, associate professor at the University of Western Ontario.
What? The Global Warmists can predict things a century in advance.
We had cloudy, overcast skies with rain showers, so there was nothing for us to miss. I’d rather have the rain. However, I was going to set up the telescope to watch meteorites hitting the moon.
I went out to look and, instead, saw something I found to be *far* more spectacular...a dark back yard filled with countless fireflies. (I just moved back to West TN after having lived in other parts of the country for the past 30 years - I figured it was time to get away from the city).
Oh ... that’s where all the fireflies went. I’ve been wondering since there are a lot fewer than when I was a kid.
Cloudy and cool in my location, too!
If you like your meteor showers you can keep your meteor showers...period!
It was global warming that ruined it.
I was looking for on-line reports of lunar meteorite impacts associated w/ this shower, but didn’t find much.
Some prior articles stated that the Moon’s waning crescent phase would make it favorable for these events, but it seemed to me that a waxing crescent phase —just after New— would be better, where the leading (visible) Terminator was plowing into the stream...
I did see one that was definitely not sporadic and part of the shower, falling under Polaris, at least -1 magninude, and left a train. I MAY have seen another one, that was a bright spot of light that brightened then dimmed. This is a fairly rare event, because that type of meteor is basically aligned right at you! But, generally the thing was generally a complete dud.
I blame this on myself. Conditions were perfect. Had it been cloudy here, or had I NOT looked for them, it would have been spectacular, a once-in-200 years event...:)
Using a night vision monocular I saw many little, faint streaks. Not one exciting one via unaided eye. I stayed out from 1:30 EST to 4AM. What a dud.
a dark back yard filled with countless fireflies.
Fireflies in Forest, Smoky Mountains, Tennessee
Same thing here in north cental Ohio.I went out at 3AM,spent 30 minutes looking-saw nothing.
It was a lot like watching wine age....but less fun.
What did we learn? Never, never trust an astronomer. I bet they beat their children too.
Hey, it’s just gettin’ started. :’) It’s really a matter of timing, and comets don’t shed uniformly during their transits. Some of the named annual showers in the mid-19th century were spectacular, and people awaited them, until one year they basically didn’t show up. There was barely a peep out of them until well into the 20th century. Thanks Jack Hydrazine, extra to APoD.
Comet to pass by Earth closely after meteor shower
view the comet online:
Cool! Do you have a link where we can watch it live?