[Michael.SF.]

I can’t see him being approved by the senate for the supreme court.

I could. Here is why: The Senate would argue (internally) that since it is a lifetime appointment, we will be able to wash our hands of him.

The man would be a solid right vote, but he would not be able to influence others on the court to agree with him.

[PghBaldy]

Interesting points. You might have something there.