Looks like a very courteous thing to do and has nothing whatsoever to do with religion. (Add appropriate expression of frustration with dolts).
Posted on 01/11/2002 8:08:17 AM PST by Native American Female Vet
Federal judge in Seattle rejects challenge to mandatory bowing in judo
By Associated Press, 1/11/2002 11:31
SEATTLE (AP) Requiring judo contestants to bow before a picture of the founder of the Japanese martial art does not violate freedom of religion, a federal judge ruled.
In a 13-page ruling, U.S. District Judge Robert S. Lasnik said three Seattle-area residents could be required to observe the ritual while participating in competitions.
James and Leilani Akiyama, 17 and 14, and Jay Drangeid, 40, all of Bellevue, had fought the rule, saying it amounted to a religious ritual being imposed on them. A 1997 injunction has allowed the three to compete in U.S. judo matches without performing the ritual.
''Virtually any restriction or regulation imposed by a public accommodation could impinge upon a person's religious beliefs,'' Lasnik wrote in dismissing the injunction Thursday.
Jim Bregman, president of the Colorado-based U.S. Judo Association, one of several organizing groups for the sport, praised the ruling.
''It's clear the bow in judo is simply a respectful act, like a handshake in wrestling,'' Bregman said. John Holm, the Akiyamas' stepfather and operator of a judo training center, said they might appeal the decision.
''We have a half-dozen Muslim kids who want to compete in the state championships coming up January 26 and they can't compete because of their religious beliefs,'' Holm said.
Competitors in judo, which has its roots in Shintoism, bow several times during competitions, usually to a portrait of Jigoro Kano, the Japanese founder of the sport. Bowing is mandatory in international competitions.
It's just plain stupid to see something like this even being discussed in a courtroom.
Looks like a very courteous thing to do and has nothing whatsoever to do with religion. (Add appropriate expression of frustration with dolts).
Good. Screw 'em. That's all we need are a bunch of martial arts proficient Muslims running around the U.S.
I understand that, it's just that being immersed in Japanese culture gets very tiring after a while. It all just seems so silly.
Tae Kwon Do seems to fall into two types: The more traditional stuff, and the guys who want to sell you a blackbelt for $5k.
I once had a really great Tae Kwon Do instructor. We bowed, but we used English. He was tough, but everyone learned a lot. Not a whole lot of traditional mumbo-jumbo, but everyone was serious about learning anyway.
Unfortunately he was a scumbag outside the gym and ended up in prison for killing someone over drugs.
All in all, I think I like aikido and Jujitsu better -- but most of the guys teaching it seem pretty wierded out.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.