Posted on 07/26/2006 3:18:25 PM PDT by NYer
ping
I think I'll stay with the Roman version, and spare myself the base alloy of Amchurch modernism.
ping
Why would you believe that the new American version of the catechism is going to be at odds or be any less than the Roman version? If they are both Roman Catholic and approved as such by the church, I would think there would be 100% agreement in all areas.
I see you share my dubious thoughts on this. I see that there are comments about the Bishops approval, but was it approved by the Vatican? THAT will be the standard on which I base my decision on whether or not to purchase it.
I do not trust the USCCB. The Roman Catholic bishops are in the minority.
**approved by the Vatican? **
Agree with you here!!
Lilllabettt wrote: "I've never seen Cesar Chavez on a list of "exemplary Catholics" before. Perhaps he was. But I associate him with zeal for leftist politics, not zeal for the faith." Same for Dorothy Day. The inclusion of these two is a cause of concern for me. I have zero faith in the USCCB.
Bernardin? Cesar Chavez? Aggh.
Dorothy Day, whom I knew personally, was actually an extremely devout Catholic. She was a pacifist and had a sort of utopian-agrarian-community ideal, not unlike Chesterton and many other Catholic intellectuals of her time and a little before. Before becoming a Catholic, she had been a Communist, and the Worker unfortunately became a magnet for all sorts of flakes during the Vietnam War (think Berrigan Brothers). But she herself was not a flake, was enormously, traditionally pious and had a great devotion to the Blessed Sacrament.
Agree with you here!!
This is from the USCCB website:
The adult catechism was approved overwhelmingly by the bishops at their November, 2004 general meeting and received the necessary recognitio from the Holy See in November of 2005.
United States Catholic Catechism for Adults Available July 31
I don't understand why we just can't go with the Roman one. Why do we need another one?
Yikes. How do you think they stay in power if they cause this kind of reaction by a lay Roman Catholic? Don't you think it would get back to Rome and they would do something about it? They serve at the appointment of the Pope, I believe.
We be not smart enough for big book.
Considering how many millions of copies of the Catechism have been purchased, I wonder if there is much of a market for this abbreviated version.
I like the Catechism.
Oh, is that it? LOL!Considering how many millions of copies of the Catechism have been purchased, I wonder if there is much of a market for this abbreviated version.
Not in my plans to buy one. I'm with you, I like the one I already have.
Excuse my lousy editing on last post to you.
There was nothing wrong with the Baltimore Catechism. The US did not need a new catechism. The USCCB just wanted to distract everyone from their lack of backbone while wasting more $$ from the faithful.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.