Replies

Roman Catholics place the Pope’s interpretation of Scripture above all else for matters of faith and practice.

your statemetn shows common Protestant mis-information on what The Church actually teaches. It's not "the Pope's interpretation" -- all that we believe is a belief of The Church as a whole. This is not the pope's personal interpretation.

Any statement ex-cathedra comes from the council of bishops and MUST be supported by scripture and holy tradition.

When we argue about this sacrament or that doctrine, the Protestant appeals to a verse from the Bible, or a group of verses. The Roman Catholic appeals to the Pope’s or the Holy See’s statements. --> that's again incorrect. We argue from scripture, not from some pope's statements. There's a lovely thread here that explains the illogicality of sola scriptura.

Well, I disagree with you, obviously. For example, such doctrines as Mary’s immaculate conception; or the perfection of the saints whose good works outweigh their sins and so they have extra grace to dispense; purgatory; these don’t have a biblical basis. They are based on church tradition and so forth.

I also should add the what Roman Catholics and what Protestants believe constitute the Bible differs. Roman Catholics accept the Apogrypha as part of the canon; we don’t. However, I have not seen much doctrinal differences based on that in my time, so I don’t know how much of a factor that is.

I was addressing your point that Roman Catholics place the Pope’s interpretation of Scripture above all else for matters of faith and practice.

This is NOT the Pope's interpretation -- none of our doctrine is the work of one Man besides Jesus Christ. The Pope's personal opinion does not make our doctrine.

Secondly, you said that When we argue about this sacrament or that doctrine, the Protestant appeals to a verse from the Bible, or a group of verses. The Roman Catholic appeals to the Pope’s or the Holy See’s statements. --> we don't appeal to the Pope's or the Holy See's statements as the reasoning for doctrine.

Church doctrines are formed in council, the Church as a whole is what interprets scripture.

And your examples are also examples of what Protestants are told that the Church believes, but we don't, as you would find in the Catechism of The Catholic Church, you would find correct definitions of what we do -- and it will surprise you, as it surprises even many life-long Catholics!