You wrote:
“There is something “dark” about his writing, while I find Lewis always refreshing, with perhaps the exception of “That Hideous Strength,” and, “The Screwtape Letters.””
I agree that That Hideous Strength is dark, but I always found The Screwtape Letters rather “light” - even though it is about demons and temptation.
“On what do you base your opinion that Tolkien is the better author. Is it objective, or just a personal opinion? Just curious.”
I think - when it came to fiction - Tolkien was a more able, more sophisticated author. Lewis was effective, but I don’t think he was evocative or able to build a complex story like Tolkien. Lewis went, generally, for obvious allegorical fairy tales while Tolkien built an entire other world.
Both were great writers. Lewis was especially good at turning a phrase. Mind you, Lewis - when it comes to turning a phrase - is a distant second to GK Chesteron!
Hank
Yes, “The Scrwtape Letters,” were “light” fare, but I only mentioned them as perhaps less “uplifting” then other works by Lewis.
Don’t think I know Chesterton well enough to compare him with Lewis, or vice-versa. Do enjoy Chesterton though.
You may be right about Tolkien’s ability with plots. I frankly do not know.
Getting a little hard to concentrate here, lots of fireworks. Hope you enjoy your Fourth.
Hank