The parishoners are the church and innocents will pay along with the guilty. The only ones who should pay for a crime are the ones who commited the crime and those who covered for them.
Stockholders and employees in Enron and Worldcom and Anderson paid pretty dearly. So they should never have been prosecuted.
How will the parishioners "pay?" Drive another 1/2 mile to the next church? It is not like they will be hit up for "their part" of the judgment.