We have to give up birthright citizenship for those with non native parents.
Dubai and the UAE does this. They import skilled workers from around the world through very low tax policy but none of those workers can ever hope to get the same benefits that the Emiratis who are natives get, unless they marry a native, and even then it is conditional.
We are the only country on earth that allows non citizens to get the benefits they do by being in America
"give up", or deny retroactively? Article V Convention?