Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Why Not Separate Marriage and State? ZOT! And ZOT Again!
National Review ^ | 3/29/13 | John Fund

Posted on 06/04/2014 10:19:50 AM PDT by Iced Tea Party

Cultural civil war can be avoided by getting government out of marriage

There is no question that the media, political, and cultural push for gay marriage has made impressive gains. As recently as 1989, voters in avant-garde San Francisco repealed a law that had established only domestic partnerships.

But judging by the questions posed by Supreme Court justices this week in oral arguments for two gay-marriage cases, most observers do not expect sweeping rulings that would settle the issue and avoid protracted political combat. A total of 41 states currently do not allow gay marriage, and most of those laws are likely to remain in place for some time. Even should the Court declare unconstitutional the Defense of Marriage Act, which defines marriage as between a man and a woman for federal purposes, we can expect many pitched battles in Congress. The word “spouse” appears in federal laws and regulations a total of 1,138 times, and many of those references would have to be untangled by Congress absent DOMA.

No wonder Wisconsin’s GOP governor Scott Walker sees public desire for a Third Way. On Meet the Press this month he remarked on how many young people have asked him why the debate is over whether the definition of marriage should be expanded. They think the question is rather “why the government is sanctioning it in the first place.” The alterative would be to “not have the government sanction marriage period, and leave that up to the churches and the synagogues and others to define that.”

Governor Walker made clear these thoughts weren’t “anything I’m advocating for,” but he gave voice to many people who don’t think the gay-marriage debate should tear the country apart in a battle over who controls the culture and wins the government’s seal of approval. Gay-marriage proponents argue that their struggle is the civil-rights issue of our time, although many gays privately question that idea. Opponents who bear no animus toward gays lament that ancient traditions are being swept aside before the evidence is in on how gay marriage would affect the culture.

Both sides operate from the shaky premise that government must be the arbiter of this dispute. Columnist Andrew Sullivan, a crusader for gay marriage, has written that “marriage is a formal, public institution that only the government can grant.” But that’s not so. Marriage predates government. Marriage scholar Lawrence Stone has noted that in the Middle Ages it was “treated as a private contract between two families . . . For those without property, it was a private contract between two individuals enforced by the community sense of what was right.” Indeed, marriage wasn’t even regulated by law in Britain until the Marriage Acts of 1754 and 1835. Common-law unions in early America were long recognized before each state imposed a one-size-fits-all set of marriage laws.

The Founding Fathers avoided creating government-approved religions so as to avoid Europe’s history of church-based wars. Depoliticizing religion has mostly proven to be a good template for defusing conflict by keeping it largely in the private sphere.

Turning marriage into fundamentally a private right wouldn’t be an easy task. Courts and government would still be called on to recognize and enforce contracts that a couple would enter into, and clearly some contracts — such as in a slave-master relationship — would be invalid. But instead of fighting over which marriages gain its approval, government would end the business of making distinctions for the purpose of social engineering based on whether someone was married. A flatter tax code would go a long way toward ending marriage penalties or bonuses. We would need a more sensible system of legal immigration so that fewer people would enter the country solely on the basis of spousal rights.

The current debate pits those demanding “marriage equality” against supporters of “traditional marriage.” But many Americans believe it would be better if we left matters to individuals and religious bodies. The cherished principle of separating church and state should be extended as much as possible into separating marriage and state. Ron Paul won many cheers during his 2012 presidential campaign when he declared, “I’d like to see all governments out of the marriage question. I don’t think it’s a state decision. I think it’s a religious function. I am supportive of all voluntary associations and people can call it whatever they want.”

Supporters of traditional marriage know the political winds are blowing against them. A new Fox News poll finds 49 percent of voters favoring gay marriage, up from just 32 percent a decade ago. And among self-described conservatives under 35, Fox found support for gay marriage is now at 44 percent. Even if the Supreme Court leaves the battle for gay marriage to trench warfare in the states, the balance of power is shifting. Rush Limbaugh, a powerful social conservative, told his listeners this week: “I don’t care what this court does with this particular ruling. . . . I think the inertia is clearly moving in the direction that there is going to be gay marriage at some point nationwide.”

But a majority of Americans still believe the issue of gay marriage should be settled by the states and not with Roe v. Wade–style central planning. It might still be possible to assemble a coalition of people who want to avoid a civil war over the culture and who favor getting government out of the business of marriage.

— John Fund is national-affairs columnist for NRO.


TOPICS: Constitution/Conservatism; Culture/Society; Government; Philosophy
KEYWORDS: freedom; fusroduh; homosexualagenda; limitedgovernment; marriage; nuclearfamily; samesexmarriage; smallgovernment; smashthepatriarchy; ursulathevk; waronmarriage; zot
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 361-380381-400401-420421-426 next last
To: TheOldLady; jazusamo; Norm Lenhart; ConorMacNessa; Arrowhead1952; Viking2002
Don't Play with Dragon Fire!

Dragons from Game of Thrones

And More Smaug

I would also advice you OldLady to listen to this rendition from the Hobbit.

It's a Little Long but VERY good.

It summarizes the Movie in Song.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P8ymgFyzbDo

381 posted on 06/05/2014 5:20:20 PM PDT by KC_Lion (Build the America you want to live in at your address, and keep looking up.- Sarah Palin)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 350 | View Replies]

To: KC_Lion; TheOldLady

This actually makes me sad......we had a turtle named Fred who looked like Gamera. We had him ten years. He got very sick a few months ago. Never came out of hibernation to speak of, and we even converted a garden tub in the master bath as an infirmary. We used every med available. It was as sterile as a hospital in there. NASA could have saved a terminally irradiated astronaut from Mars if they’d have transferred him here. We moved into another bath to accommodate him. We lost him on Monday. Poor old guy. We got him when he was the size of a bottle cap. I built a hardwood casket and we buried him deeply under an English holly tree in our front yard, in front of his favorite window, and marked it with a stepping stone and solar lights. Now all we have is a 110 gallon tank and his favorite perching rocks to remember him by. Not to mention enough aquatic pumps and lighting to sterilize and filter Lake Michigan.


382 posted on 06/05/2014 5:38:02 PM PDT by Viking2002 (Liberals - destroyers of both men and civilizations. The Fourth Turning Cometh.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 381 | View Replies]

To: Orangedog; Iced Tea Party

Guys, there’s already a June Undead Thread.
Try real hard around the 30th, it might make the July playoffs.


383 posted on 06/05/2014 5:39:55 PM PDT by Darksheare (Try my coffee, first one's free..... Even robots will kill for it!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 343 | View Replies]

To: Darksheare

lol


384 posted on 06/05/2014 5:41:53 PM PDT by GeronL (Vote for Conservatives not for Republicans)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 383 | View Replies]

To: GeronL

They sure do seem to try competing for UT status once one has already been chosen.
:-/


385 posted on 06/05/2014 5:46:43 PM PDT by Darksheare (Try my coffee, first one's free..... Even robots will kill for it!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 384 | View Replies]

To: Orangedog
Just so we're clear, this post is me calling you a zotted sack o horse dumplins.
386 posted on 06/05/2014 5:49:57 PM PDT by Darksheare (Try my coffee, first one's free..... Even robots will kill for it!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 340 | View Replies]

To: Oliviaforever
Because then they can present themselves all over town as being married and they will be in our schools, neighborhoods, parks and workplaces and before you know it, gay marriage will be normalized and traditional marriage will marginalized.

Uh, apparently you haven't been paying attention, because we are in that situation RIGHT NOW. Shockingly, your silly government-issued pieces of paper didn't do anything to prevent it.

387 posted on 06/05/2014 5:57:39 PM PDT by Sloth (Rather than a lesser Evil, I voted for Goode.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 34 | View Replies]

To: KC_Lion; Viking2002

Bryan and I watched that episode of Game of Thrones. We buy each season as it is released. I really like the way Daenerys
Targaryen is always in control and serene when some slimy crook thinks he has the better of her and her dragons.

That would make a great ZOT post, but as Viking2002 pointed out, there may be copyright infringement.

The gif where Smaug is calling Bilbo a liar is a good one as well.


388 posted on 06/05/2014 6:21:36 PM PDT by TheOldLady
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 381 | View Replies]

To: TheOldLady; Viking2002
Well I don't want to get no one in trouble.

But I say when it comes to Gifs....... We Don't Ask, Don't Tell.

That Rule Still has to be good for something.

So you haven't seen Season 4 of Game of Thrones?

I have some Free HBO for a month for being a Dish Customer for (too long) so I set it up on my Play Station 3 to go back on HBO Go and re-watch them.

I refuse to Pay for HBO itself because of Bill Maher. But I still by the DVD sets :/

Daenerys Targaryen and her Posse is my Favorite, she would do the best job in Westeros out of them all.

But Tyrion is great and Jamie is becoming a good guy.

389 posted on 06/05/2014 6:29:16 PM PDT by KC_Lion (Build the America you want to live in at your address, and keep looking up.- Sarah Palin)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 388 | View Replies]

To: Viking2002

I know that your pet was not “just a turtle,” and it is sad to hear that Fred died so young.

Losing a pet, especially a sweet companion is very difficult, which I can say from my
own experiences with the deaths of pets.

RIP Fred. Viking2002 will see you at the Rainbow Bridge some day.


390 posted on 06/05/2014 6:29:42 PM PDT by TheOldLady
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 382 | View Replies]

To: KC_Lion

Ack! Spoilers! I’m sticking my fingers in my ears and singing, “La la, lul-lah lah!” ;-)

I like Tyrion a lot. Peter Dinklage is brilliant.

I’m really glad that Jamie is getting nicer, but I hear that he isn’t too polite to Cersci in the first ep. of next season.


391 posted on 06/05/2014 6:35:59 PM PDT by TheOldLady
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 389 | View Replies]

To: Viking2002

You have FReepmail. :)


392 posted on 06/05/2014 6:43:31 PM PDT by TheOldLady
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 382 | View Replies]

To: TheOldLady
I’m really glad that Jamie is getting nicer, but I hear that he isn’t too polite to Cersci in the first ep. of next season.

Jamie? Polite? HA! Ah HA HA HA!

.....no....

Please, if you didn't think that relationship was messed up already.....

Season 4 is really good so far :)

Although I still feel a little sorry for Grayjoy :(

393 posted on 06/05/2014 6:44:08 PM PDT by KC_Lion (Build the America you want to live in at your address, and keep looking up.- Sarah Palin)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 391 | View Replies]

To: KC_Lion

Goodness. Are they still torturing poor old Grayjoy?

Haven’t they done enough? He must be seventeen kinds of insane by now.


394 posted on 06/05/2014 6:45:47 PM PDT by TheOldLady
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 393 | View Replies]

To: TheOldLady
You don't know the half of it.

That plot point is much bigger than it seems.

Dany's Dragons are getting big though! Soon they may be as big a Smaug!

395 posted on 06/05/2014 6:48:36 PM PDT by KC_Lion (Build the America you want to live in at your address, and keep looking up.- Sarah Palin)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 394 | View Replies]

To: TheOldLady

Now THAT is one mad kitteh...as well he should be at such disrespectful posts! GRRRR!


396 posted on 06/05/2014 6:54:49 PM PDT by luvie (All my heroes wear camos! Thank you David, Michael, Chris Txradioguy, JJ, CMS, & ALL Vets, too!l)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 350 | View Replies]

To: LUV W

That is the dragon, Smaug, from The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug.

So... not a kitty. But we are the Viking Kitties, and the zottee is quite tasty this evening. ;-)


397 posted on 06/05/2014 6:59:19 PM PDT by TheOldLady
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 396 | View Replies]

To: TheOldLady

I miss all the fun. You’re getting a good day’s Internet exercise here, dear lady!


398 posted on 06/05/2014 8:21:29 PM PDT by Colonel_Flagg ("Compromise" means you've already decided you lost.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 350 | View Replies]

To: TheOldLady; Orangedog; All
'e just taking a ride (bareback) on the razor roller-
coaster..apt tenderizing for the kitties.

399 posted on 06/05/2014 9:52:50 PM PDT by skinkinthegrass (The end move in politics is always to pick up a gun..0'Bathhouse/"Rustler" Reid? d8-)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 350 | View Replies]

To: TheOldLady

My bad! Didn’t mean to insult a dragon! :)


400 posted on 06/05/2014 10:09:46 PM PDT by luvie (All my heroes wear camos! Thank you David, Michael, Chris Txradioguy, JJ, CMS, & ALL Vets, too!l)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 397 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 361-380381-400401-420421-426 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson