Posted on 08/25/2015 8:59:54 AM PDT by SJackson
If a senior US senator can so quickly become the target of a widespread campaign of anti-Semitism from both the Right and the Left, we should all increase our vigilance.
The social media site Twitter offers an extraordinary form of communication. But perhaps because of its scope and anonymity, it is also a hotbed of racism, bigotry and anti-Semitism. This has never been clearer than in the wake of Senator Chuck Schumer’s announcement that he will oppose President Barack Obama’s nuclear deal with Iran.
In doing so, Schumer became guilty of heresy in the eyes of many on the progressive Left and the isolationist Right. The former is now campaigning against Schumer’s ascension to Senate Minority Leader.
After reading an article mentioning the subject by writer Lee Smith, I waded into the cesspool created by the popular Twitter hashtag #Dump- Schumer. What I found was a deluge of anti-Semitic vitriol. By Saturday I had accumulated a collection of well over 100 tweets from both Left and Right attacking Schumer as a paid agent of Israel or AIPAC, a puppet of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and an outright traitor to the United States, loyal only to Judaism and the Jewish state.
Many in the #DumpSchumer ranks appear to believe that the senator is, as one tweeter put it, “an Israeli TRAITOR Jew.” Another proclaimed that Schumer is “a traitor to his own country which is the US NOT ISRAEL.” Another asserted, “Calling Schumer a traitor is just telling the truth. He’s not one of us – his only loyalty is to Jews.” Another echoed this, saying, “Schumer is only loyal to his tribe... certainly not to America.” Another was somewhat more subtle, declaring, “A senator is there to do the right thing for country [sic]. Question is which country is he thinking Abt?” Another asked, “Will the Senator From Israel Yield the Floor?” Another declared, “He’ll make even More $$$ as official #AIPACLobbyist.”
Another stated, “Schumer is doing the bidding of AIPAC.” Still another simply called the senator “The Israeli Manchurian candidate.”
Echoing rhetoric that has a distinctly dark provenance, other tweeters more or less advocated Schumer’s deportation to Israel.
One said so plainly. Another question, directed at Schumer himself, asked, “If you prefer ISRAEL over the USA? Why not move there?” There were also pieces of ostensibly more respectable provenance.
Journalist M. J. Rosenberg remarked, “It is sick that most Jewish members of Congress will decide on #irandeal based on Israel’s interests not US.” In more insidious fashion, Josh Marshall of Talking Points Memo asked, “So why did Schumer oppose the deal? I think he moves in circles, personal and financial, where this deal is simply anathema.”
One is left to wonder which “personal and financial” circles these might be. For many, the evil standing behind Schumer was clear: Netanyahu. One tweet referred to Schumer as “Bibi’s US Senator from Israel.”
Naturally, all of these tweeters refused to acknowledge even the possibility that they were engaging in anti-Semitic rhetoric. A picture making the rounds told Schumer, with breathtaking cognitive dissonance, “Calling out your allegiance to Israel ... is not anti-Semitism.”
Awakened by all this were more forthright characters. That is, neo-Nazis. Crawling out of the virtual woodwork, one proclaimed, with the concision of Conrad’s Kurtz, “Exterminate the parasite!” Another howled, “International Jews are the cancer of the earth! Sign this petition to arrest Netanyahu!” referring to a campaign to have the prime minister arrested for war crimes during an upcoming visit to Britain.
This is a small sample, but it is representative enough.
But the final tweet cited above did prompt an interesting realization.
Here was a proclamation of genocidal neo-Nazi racism coupled with an anti-Israel petition from the ostensibly anti-racist Left. It seems that politics is indeed circular; its extremes always converge in the end, especially when anti-Semitism is involved. There appears to be something in it that satisfies all emotional desires and answers all questions. Hence its great appeal to both sides of the political spectrum.
Indeed, during my exploration of the #DumpSchumer tweets, I was twice called a “kike” by neo-Nazis, and once a “semitic bigot” by a Leftist.
Now, it seems, these two sides have come together around the person of Senator Schumer.
Unfortunately, this convergence is not new. During last summer’s Gaza War, I was inundated with anti-Semitic statements from reactionary Muslims, Leftists, neo-Nazis and most everyone in between.
And lest we forget, this was merely a tiny symptom of a much larger and far more dangerous phenomenon.
Throughout Europe and elsewhere, there was an explosion of anti-Semitic rhetoric and physical violence.
This climaxed most famously in France, where a synagogue was attacked and a Jewish neighborhood trashed by rampaging mobs, followed by the Hyper Cacher massacre.
I have called this phenomenon the “Global Pogrom.” But thus far, it has mostly been a European pogrom.
In the United States, it is mostly confined to college campuses. If the anti-Semitism of the #DumpSchumer virtual mob indicates anything, however, it is that the pogrom is now centered on a specifically American issue: The Iran deal and its opponents.
This, in turn, demands that we entertain the possibility that the disease has now reached the United States, and is finally erupting into the public sphere.
If this is indeed the case, I think it very likely that this is only the tip of the iceberg. Certainly, if a senior US senator can so quickly become the target of a widespread campaign of anti-Semitism from both the Right and the Left, we should all increase our vigilance. The lights have gone out all over Europe. We must ensure that they remain lit in the United States.
If you’d like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
..................
Chuck should speak out on this issue. It's his party stifling debate with antisemitic outbursts. Of course they do that with race and sexual orientation as well. Bigotry of all sorts has found a political home.
Sad but true funny headline.
It’s not “from the right and the left”. It’s all from the Left.
Iran is a disgrace and our disgraceful, muslim pResident should be impeached for this and many other things he and his ilk have done to America....
Far left, Neo-Nazis...
To-MAY-to, to-MAH-to.
Author Ben Kerstein, please name one person from the 'isolationist Right'.
Exactly! The global socialists and the national socialists are both left wing movements not right-wing movements.
It always boggles me how American Jews can be liberals, when, to be blunt, the vitriol towards them in this group is palpable.
And more than a few Jewish people think the religious right that supports Israel is wacky, to be kind.
Israel is a true ally, the only one in the region, with, perhaps, the exception of Egypt under it’s new ruler.
The threat Israel faces from this horrific deal is the same we face. $100 billion dollars being dumped into the lap of people who would use the money to destroy Israel and us.
I would like to think Schumer took this position out of integrity and not because he knew the votes were already there to support obummer, the traitor and destroyer of America.
I pray American Jews give Trump or Cruz 40 percent of their vote.
They must see the incredible anti-semitism inherent in this president’s administration.
“Chuck should speak out on this issue. It’s his party stifling debate with antisemitic outbursts. Of course they do that with race and sexual orientation as well. Bigotry of all sorts has found a political home. “
He does need to speak out on this . This deal gives Iran the money to purchase the long range missiles they have been wanting . This endangers major U.S. cities ,Iran does not need these to nuke Israel. Iran has insisted in the past that they need to take out the big Satan (U.S.)first before they can take out the little Satan (Israel).
Thus what is good for Israel is also good for the U.S.
I have been watching twitter and the occupy movement is behind most of these talking points .
We have lost the culture war in this country to the extreme left (communist , socialist ) and the slightly right of left (facist ) both of which are much further left than the middle right view that was the norm for most Americans .
We are quickly inching our way to pre WW2 Germany where everyone was demonizing each other . I really really do not like the way the left is getting in bed with Islam , this is the same thing that happened in Germany .
Arming these Islamic countries is going to come back and bite us in the tush just like it always has .
When you see these thugs start to force the closure of bible believing Christians it is way past time to flee this nation .
Schumer isn’t worth the hostility. He only opposes the deal for political reasons and refuses to lobby against it with other Democrat senators. Plus it will probably pass anyway (which may be why he felt comfortable about opposing it).
Sadly, no. There are those on the right who blame Israel for our foreign policy problems and those who hate liberal Jews and shift this to Israel.
opposing this deal is about the first thing this schmuck Schumer has ever done right.
SCHUMER PULLS HEAD OUT OF @SS—LEFT AND OTHER NAZIS REVOLT!
Ron Paul? Pat Buchanan?
Neither is my idea of “right” but they are regarded as such.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.