I OC regularly. This is agitprop. There is no great disagreement within gun rights groups other than perhaps the type that go on over a watercooler.
That said, in my view CC is the best tactical choice, OC the best strategic choice. Both have their place.
I think the combination of open and concealed is the best possible option. Open carry reminds the idiots that there may be concealed carriers present.
Personally I’d get rid of the concealed carry permit altogether and let people carry as they choose.
I would agree with both your thoughts. This is a false narrative. Both OC and CC have their place.