Skip to comments.For illegal immigrants, new mobile ID service
Posted on 11/28/2002 2:33:59 PM PST by dennisw
from the November 29, 2002 edition
LINING UP: Armando Ortiz Rocha (l.), Mexican consul for North and South Carolina, looks over a deputy's shoulder as hundreds of Mexican immigrants wait for matricula consular IDs in West Columbia, S.C.
For illegal immigrants, new mobile ID service
Thriving beneath the radar and above the law, matricula consulars boost the privileges and status of illegal Mexicans.
| Special to The Christian Science MonitorWEST COLUMBIA, S.C. At El Rincon Vaquero trading post here in West Columbia, S.C., votive candles compete with cowboy hats and jars of dark mole for shelf space. The colorful shop is a slice of Mexico in the middle of a rundown neighborhood. But one day this month, El Rincon Vaquero became, through a bit of diplomatic magic, an actual outpost of Mexico.
In an aggressive - some say subversive - new gambit, the Mexican government is sending its deputies through the American countryside, setting up shop in strip malls and schools, and handing out new Mexican ID cards called matricula consulars for $29.
To the Mexicans and many of their US supporters, it's a way to get driver's licenses and other benefits. Some say it even helps US officials by keeping track of illegal immigrants. For local governments, the cards are a stopgap way to deal with growing Mexican communities.
But to critics, they're an attempt to legitimize illegal immigrants' presence, conferring the advantages of citizenship. It is, they say, a new blight on an immigration policy as tattered as an old piñata.
"This is like a ... creeping legalization," says Robert Leiken, director of the Immigration and National Security Program at Washington's Nixon Center.
On a recent Saturday, over 1,000 Mexicans arrive in busloads from across South Carolina, crowding into the back room at the El Rincon Vaquero, clutching paperwork and Spanish-language car magazines. Several hundred are turned away: There just aren't enough forms to go around.
Still, "At least for a day, this is Mexican territory," says Irma Santana, a Hispanic outreach worker here.
Legal, portable, and on the rise
The scene unfolds weekly from Illinois to Georgia, as schools and strip malls morph into consular safehouses where Mexicans can be "normalized" - if not naturalized - into the US. And despite the six patrol cars here in West Columbia, drawn by neighbors' complaints about the crowd, it's widely assumed that the INS is stretched too thin to attempt a raid.
"We're safe here, or else nobody would come," says Edren Saenz, a contractor from Greenville, S.C., who's teaching himself English by watching TV and skimming a dictionary nightly.
The mobile Mexican consul is so new that some INS officials haven't heard of it. Launched in 1999, it's picked up speed since 9/11. While State Department officials are dubious that the consul can technically establish Mexican soil in random US locations, nobody doubts the cards' legality: To the INS, handing them out is the right of any government.
"When it comes to the matricula cards, we don't have a dog in that fight," says Dan Kane, an INS spokesman in Washington.
Some insist it's the cards' open acceptance that's enabling the "subversion" of US law. A growing number of banks, for instance, welcome matriculas as a way to establish checking accounts - which makes it easy for relatives back in Mexico to access accounts through ATMs.
"If US interests weren't accepting these cards, nobody would be lining up to get them," says Steven Camarato, research director at the Center for Immigration Studies in Washington.
An alternative to amnesty
While legalization is not the Mexican consul's stated aim, some say it's the implicit goal. Plans for amnesty for several million US illegals - which Mexico President Vicente Fox had lobbied for before 9/11 - don't seem politically feasible at the moment. But many see matriculas as the next best thing. The mobile consulate is part of Mr. Fox's bold attempt to help Mexicans in the US - and tap into a lobbying network that's quietly changing attitudes toward illegal immigrants.
Though they contribute less than two percent to the GDP, illegal Mexicans prop up parts of the American economy. Many farmers, contractors, factory owners, and homeowners wink at their services, and matricula cards are evidence that such attitudes are spilling into American officialdom.
"The basic thing ... is an attempt by the Mexican government to try to be useful to its citizens in the United States, but in particular it's an attempt to be useful to those in the US illegally," says Mr. Camarato.
'This is about the safety of our citizens'
For Deputy Consul Carlos Isunza, the roadshow is a legal way to serve Mexicans - and one that has taken on new aspects since 9/11. It's also for safety: With cards in hand, Mexicans feel more comfortable about reporting crimes. "This is not about immigration," he says. "This is about the safety of our citizens." And states that allow Mexicans with matriculas to get drivers' licenses, for instance, may improve road safety.
But while few people see illegal Mexicans as a threat to national security, the ease with which they move through American society is a concern, says Mr. Leiken, author of "The Melting Border," a book about US-Mexican immigration.
"There is a security problem associated with having a large population of illegal immigrants, in that it creates a market for fraudulent documents," he says. "And we saw the result of that on 9/11, when some of the terrorists obtained their papers through Salvadoran illegals."
What's more, critics fear that the Mexican government's new practices in the US will open the door for other governments to take a larger role in the lives of expatriates living here illegally. Right now, the Guatemalan government is preparing its own version of the matricula consular.
"Next we may see the Chinese and Egyptian governments doing the same thing," says Mr. Camarato. "If you're a patsy, people beat up on you, and that's what's happening right now to the US."
How much are we going to pander to people who are breaking the law just by being here?
No mucho más largo. Ellos cambiarán la ley.
Ain't that the truth. The patriots that fought and died for the independence of this great Nation would be wondering why the hell they bothered, if they could see what was going on now.
Cuando? No puede ser pronto suficiente para mí.
Secret is suggesting the law be changed, so that the illegals are no longer considered illegal. That way they all remain within our borders legally and the pandering can continue forever.
Isn't that true, Secret?
I meant to convey that the illegals will gain enough power to change the law. I don't approve, but that looks like the trend.
Keeping track of illegal immigrants? I thought U.S. officials were supposed to round up illegal aliens and deport them.
That appears to be a pretty safe bet with the RINOs in the White House and in control of Congress.
This is TOO MUCH!!!
Think what ALL the immigrants that came to this country and entered thru Ellis Island must be thinking. This is not fair no matter how you look at it.
I don't have a need for a translator usually, but I'll flag you If i need to.
I think the Republicans will survive as a party, that is a party with the name "Republican", only by going along with the Democrats and conceding to them the morality of ever increasing government programs. Thus Republicans reiterate the sacredness of Social Security, government education, Medicare, and so on without end.
Apparently Republicans can't say anything about the illegals, unless Democrats give them permission.
Now let's take back the White House.
Flyover country!! Welcome to the government sponsored, immigration lunacy.
Just doin what his Rockefeller/Globali$t bo$$e$ tell him to do.
Here are our first demands:
Illegal Immigrants.... We Must Help Them!
Ban Privacy! Make All Privacy and All Clothing illegal!
I think so too ---I don't think they're used in Mexico for anything at all, it seems that Fox is trying to dictate our immigration policies, and he's trying to say he will decide who can and who can't come into the US by these cards. If illegals want to pay $29 for a useless card it's fine with me ---but that's all they should be here is useless. If banks wanted to accept the usual Mexican ID cards like their voter ID cards it's their business I guess ----but these cards seem to be all about something else. If I was an illegal, I wouldn't be giving out my address. It may be the Mexican government's way of trying to get control over it's citizens after they've left.
That only shows where there are Hispanics. That does not equate to "illegal alien." The majority of hispanics are legally here, productive memebers of society.
But, of course, xenophobia is an american tradition dating back to at least the 1850's with the Irish and the Italians. Seems to me that those groups turned out okay.