Is the Mass the Real Sacrifice of Christ?

In Plain Site ^ | Febuary 7 ,2015 | James G. McCarthy

[verga]

Do do that voodoo that you do so well.

Now who is talking like a pagan?

If you can't be either constructive or intelligent SHUT UP.

[CynicalBear]

Hit too close to home did I?

[verga]

Does it taste like bread and wine to you or flesh and blood? This was the “issue” Martin Luther had.

The accidents (taste, appearance, texture, etc ....) remain the same. The nature changes.

[DuncanWaring]

The "last Supper" was not ever a "sacrifice".. It was a passover meal...a memorial..

Makes perfect sense ... except for the part about "Take this and eat of it, for this is My Body.

[verga]

So once again the Catholics twist the words to mean something different.

You are wrong, the Jewish people believe that they are participating the actual event of the original Passover.

[verga]

More like prots want it to be.

[CynicalBear]

>>Makes perfect sense ... except for the part about "Take this and eat of it, for this is My Body.<<

And Ezekiel ate the physical scroll too right?

[CynicalBear]

You said to go to that site and ask. Sorry to dissapoint you and actually do it.

[verga]

The rebellion runs deep with some Protestants.<

Stupidity runs even deeper.

[verga]

Jesus is God incarnate, He is capable of doing it.

[BlueDragon]

Tape that to your own bathroom mirror.

Of course some explanation to the missus, like "that's not for you dear, that's to remind my own self, daily. You go ahead and talk to me whenever you so desire", would be necessary? Hmmm, and some form of tape which won't degrade, dry out and be difficult to remove, perhaps?

Just being helpful here, and constructively intelligent (in three paragraphs or less).

[verga]

Gave it the response it was due, actually twice as polite as it was due.

[verga]

You can make the claim all you want, now post the copy of the transcript that they sent you.

[verga]

I hope you have the integrity to tell CB exactly who gave me the idea of using that to settle matters.

[Roos_Girl]

I’m sorry, that doesn’t make sense to me with what I understand of Catholic belief that the wine and bread actually turning into the blood and body. But I appreciate you trying to explain. :)

[Lil Flower]

>>move on, folks.<<

Exactly! Why do so many Catholics allow these same handful of people to suck you in to these posts? It’s so obvious they are just looking for an argument and to antagonize. I’ve been foolish enough to be dragged into it too.

Please stop taking the bait. If you ignore these posts and don’t comment eventually they’ll stop posting them.

[Romulus]

Which unwritten apostolic traditions do you keep? Since you believe in the bible I’m sure you’ll agree unwritten tradition is vital and indispensable.

[CynicalBear]

>>I’m sure you’ll agree unwritten tradition is vital and indispensable.<<

To which "unwritten tradition" that the apostles taught do you refer? Oh, and please show proof that they taught them.

[Romulus]

All the ones referred to in the NT. I’m sure you know what I mean. Paul says keep them. Do you? You’re a bible believer, so I’m sure you believe in oral tradition. Right?

[BlueDragon]

I'm sure he already knows.

I notice that none of your cohorts came out of the woodwork to express objection the multiple times which you have used that, since.

What's holding them back?

Two sets of rules?

Meanwhile, previous to your own reaction to CB's mention of voodoo, he was "bringing something to the discussion" regardless of whether or not yourself, or anyone else (including myself) entirely agreed with him, or not.

Which would serve to show that CB had been operating under the conditional requirements of the "or else shut up", leaving your own usage of the "or else" to be superfluous.