“Is God eternal, or not?”
Is Jesus God or not?
“If so, he always was and existed before Mary.”
Did Mary give birth to Jesus or not?
“In fact, he created her in her mother’s womb. And she was born a sinner as we all are.”
Does that change the fact that Mary gave birth to Jesus?
“If Mary is the mother of God, then God is not eternal.”
That’s not a logical conclusion since someone could just as easily (and illogically) conclude Jesus is not God for God is eternal but Jesus died and what is eternal cannot die. See how illogical that is?
“She IS the mother of Jesus.”
Who is God. Thus, Mary is the mother of God.
Sounds logical...In a man's failed wisdom sort of way...But that logic only shows a person's ignorance of the rest of the scriptures that explain this operation which has been posted on this and numerous threads on FR in the past...