[ebb tide]

At first I thought you were a cafeteria catholic, by choosing which popes were right and which popes were wrong.

But I’ve now seen that you have admitted you are a sedevacancist.

Your denial of the dogma of EENS also makes one a material heretic.

[BlackElk]

Extra Ecclesia Nulla Salus. Vatican II apparently saw Ecclesia BEYOND the boundaries of the Roman Catholic Church (and presumably the Eastern Orthodox Church).

I have admitted no such thing.

So, I gather you regard John XXIII and Paul VI as right in whatever they did, including instigating Vatican II and approving its decrees. That must end the controversies. When will you parish institute its Novus Ordo Mass schedule? After all, you don't want to be choosing the right and wrong among popes.