Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Republicans Dismiss Daschle 'Proposal' on ANWR
townhall.com ^ | Oct.13,2001 | CNSNews

Posted on 10/13/2001 8:10:13 AM PDT by callisto

CNSNews.com) - Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle (D-S.D.) Friday introduced what he calls a "compromise proposal" to help end the legislative stalemate over whether to open the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) to oil drilling.~~

Daschle suggested that instead of drilling in the ANWR, a new natural gas pipeline be built running south from Alaska's North Slope. According to Daschle, the pipeline could be completed within six years, providing 400,000 new jobs.

It could be "one of the fastest ways that we could produce energy from Alaska," Daschle said, and would pose no danger to the environment.

Republicans, however, dismissed Daschle's plan.

Sen. Frank Murkowski (R-Alaska), ranking Republican on the Energy and Natural Resources Committee said, "An Alaskan natural gas pipeline isn't going to do anything to help reduce our dangerous dependence on foreign oil."

Murkowski added, "Senator Daschle needs to understand the difference between oil and gas."

Daschle earlier this week suspended action on the Senate's energy bill because, according to Republicans, it included ANWR drilling and was headed for committee passage.

Daschle later announced he would bypass the committee and bring the energy bill before the full Senate, but not before completing work on appropriations bills and legislation dealing with terrorism.


TOPICS: Government; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS:

1 posted on 10/13/2001 8:10:13 AM PDT by callisto
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: callisto
Daschle may be pleasing his liberal friends but they are all looking more and more foolish in this time of terror and need.
2 posted on 10/13/2001 8:14:52 AM PDT by Mind-numbed Robot
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: callisto
Republicans, however, dismissed Daschle's plan.

I'd say with Bush's popularity the repubs finally have the upper hand. They and Bush should stick to this, if they do they'll win it and Duschnozzle will only look like the foolish obstructionist he is, at a time when being one will be most frowned upon.

3 posted on 10/13/2001 8:16:46 AM PDT by liberalism=failure
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: callisto
Murkowski added, "Senator Daschle needs to understand the difference between oil and gas."

That may be asking too much, given that Dashole doesn't understand the difference between his a$$ and a whole in the ground.

4 posted on 10/13/2001 8:25:20 AM PDT by Freemyland
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: liberalism=failure
They and Bush should stick to this, if they do they'll win it and Duschnozzle will only look like the foolish obstructionist he is, at a time when being one will be most frowned upon.

Bush does not need to be or even appear to be partisan. He can just say at any TV opportunity that the US NEEDS Alaskan oil, that "congress" is having some trouble seeing the light, and that he hopes the American people will support him on this urgent matter.

GW could jazz up his remarks with a clintoonistic poll showing that some huge percentage of Americans support his position. Nah, I take that back; it would be beneath the dignity of the presidency to behave like some sort of lying backwoods jerkwater slob.

5 posted on 10/13/2001 8:30:44 AM PDT by hauerf
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: hauerf
You sir (or maam), in linking them with BJ Clinton, have defamed lying backwoods jerkwater slobs all across this great land.
6 posted on 10/13/2001 8:41:22 AM PDT by Freemyland
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: hauerf
And don't you EVER again suggest that Bush should use a Clintonistic tactic! Go to your room and think about what you've done for awhile before you return to FR! ;o)
7 posted on 10/13/2001 8:46:40 AM PDT by SW6906
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: callisto
ANWR drilling, in vast likelihood, won't do nuthin' to "hurt the environment" there. The worst thing we have to worry about is some fool shooting the pipe.
8 posted on 10/13/2001 8:47:43 AM PDT by HiTech RedNeck
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Freemyland
Murkowski added, "Senator Daschle needs to understand the difference between oil and gas."

That may be asking too much, given that Dashole doesn't understand the difference between his a$$ and a whole in the ground.
Audio

9 posted on 10/13/2001 8:59:36 AM PDT by hoot2
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

Comment #10 Removed by Moderator

To: SW6906
"And don't you EVER again suggest that Bush should use a Clintonistic tactic! Go to your room and think about what you've done for awhile before you return to FR! ;o)"

undo....undo....undo,quick
Audio

11 posted on 10/13/2001 9:07:58 AM PDT by hoot2
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Freemyland
I see that Dasshole's wife is not to dumb. As a lobbyist for the airlines she managed to get them 15 billion from all us stupid taxpayers.
12 posted on 10/13/2001 9:10:11 AM PDT by Piquaboy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: hauerf
Hey Bud...I live in the backwoods...does that make me a lying slob? I will await your reply.
13 posted on 10/13/2001 9:40:29 AM PDT by crz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: callisto
Dacschle is playing a cynical game of extreme Leftist politics

by shamelessly pandering to a radical-extremist, leftist,

enviro-Nazi, & Red-Green-Marxist agenda of the Marxist thugs

(which they letrally are to those of us who KNOW them!)

at the top who run Sierra Club and Greenpeace, and lead their brainwashed, ignorant, and uninformed members around by their noses.

As one who has been to the Alaskan North Slope (Prudhoe Bay) and who has also been to the Western Siberian oilfields in Russia, I hhave seen good, pristine environmental conditions in Alaska,

where the Caribou and Moose herds have nearly tripled(!) since oil developmnent started in Alaska,

and every INCH of the Tundra is protected through great care and expense

(huge balloon tires distrubte a vehicle's weight so that a large vehicle has less impact on the Tundra than the human footprint!);

in STARK contrast to ENVIRONMENTAL CRIMES of unimaginable depravity

(For example, an engineer torned to me while we were standing in a Western Siberian oilfield and said:

"Look around:

notice there's no signs of life:

not even birds!":

A chillingly true, but hardly unique, observation).

The eNazi, Leftist-Marxist-redistributionist so-called ersatz "Environmentalists" True & Real Agenda is:

1) To Abolish all private protperty, or at least as much as they can possibly get thier hands on;

2)To control or TAKE (through "Regulatory Takings", like zoning regs., aimed at severely limiting building and ALL other human protperty rights, limiting road and otehr access to one's own land, and limiting other, e.g., agricultural, grazing, and timber & mining uses), on both public and private U.S. lands; 3) To give increasing power to Central Planning by Federal (or State) Bureaucrats over both Public and Private lands, rather than vesting control & power with OWNERS of private property, whjo are clsoer to the land and have a greater vested interst in the Wise Use of thier own land (and often, have better resoure\ces than the Federal & Sate Goivt., which both through bad policy and lack of resources, neglects thier lands,a s is demonstrted by the W?estern U.S. Forest Fires the last two summers, & the Yelowstone travesty a few years ago; virtually ALL priovate landowners int he Western U.. must or should live in fear of Federal & State lands, mis-managed as they are being sources of fires which will/can/& have destroy(ed) not only the Federal/Public lands but also the neighboring Private land and building parcels.

4) Redistribution from American, the leading "HAVE" nation, to the Developing Naions, which are the Sources of far more pollution, generally, tahn is teh U.S. (China (PRC) has, according to the UN, 8 of the ten most polluted cities in the world(!)

I personaly, spent a month in four Provinces i Chinma; each day in each city I could feel my vitality decling from the coal-air poluution; for 9 days I lived at the exit confluence of the two giant Chiense Rivers: the Yellow and Yangzee Rivers in Shaghai, which emptied eventually into the Shanghai Harbor: They were putrid with criminally grossly negligent (of the environment) and carelessly dumped organic and inorganic waste from thousands of miles upstream): Communism/Marxism is the CAUSE of POLLUTION & Enviro-Crimes on a scale unrecorded and unknown before in History; Russia (the /Former Soviet Union, including its E. European Satellites adn the Fopremer Soviet Republics, like Kazakistan and the Ukraine, has destroyed air, land, water, (Inlcuding the Caspian Sea and major River systems) on a sacle comparable to its destruction of human life (50 million mrderd and starved, just like China/Mao who killed and starvbed 40-50 million people during hsi bloody and environmentally deatructive reigh\n of terror),

It is important to note that even in rapoidly developing capitialistic nations, such as Taiwan, Korea, much of Latin America, (e.g., Mexico City (worst air and air-borne sewer and car pollution in the world!)and Monterrey, Brazil, including Sao Paulo (my sister lived theer and developed boils/sores on her face from the pollution!) and the Amazon River Basin)

as well as Africa, India, Indonesia, those parts of the Middle East, where there is rapid industrial development, and and even Eastern (espedcaily massive gas leaks and air and water and agricultural pollution!) and Western Europe, which are FAR less environmentally-careful tahn the U.S.( I visited a waste treatmetn/water treament plant is England and was SHOCKED)>


What does all this have to do with Daschle?

He is implicityl siding with the Marxists and giving aid and comfort to the Terrorists by limiting the U.S.'s relaive energy indepencdence and has thus suboridngated American Naional & Economic Secrity cons\cerns and elevated our dependency on foreign-sourced oil & gas by siding with teh dis-information, lies and prob\pagamnda promulgated t\by the extreme Leftists e-Wackos and AGAINSTY the Untied States long-tem iterests.

Most of ALL, jhe has perper\tualted and accee\ded to the very succesful job of decades of brains\washing by the enviro-radicals through their massively successful propaganda and brain-washing campaign innn the Media and the Classroom, starting with pre-school and not ending with Graduat School.

It is the most successful use of the BIG LIE, unconctested and virtualy undefended by those who knew the TRUTH about the environment, to wit;

Free Markets and Private Property Ownership are the BEST and ultimately, the ONLY Protections of teh ENVIRONMENT; by contrast, Central Planning and public ownership result in envirim\nmental destruction on a grand scale. (Where "everybody" owns it, NOBODY cares for the land, teh water, the air, the environment).

Protection of 5th Amendment-protected Private Property Rights (against "Takings" "without just compensation"),and the Unalienable Rights to "Life, Liberty and Property" enunciated by Joh Lockke and inc\liuded by Jefferson in the first four drafts of the Declartation of Independence, whereupon he unwisely, in my humble but long-considred oinion, \substituited the more ambiguous Spinozan formulation (especially in this libertine-hedonsitic age): "life, liberty and 'the pursuit of Happiness.'"

P.S. There is an economic "information theory"/ feedback-loop reason,

(intimately related to the discipline that has just won three U.S. economists Nobel Prizes for Economics)

that I saw unwise practices in Siberian oil-fields versus environemtnally and economicalllly (& geologicaly) wise decisions and practices in teh Alaskan North Slope oil (& gas) fields:

1) Central Planners with "5 YEAR PLANS" who are 5 time zones from the fields that they abritrarily and ignorantly Command: I saw oil fiedl structures drilled in Phalanx fashion Miles off geologic structures because the Moscoew bosses and inflexible

"5 Year Plans"

in Marxist-Socialist-Leftist Totalitarian "Command Economies"

told them to do do, raher like some English generals senidn lambs to pointless and wasteful slaughter, theuy wsted humdreds of costly drii\llsites whic the men as ground zero had to knbw weren't propsective geologically;

2)Conversly, whemn the authority and responsibilty is dealt to the lower\st level and to those closest to the situation ("the "OWNERS", as it were), the BEST decisons tend to be made, as is the case int the Untied states where the

market discipline of

unforgiving (& ETERNAL)

"Competitive Justice", (

which provides immediate FEEDBACK each and every day),

Spontaneous Order

(the contemporary libertairian /classical (18th Century) liberal term for/ version of Adam Smith's famous "Invisible Hand",

consisting of the best collective outcome from a myriad dynamic of individual decisions made with enlightened self-interest every day),

the RULE OF LAW,

and corporate accountabilty tend to drive the best ECONOMIC and the best ENVIRONMENTAL decisions.

P.S. As every good farmer amd rancher knows:

A good conservative,

is one who "husbands" his land

and other scarce economic and intellectual resources given him with

"wise stewardship" and

"WISE USE";

a "Good Conservative"

is ALWAYS

a "GOOD CONSERVATIONIST."

14 posted on 10/13/2001 9:55:26 AM PDT by FReethesheeples
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: FReethesheeples
BUMP!
15 posted on 10/13/2001 9:59:24 AM PDT by AnnaZ
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: callisto
Spelling & corrected version (sorry about the numerous typos earlier!;

I wanted to first get my thoughts down, above ; these, obviously, represent YEARS of observation & thinking):

Dacschle is playing a cynical game of extreme Leftist politics

by shamelessly pandering to a radical-extremist, leftist, enviro-Nazi, & Red-Green-Marxist agenda of the Marxist thugs

(which they literally are to those of us who KNOW them!)

at the top who run Sierra Club and Greenpeace, and lead their brainwashed, ignorant, and uninformed members around by their noses.

As one who has been to the Alaskan North Slope (Prudhoe Bay)

and who has also been to the Western Siberian oilfields in Russia, (both cold weather drilling environemnts)

I have seen good, pristine environmental conditions in Alaska,

where the Caribou and Moose herds have nearly tripled(!) since oil development started in Alaska, and every INCH of the Tundra is protected through great care and expense

(huge balloon tires distribute a vehicle's weight so that a large vehicle has less impact on the Tundra than the human footprint!);

in STARK contrast to ENVIRONMENTAL CRIMES of unimaginable depravity

(For example, an engineer turned to me while we were standing in a Western Siberian oilfield and said:

"Look around:

notice there's no signs of life:

not even birds?(!)":

A chillingly true, but hardly unique, observation).

The nazi, Leftist-Marxist-redistributionist so-called ersatz "Environmentalists" True & Real Agenda is:

1) To Abolish all private property, or at least as much as they can possibly get their hands on;


2)To control or TAKE (through "Regulatory Takings", like zoning regulations., aimed at severely limiting building and ALL other human property rights, limiting road and other access to one's own land, and limiting other, e.g., agricultural, grazing, and timber & mining uses), on both public and private U.S. lands;


3) To give increasing power to Central Planning by Federal (or State) Bureaucrats over both Public and Private lands, rather than vesting control & power with OWNERS of private property, who are closer to the land and have a greater vested interest in the Wise Use of their own land (and often, have better resources than the Federal & Sate Government., which both through bad policy and lack of resources, neglects their lands, as is demonstrated by the Western U.S. Forest Fires the last two summers, & the Yellowstone travesty a few years ago; virtually ALL private landowners in he Western U.. must or should live in fear of Federal & State lands, miss-managed as they are being sources of fires which will/can/& have destroy(Ed) not only the Federal/Public lands but also the neighboring Private land and building parcels.

4) Redistribution from American, the leading "HAVE" nation, to the Developing Nations, which are the Sources of far more pollution, generally, than is the U.S. (China (PRC) has, according to the UN, 8 of the ten most polluted cities in the world(!)


I personally, spent a month in four Provinces in China (PRC); each day in each city I could feel my vitality decline from the coal-air pollution; for 9 days I lived at the exit confluence of the two giant Chinese Rivers: the Yellow and Yang’s Rivers in Shanghai, which emptied eventually into the Shanghai Harbor: They were putrid with criminally grossly negligent (of the environment) and carelessly dumped organic and inorganic waste from thousands of miles upstream): Communism/Marxism is the CAUSE of POLLUTION & Environ-Crimes on a scale unrecorded and unknown before in History; Russia (the /Former Soviet Union, including its E. European Satellites and the Former Soviet Republics (FSU), like Kazakhstan and the Ukraine, has destroyed air, land, water, (Including the Caspian Sea and major River systems) on a scale comparable to its destruction of human life (50 million murdered and starved, just like China/Mao who killed and starved 40-50 million people during his bloody and environmentally destructive reign of terror),


It is important to note that even in rapidly developing capitalistic nations, such as Taiwan, Korea, much of Latin America, (e.g., Mexico City (worst air and air-borne sewer and car pollution in the world!)and Monterrey, Brazil, including Sao Paulo (my sister lived there and developed boils/sores on her face from the pollution!) and the Amazon River Basin)


as well as Africa, India, Indonesia, those parts of the Middle East, where there is rapid industrial development, and even Eastern (especially massive gas leaks and air and water and agricultural pollution!) and Western Europe, which are FAR less environmentally-careful than the U.S.( I visited a waste treatment/water treatment plant is England and was SHOCKED).


What does all this have to do with Daschle?


He is implicitly siding with the Marxists radial leftist eNazi envor-wackos

--- and giving aid and comfort to the Terrorists in time of WAR---

by limiting the US’s relative energy independence and has thus subordinated American National & Economic Security concerns to teh AGenda of the envrio-Commies


and elevated our dependency on foreign-sourced oil & gas

by siding with, perpetuating and promoting the dis-information, lies and propaganda

promulgated by the extreme Leftists e-Wackos and AGAINST the United States long-tem interests.


Most of ALL, he has perpetuated and acceded to the very successful job of decades of brainwashing by the enviro-radicals through their massively successful propaganda and brain-washing campaign in and by the Media and in and in the Classroom, starting with pre-school and not ending with Graduate School.


It is the most successful use of the BIG LIE, uncontested and virtually undefended by those who knew the TRUTH about the environment, to wit:


Free Markets and Private Property Ownership are the BEST and ultimately, the ONLY Protections of the ENVIRONMENT; by contrast, Central Planning and public ownership result in environmental destruction on a grand scale.


(Where "everybody" owns it, NOBODY cares for the land, the water, the air, the environment).

Protection of 5th Amendment-protected Private Property Rights (against "Takings" "without just compensation"),and the Unalienable Rights to "Life, Liberty and Property" enunciated by John Locke and included by Jefferson in the first four drafts of the Declaration of Independence, whereupon he unwisely, in my humble but long-considered opinion, \substituted the more ambiguous Spinozan formulation (especially in this libertine-hedonistic age): "life, liberty and 'the pursuit of Happiness.'" P.S. There is an economic "information theory"/ feedback-loop reason,

(intimately related to the discipline that has just won three U.S. economists Nobel Prizes for Economics)

that I saw unwise practices in Siberian oil-fields versus environmentally and economically (& geologically) wise decisions and practices in the Alaskan North Slope oil (& gas) fields:

1) Central Planners with "5 YEAR PLANS" who are 5 time zones from the fields that they arbitrarily and ignorantly Command: I saw oil field structures drilled in Phalanx fashion Miles off geologic structures because the Moscow bosses and inflexible

"5 Year Plans"

in Marxist-Socialist-Leftist Totalitarian "Command Economies"

told them to do,

rather like some English generals sending lambs to pointless and wasteful slaughter,

they wasted hundreds of costly drill-sites which the men as ground zero had to know weren't prospective geologically;

2)Conversely, when the authority and responsibility is dealt to the lowest level and to those closest to the situation

("the "OWNERS", as it were),

the BEST decisions tend to be made,

as is the case in the United states where the

market discipline of

unforgiving (& ETERNAL)

"Competitive Justice",

( which provides immediate FEEDBACK each and every day),

Spontaneous Order

(the contemporary libertarian /classical (18th Century) liberal term for/ version of Adam Smith's famous "Invisible Hand",

consisting of the best collective outcome from a myriad dynamic of individual decisions made with enlightened self-interest every day),

the RULE OF LAW,

and corporate accountability tend to drive the best ECONOMIC and the best ENVIRONMENTAL decisions.

P.S. As every good farmer and rancher knows:

A good conservative,

is one who "husbands" his land

and other scarce economic and intellectual resources given him with

"wise stewardship" and

"WISE USE";

a "Good Conservative"

is ALWAYS

a "GOOD CONSERVATIONIST."

16 posted on 10/13/2001 10:28:00 AM PDT by FReethesheeples
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: FReethesheeples
Is the new format screwing with my Netscape or are you purposely putting in a paragraph break every other word?
17 posted on 10/13/2001 1:02:52 PM PDT by hattend
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: callisto

DRILL!


18 posted on 10/13/2001 1:06:07 PM PDT by ChadGore
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: hattend
Sorry, its the latter, not the new formating, its me, I'm afraid; some of the sentences are filled with too many concepts or need to be broken into separate shorter sentences, i.e., I am spacing in the interest of time instead of re-editing complex sentences into short sentences.

These involve related & linked concepts in my post, which have been bouncing around in my thoughts for years, but I was anxious to get them down in one place.

So, thanks for being a "guinea pig."

It'll get refined, maybe.

Maybe I need a good editor.

FReegards,

19 posted on 10/13/2001 1:17:14 PM PDT by FReethesheeples
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: callisto
Murkowski added, "Senator Daschle needs to understand the difference between oil and gas."

AAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!

20 posted on 10/13/2001 1:28:36 PM PDT by Dan Day
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson