[rosenfan]

Geez. What is wrong with people? Instead of harming Thornhill's credibility, he has damaged his own (if you are in fact correct.) Thanks.

If I had said he was associated with Scientology, you'd be correct.

Since I didn't, you're not.

[BillCompton]

If I had said he was associated with Scientology, you'd be correct.

Since I didn't, you're not.

Well, I did not read your entire reply. When an Obama supporter posts on FreeRepublic...

How is the above different than when you wrote:
I did not read the entire article. When a Scientologist...

At the very least you left the association dangling to the extent that I could not tell whether you were making the association or not.