Posted on 09/20/2010 9:04:11 AM PDT by AccuracyAcademia
Teach for America, the creation of yesterdays Left, is becoming the bete noire of todays.
When it was created, free marketers questioned the value of paying volunteers. Meanwhile, conservatives argued that yet another federal program would give the political Left one more redoubt than the many it already had.
Audits of the program showed that their fears were not irrational. Nevertheless, a funny thing happened on the way to the millennium.
Genuine reformers, such as Washington, D. C. chancellor Michelle Rhee emerged from the program. Moreover, a staple of the modern American political Left, teachers unions, began to view the young TFA trainees with their comparatively modest federal stipends as low-wage competition.
Thus, the stage is set for an odd face-off. Increasingly, however, critics say, the programs good intentions are overpowered by its problems, Kristi Eaton writes in the Summer 2010 issue of Campus Progress magazine. According to some TFA alums, the organization often seems less like a shining example and more like a way for school districts to replace experienced, more expensive teachers with people who will work for far less, most of whom end up leaving after their two-year commitment is up.
Eaton points to a 43 percent retention rate among TFA alums found by the Harvard Graduate school of Education. But the Harvard study that she cites actually found that statistic to be 61 percent, and TFAs three-year retention rate for high-poverty schools exceeds that of non-TFA teachers, Chris Myers Asch of the University of the District of Columbia claims in a response which the magazine printed. Furthermore, because they ignore the alumni 9including myself) who leave the classroom but stay in education, discussing classroom retention rates when discussing TFA is a bit myopic.
Nearly two-thirds of all TFA alumni from the past 20 years work full-time
(Excerpt) Read more at academia.org ...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.