Or, of course, one of them could stand partway in a hole in the ground: http://being.publicradio.org/programs/whalesongs/images/ss_kneeling.jpg
In Randolph the guy lived there. The woman had clearly moved out and had, in fact, GONE TO CANADA.
If you want to apply this case to the situation in Indiana note that the woman lived there and the guy had got his stuff and moved out!
The USSC ruled in favor of the occupant who lived there ALONE ~ as would they rule in favor of the woman in this case because she lived there ALONE.