I could fall for the Elephant Man or the Hunchback if I got to know him...if I got to know his soul some and found it to be decent and deep and I felt a connection. So I’m not sure how good this test is. What if these same women were presented with these less than attractive men, but got to know them on a deeper level? Pictures are one thing. We all have things that attract us physically. But this is only one aspect of attraction. It’s not complete, IMO.
You are thinking like someone who plans a lifetime with someone.
Today’s hookup culture snowflakes (who demand somebody else pay for their birthcontrol) just want a few orgasms and for someone to pay for some meals. They might stay with one guy for a few years (until they pay off their car) if he isn’t too boring.
Different goals and expectations. Even in the Church often enough.