5 1975 My Eyes Adored You Frankie Valli
(Tough call because I liked both songs. I think this one has aged better, plus this one reminds me of the girl I had a hopeless crush on about the time this came out.)
1 1976 Silly Love Songs Wings
Half a vote for this song, half a vote against the other.
I never heard that song quite the same way after Rush Limbaugh's "My Hands Explored You" version.