Posted on 03/18/2019 5:51:32 AM PDT by reaganaut1
About a year ago, Princeton philosopher Robert P. George came to Chapel Hill, North Carolina to speak about civil discourse and diversity of thought with the UNC system Board of Governors. He returned on February 8, but this time he came with Cornel West, a long-time friend and philosopher at Harvard University, as guest speakers for Duke University’s Kenan Distinguished Lecture in Ethics.
Instead of directing their message to policymakers, George and West came to speak face-to-face with students, faculty, and local citizens. The two spoke about how they navigate their vastly different political views while maintaining a strong friendship, a skill seemingly rare on most college campuses. Their message and example isn’t just a much-needed antidote to an increasingly polarized culture, either. It also contains an essential ingredient for what George and West call a “deep education:” the desire to be challenged in one’s most fundamental beliefs.
Indeed, George and West argue that students can’t receive an authentically “deep” or “liberal” education unless they look for opportunities to be “challenged and unsettled.” So, even though their talk touched on the importance of courteously engaging with one’s intellectual opponents, the heart of their message went beyond mere platitudes to the importance of civil discourse. In their view, civil discourse is much more than politeness or putting up with others’ opinions. Far from simply tolerating those who challenge one’s beliefs, George and West insist that they should be considered one’s “truest friends.”
Why? Because actively engaging with an ideological opponent refines one’s own understanding of an issue and can lead one closer to the central goal of all education: the pursuit of truth.
(Excerpt) Read more at jamesgmartin.center ...
The Romans and the Greeks knew that knowing the mind of your opponent in any endeavor was the key to success.
So the Democrat thugs who run most universities will now allow a controlled discussion of the level of brutal violence required to destroy the Western freedom and Christianity and replace it with global oppressive socialism.
After all, violent oppression has many options.
This “triggered snowflake” college generation cannot even take comefians who ARE MORE LEFTY THAN THEY ARE.
There is no college comedian circuit any more.
This generation cannot handle discorse nor discussion (much less debate). It can only handle confirmation of its narrow left orthodoxy.
I wonder how open Professor West would be to students being challenged about their beliefs about Leftist doctrine?
Kinda like with my ex-wife. I told her one time, before we divorced, that I was the only one who loved her enough to tell her the truth. Later she figured out I was right . . . after she re-married . . . but her level of respect for me has increased exponentially in the last couple of years. . . bittersweet development.
Thank you for posting this. I’ve put it into my own bookmarks. I have often wondered about the Cornell West /Bobby George alliance, and this restores my already-great respect for Prof. George and even compels me (if warily!) to respect West.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.