Trailer parks are notorious for failing to ask that question to potential park managers.......Why? I don't know.....
Well D appears to be the general consensus... and what I got too! It was not that difficult, but I had to re-write it as a greater than/less than math problem to visualize it.
I have to say, http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/3787984/posts?page=16#16 and http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/3787984/posts?page=17#17 tie for the win on this thread... My wife and I were rolling on the floor after reading both of your comments!
My friend could not figure it out, then I told him the answer and he argued with me for 20 minutes... so I sent him this -
A) Gives No Help - The Juice is smaller than the Tea.
B) FALSE, Not Possible - This directly contradicts original given fact #3.
C) Gives No Help - Milk is the smallest, by given facts.
D) This Proves the Tea is the bigger bottle, because Milk was already the smallest of the 4.
E) Gives No Help in Proving it alone - by all given facts Water is largest bottle, so while E is a true statement, it does not prove the question without knowing D also.
Bottle sizes are as follows -
WATER > TEA > JUICE > MILK > OIL