Vazquez ruled in early 2018 that the DNC had not shown a violation of the consent decree and that the consent decree was expired as of 2017, as it was written.
The DirtyDems appealed the new Vazquez ruling to the Third Circuit [the prize they were going for was an extension of the consent decree for ANOTHER eight years - till 2025].
It was a Dubya judge and a Grabby Poppy judge, along with an Obama judge, that turned the DNC down flat in 2019:
Thank you so much for the updated research!!!