I watched Dr Who from the very beginning, but my favourite Doctor was Jon Pertwee - the third actor to play the part. So, not everyone prefers their first one. I also liked Paul McGann in the 1990's movie.
It's a situation similar to when your best friend becomes Hall Monitor in 3rd grade and writes you up for walkingtoo fast. Some people cannot handle power or authority. Oh well.
Your selection is highly unusual. The BBC has lengthy public opinion polls on the matter.