I agree with you, DR. Unless space aliens were involved, there is no good reason to keep this classified. That would be an abuse of the classification system and result in less respect for the overall secrecy protection of the US.
I agree with both of you, but...where does one draw the line? This seems remote and rather harmless, but when is it okay and who decides? If a Vietnam Vet decides to disclose something is that okay?
How about Desert Storm?
The problem I have with disclosure of classified material is...who decides, and are there any guidelines, or do we leave it up to the individual to decide?
Again, this seems pretty harmless to me. What are the Chicoms going to do, go after us because we broke the Yalu River understanding?