“Ingredients for life” is one thing; life is something else.
Yes pretty dum. It is like saying steam is at the origin of the life of the steam engine.... doh!
. Both organics and inorganics make life... although the reference of the return to the inorganic dust means death...
Yeah, ok, but it also was from dust to dust. So basically minerals are also at the origin of life. The organic is allowing the thermodynamics and metabolics of it.