I don’t think anybody can replace Eisenhower, so I consider Trump to be the second greatest President of our time.
That’s not a slag against Trump. Eisenhower was simply on par with George Washington in terms of greatness.
Eisenhower didn’t get the problem with big, unconstitutional government. He left office with taxes up to 91%. That certainly doesn’t make him a great President.
Trump was/is the best President for our time. How he would have done during other key points in our history, one can only speculate. For all I know, he might have been a real disappointment if he had been President during the Civil War era or during other crises in our history. But he was born for this time in history to fulfill a historic purpose.