Posted on 07/27/2023 8:18:39 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
Last summer, World Aquatics, the group that oversees most international swimming competitions, angered the trans community when they changed their rules to bar most male athletes from competing against women unless they had “transitioned” prior to the age of 12. It was one of the most sensible moves we’ve seen throughout this entire debate, but they were hit with the usual charges of transphobia, hate speech, and all the rest. It appears that they were not entirely insensitive to the complaints and they have been working since then to formulate a new compromise. This week, the group’s president announced that they have come up with what they see as a solution. They propose to add a third category of competitions beyond the men’s and women’s races and it will be open to “other” (trans) athletes and essentially anyone who can win the qualifying races. (AP)
Swimming will set up an “open category” that will include transgender competitors, the governing body of the sport said Tuesday.
World Aquatics president Husain Al-Musallam said the event would take place in the future among other races but gave no details. Reports suggest it could be this year.
“This is a very complex topic,” Al-Musallam said at the World Aquatics Congress in the southwestern Japanese city of Fukuoka. “But I am delighted to tell you today that we are now making plans for the first trial of an open category, and we hope to be able to confirm all the details soon.”
This is pretty big because World Aquatics sets the rules for some of the biggest competitions, including the Olympics and other world championships. (They have no control over the NCAA, however.) The first event with the third “other” category may take place as soon as this summer or fall.
This doesn’t seem like an unreasonable compromise and it’s not drawing absolute lines in the sand. Others have previously suggested having separate competitions specifically for trans athletes, but the idea hasn’t drawn much support from trans activists. There also probably aren’t enough trans athletes in each sport to fill out a reasonably sized field. But if you open it to everyone, you might draw some additional non-trans athletes who think they won’t do well enough in the main events but would be willing to give it a go in the trans races.
Such a third category might also produce the unintended consequence of answering another question that has surrounded this debate. The category won’t just be for men “identifying” as women. It will include trans men (women) as well. We’ve been asking here for some time now where all of the women transitioning to men and kicking the actual men’s butts are. Will they show up to compete in this category, and how will they fare if they do?
In any event, if you’ll forgive my lack of optimism, I’m not expecting the reaction to this news from the aforementioned trans activists to be positive. None of this gender-bending in sports or in schools has ever had anything to do with fairness, equality, or opportunity. It’s always been about shoving this in everyone else’s faces, forcing people to change their language, and bullying their way into private spaces, particularly those traditionally reserved for women.
These athletes like Lia Thomas aren’t fighting to compete in women’s sports because they need to prove that they’re “real women.” They’re seeking an advantage over competitors without the same inherent biological advantages because they weren’t able to reach the highest levels against other actual men. And in his case he was spectacularly successful, going from being a guy who almost never qualified for the finals to a “female swimmer” who hoisted some championship trophies. And in the process, he robbed plenty of actual women of potential opportunities. Perhaps World Aquatics is on to something here and we might be able to put this annoying debate to rest once and for all.
Freaks might be a better term, but regardless, they do have to be careful to make sure it’s not too ‘open’, as they’ll wind up with REAL MEN competing against Fake Women and Fake Men, and not much would be solved.
Go ahead. But the sports will most likely be dominated by men pretending to be women if there are any women pretending to be men in it at all.
Can’t wait for trannies to wreck dyke anti American soccer.
Have they solved the problem?
There’s an easy solution, but that solution violates political correctness and offends the sensibilities of the activists who push this on us.
That solution would be, biological males compete against biological males, and biological females compete against other biological females.
But we aren’t allowed to use such criteria anymore, because to do so, offends the sensibilities of the activists.
And the highest priority nowadays, is placating the activists who will claim these sports organizations are being transphobic and not inclusive, etc.
“Open”
Are women forbidden from competing in men’s events?
I never thought of that. That would be beyond glorious. I honestly wonder how the liberals would comment on that one.
High school boys soccer teams have already wrecked womens top pro soccer teams. Beat them handily.
True. I’d just like to see the dykes sit as benchwarmers or don’t make the team as the trannies dominate the field.
To be honest, they know the deal that men, high schoolers, men in their 60s, beat them handily. They arent going to go onto those teams and be embarrassed.
Trans competitions will become like the WNBA...it’s there, but no one watches.
The “open category” will get legal action stated against them! Why? Because this is not about swimming!
Time for another Civil War this time against the woke. Time they were slapped truly awake.
Maybe if they gave style points for flamboyance.
A “trans” or “open” category is a form of surrender not accommodation. Two sexes, two categories.
‘unless they had “transitioned” prior to the age of 12’
It means more “mommies” will mutilate their sons earlier.
Why not have the category as ‘Mentally ill’ instead of other. I mean, I could train a dolphin and it could win..🤓
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.