Posted on 04/19/2004 5:53:28 AM PDT by OESY
Edited on 05/26/2004 5:20:43 PM PDT by Jim Robinson. [history]
The American intelligence community is quickly becoming a dinosaur. It has to stop fighting the Cold War and transform itself to combat new security challenges, such as terrorism, weapons of mass destruction and rogue states - now. Just last week, the 9/11 Commission expressed serious concern about the intelligence community - the IC, as we say in the biz. Members are even thinking about issuing IC-reform recommendations before completing their final report. The commission's early work has raised major doubts about IC leadership, cooperation, communications and information-sharing.
(Excerpt) Read more at nypost.com ...
Second, for someone who claims to have served with the CIA, DIA and Naval Intelligence, Brookes displays a profound lack of appreciation for the nature of national intelligence and the need for internal debate regarding credibility of sources and methods, likely patterns and scenarios, etc., as part of the evaluation process.
Third, introducing a new layer of management, in all due respect to Brookes, is not the way to reduce bloated bureaucracies and eliminate turf battles. It merely places one person in the position of chief lightning rod who will be fired immediately whenever the pundits call for it -- a "feel-good solution" with no merit in terms of strengthening national security. On the contrary, it guarantees a homogenized politically correct view of the world by a new official nervous about keeping his job.
Fourth, if there is anything wrong with Tenet's statement that it could take five years to rebuild an effective spy network, it is that it may be too optimistic. Brookes reveals little appreciation of how destructive a combination of agency turncoats and Congressional meddling have had in decimating our human intelligence capabilities and the time and effort needed to recruit reliable sources on the ground.
Fifth, if Brookes thinks that a new intelligence director is the key to "preventing" another 9/11, he is dangerously delusional. Intelligence is not a science where you discover the right formula and it solves all your problems. That is far too simplistic a view coming from someone at the Heritage Foundation. Good intelligence, properly shared, can lower the risk of future attacks, but that depends on the renewal of the Patriot Act, destruction of "The Gorelick Wall" between intelligence agencies and law enforcement functions, and active involvement of the military, Treasury, our allies and others to find and destroy terrorists wherever they are.
I lost all confidence in Mr. Brooks, in spite of his background, when he fails to include China in the threat category.
The phrase of the day. Henceforth I shall refer to the "Heightened Gorelick Wall" in all discussions of 9/11 causes, the commission, etc. Congratulations on introducing a powerfully descriptive image into the debate.
According to Osama bin Laden's latest tape, his terrorist road show is now headed to a theater near you.
An excellent description of the real root causes of 9-11.
I wish this would become the descritive phrase for the talking heads and microphones of the media. Hey Sean, Bill and Hugh, try this Banner !
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.